Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

Posts

WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#1

WOW!!  Scary, Scary!!

Dick Wilson

I haven't been on YouTube in a month or so. Last night I got into the wood turning videos and started watching some of them. I came across one where the guy was going to turn a tree crotch bowl/vessel. He put this chunk of wood between centers so the pith was spinning perpendicular to the lathe bed. The limb section looked to be 4-5" in diameter and stuck out a good 6" past any of the other wood. Obviously, it was way out of round, which didn't deter him from cranking up the speed past the serious vibration that would move the lathe across the floor. Now the lathe only vibrated. He sit up the tool rest and turned on the lathe. To my astonishment he picked up "his favorite tool" - THE ROUGHING GOUGE!!! My jaw dropped and I broke out in goose bumps. I sat there watching in amazement as he turned the ENTIRE branch away. Guess he never heard of a chain saw. All I can say is I pray to God that beginner turners don't see this video and think this is the way to do things. That exercise is a nightmare waiting to happen.

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: WOW!!  Scary, Scary!!

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

You only make that mistake once.........

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#3

I've seen lots of scary stuff like that ......

JamieDonaldson

..posted on YouTube. I don't understand any reasoning other than an ego trip for posting such stuff, but there is no proficiency or safety check required beforehand. Must go back to a variation of Descartes statement, "I post, therefore I am" an expert! :b

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#4

Brad Vietje

Link?

Brad Vietje

Dick,

Any way you could find and post the link?

I've seen all manner of stoooopid turning on You Tube, so no great surprise. Maybe with the link we can jump all over the guy, and save a few newbies...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#5

Re: Link?

Dick Wilson

Here you go Brad. I doubt very seriously if contacting him or whoever would do any good. Moron is as moron does.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiZXc5TbPHA

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#6

Re: Link?

Terry Scott

Removed by the user it says

It wasn't me honest

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#7

I wonder

Stuart Johnson

I wonder if this might not have been a case of someone not knowing how dangerous it was working the way he did. Or, was he thin skinned and wasn't going to take kindly to any negative posts. There have been a couple of posts on other threads by turners that use their roughing gouges and swear they do it safely and don't worry about the weak tang.

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#8

Re: Link?

Dick Wilson

Terry, This is an example of what can be accomplished if enough people pitch a bitch. There were a half dozen or more comments about this video. They were all very negative about his turning technique (including myself). I even reported to YouTube that this video had the potential of being harmful/dangerous. When it says that the video has been pulled by the user I don't know if that means the guy who posted the video pulled it or someone at YouTube posted it.

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#9

Re: I wonder

Dick Wilson

Stuart, Those guys can state that they do it safely all they want........until they get a catch, the tang breaks, and they end up sticking "their favorite tool" into some body part. I think this guy was a beginner. I looked at Part 4 of his little "instructional" and let me tell you, he was not an experienced turner.

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Link?

keith tompkins

Me neither, Terry. At least I don't think so :)

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#11

Re: Link?

barry Ward

I missed this one,but have seen several of these videos on you tube that should have been removed,anybody remember the one about the Idiot that started the motor on the table saw with an old innertube,he has a few of them going around.I agree with what has been said before,that someone just starting out and doesn't know much about woodworking tools could get hurt or even killed trying to do what these idiots do.

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#12

Bob

Re: WOW!!  Scary, Scary!!

Bob

Dick, I 'm very glad you brought this up. I didn't see this one but several others have amazed me with their unsafe practices. It's good to get the word out to newer woodworkers that not everything they see on the internet has a solid foundation. Bob.

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#13

Brad Vietje

Got This Reply From Bertminator:

Brad Vietje

I not only commented on the YouTube page, but wrote to the fellow directly with what I thought was an encouraging and supportive note about sharing his passion for turning wood, but warning him about what could happen if newbies followed his lead. Got this reply in my in-box this AM:

Bertminator has sent you a message:

Woodturning video

To: PM3520

Ok, I removed the videos. Next time try to be kinder with your comments. I appreciate the advice, and I will change my methods, but frankly, you guys were kinof nasty. Fair enough?

Regards,

So, for once our efforts actually accomplished something. I may have offended the fellow, but I'd rather he take offense than have someone get hurt trying these dangerous acts at home. With any luck, this fellow will be posting much better videos in the future, after learning to do it right himself.

Score one for the good guys! 8)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#14

Re: Got This Reply From Bertminator:

Stuart Johnson

Did you follow and and invite him to join in here on WC?

Re: WOW!! Scary, Scary!!

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: Got This Reply From Bertminator:

Brad Vietje

Great idea, Stuart.

Haven't, but will do. Thanks.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT