I like what you are trying to do, although I am not in love with that particular box. I'd probably like it a lot more if it somehow had a detent in the bottom of the box and it could spin on the entire finial without being disassembled. A fine bit of work to balance it, but it would give you the effect without appearing contrived...
I found images and descriptions of Siegfried Schreiber's kinetic works a while back. He has a wonderful sense of aesthetic and it shows in his pieces.
I'm too impatient and too easily distracted to take an idea much passed a proof of . Maybe someone else will use the idea in a more aesthetic piece.
You're idea of having the whole lidded box spin is interesting - and this piece could easily be modified to do that. Turn a small concavity in the bottom of the box's tenon and glue in a small ball bearing. I'd have to tighten up the lid fit - it's fairly loose so it can be removed with one hand. It might be interesting to have
the piece have two movement modes. I may give it a try.
Even if the piece were perfectly balanced, any force applied to get it to spin - that wasn't in the horizontal plane of rotation would tilt the piece - and likely knock it off its "pedistal".
A semi-snug hole for the round tenon to fit in would resist knocking off forces - but would add friction. That would reduce the "spin-ability" of the piece. Hence - The Bearing.
As is usually the case, design criteria often constrain the possibilities. In this case, the bearing criteria dictated the top of the finial's minimum size to a less than aesthetically pleasing diameter - making for a not very elegant finial.
If I do another version of this spinning winged box I'll replace the box's bottom round tenon with a hard "oily wood" - rosewood, maybe ebony or even Tagua Nut. The finial on this piece is pink ivory and it's a pretty hard semi-oily wood so I'd likely use it again.
I tend to come up with an idea and then make it out of whatever wood is laying around that's big enough to use. I had a piece of Santos Mahogany that was big enough for the box, some claro walnut big enough for the lid and a piece of pink ivory that was long enough. If I'd had some maple that would have worked I'd have done the whole piece in maple. That would leave me the option of coloring it anyway I wanted. I've got to work on taking the time to select the right wood for an idea and wait 'til I have it before doing the turning. I'm not real good at patience - so . . .
Lots of what we do is a trade-off. Sacrificing wood for form. Bearing for balance. Form for balance.
I think that it is an interesting experiment, but the addition of the bearing cause you to make a finial that you aren't happy with. It also made that odd nub on the bottom of the box so you could get the box to seat and spin. You had one positive, 2 negatives... -1 overall...
Not trying to dissuade you from anything, merely suggesting a potentially different path to travel...
For those who did not like the box bottom nub you could have recessed the bearing in the bottom of the box and then made your finial thinner to fit the bearing inside bore.
But what the heck, there is always someone that can suggest things after the fact, when it's not their original idea.
The finial? I can fix that by turning a more compatible "cap"
The tenon on the bottom could be made shorter - and a small pearl put on its bottom.
As for suggestions for improving the piece- THAT is one of the benefits of WC - other eyes and other minds seeing things and possibilities I missed. Thanks Steve for the constructive criticism - and suggestions.