bevel rubbing a scaper
John Lucas
I know we preach that you should not rub the bevel of a scraper and always keep the handle higher than the cutting edge. Well I did a test the other day to see using a round nose scraper and a spindle gouge of the same size to see what the differences were. The scraper I used and the spindle gouge both had 45 degree bevel angles.
I cut coves. I ran the scrapers with and without a burr and shear scraped with the burr.
The scraper with no burr worked just fine rubbing the bevel but of course it did not give as clean a cut as the spindle gouge. I think this was because of the curved edge of the spindle gouge. You are sort of making a slicing cut as you go from high point to low point on a cove. The scraper with burr used in a shear cut going from high to low gave the second best cut.
Rubbing the bevel of the scraper made it catch prone just like a spindle gouge would be if you come off the bevel. It cut cleaner without the burr.
The scraper held flat on the rest was the least likely to catch and did cut cleaner with the burr. The Burr last a very short while and has to be refreshed often. This was the poorest quality of cut of the 4 things tested however when starting the cove you had almost no kick back problems. With bevel rubbing tools you have to pay attention when starting a cove so you don't get a kickback.
With the scraper held flat it was extremely difficult to get a fine point where 2 coves come together. It simply tears the fibers. The bevel rubbing scraper held flat did the same. With a scraper used in shear scrape mode I was able to get a fairly good point but it took a very light cut. With the spindle gouge I could get a point that was sharp enough to cut you, very easily and quickly.
So what did this prove. It proved that you can rub the bevel of a scraper. Why I don't know because a spindle gouge will do a better job and you still have the catch problems if you come off the bevel. If your scraper is ground blunt like many people do then it will do a much worse job on the finish if you rub the bevel.






