Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

bevel rubbing a scaper

Posts

bevel rubbing a scaper

#1

bevel rubbing a scaper

John Lucas

I know we preach that you should not rub the bevel of a scraper and always keep the handle higher than the cutting edge. Well I did a test the other day to see using a round nose scraper and a spindle gouge of the same size to see what the differences were. The scraper I used and the spindle gouge both had 45 degree bevel angles.

I cut coves. I ran the scrapers with and without a burr and shear scraped with the burr.

The scraper with no burr worked just fine rubbing the bevel but of course it did not give as clean a cut as the spindle gouge. I think this was because of the curved edge of the spindle gouge. You are sort of making a slicing cut as you go from high point to low point on a cove. The scraper with burr used in a shear cut going from high to low gave the second best cut.

Rubbing the bevel of the scraper made it catch prone just like a spindle gouge would be if you come off the bevel. It cut cleaner without the burr.

The scraper held flat on the rest was the least likely to catch and did cut cleaner with the burr. The Burr last a very short while and has to be refreshed often. This was the poorest quality of cut of the 4 things tested however when starting the cove you had almost no kick back problems. With bevel rubbing tools you have to pay attention when starting a cove so you don't get a kickback.

With the scraper held flat it was extremely difficult to get a fine point where 2 coves come together. It simply tears the fibers. The bevel rubbing scraper held flat did the same. With a scraper used in shear scrape mode I was able to get a fairly good point but it took a very light cut. With the spindle gouge I could get a point that was sharp enough to cut you, very easily and quickly.

So what did this prove. It proved that you can rub the bevel of a scraper. Why I don't know because a spindle gouge will do a better job and you still have the catch problems if you come off the bevel. If your scraper is ground blunt like many people do then it will do a much worse job on the finish if you rub the bevel.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#2

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

David Walser

Very interesting. Thanks for posting the results of your research.

Question, possibly for another research team to pursue, does it make any difference if you are using a negative rake scraper? I would think a bevel rubbing position with a negative rake scraper would result in a pealing cut -- better than a regular scraper in a shear scrape position, but not as good as the spindle gouge.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#3

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

robo hippy

If it has a bevel, you can rub it as you cut. True for probably any tool. My scrapers are rather blunt, in the 80 degree range. If you take a 45 degree bevel, then you are getting closer to a gouge angle. I would guess you could say that the skewchigouge (beefed up Sorby spindle master) is a scraper type tool made from round stock, that could scrape, or shear cut. Round the nose to a spindle gouge profile, and it cuts beautifully.

I have found that scrapers with a burr, especially if you burnish the burr, will not cut well, or at all, when rubbing the bevel. Since a negative rake scraper is supposed to cut with a burr, and the burr is very delicate, it would do a poor job of cutting when rubbing the bevel.

I have always felt that scrapers will cut a lot cleaner in a shear/angled mode than flat on scraping. More so on end flat grain (bowls) than on spindles or end grain.

robo hippy

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Hey John, that was not a scraper; it was a highly curved skew with one bevel. Not surprising that it should cut like one when you rub the bevel. :)

Dennis

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#5

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

John Lucas

David I could be wrong but I think a negative rake only changed the place where the handle will be. In other words if you hold the handle parallel to the floor a negative rake scraper will have the cutting edge lower than the top which is the same thing you do when you hold the a handle higher on a regular scraper grind.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#6

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

John Lucas

You are right, the Skewchigouge is just a round scraper with the top surface polished.

I did the bevel rubbing test with and without a burr. it works much better without the burr.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#7

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

John Lucas

Dennis In reality a scraper is just a tool with one bevel. There's really no difference in a Bedan and flat scraper except the Bedan is sharpened much more acutely so it will work like a skew.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#8

Katherine Kowalski

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

Katherine Kowalski

Hi John,

Technically speaking, the scraper, even if held at a downward angle, would NOT be a negative-rake scraper, and would act differently accordingly. A negative-rake scraper has two bevels which meet at the cutting edge. Because neither bevel is parallel to the bar of the tool, the forces on the tool are greatly reduced. (Not so with a traditional scraper.)

A good example is with tool-rest overhang: a "regular" tool of any sort (gouge, scraper, etc.) must have a handle 5-7 times longer than the overhang in order to counteract the downward force and act as leverage. In contrast, a negative rake scraper needs only 3 times the length.

(And that's one of the reasons I prefer flat-bar skews instead of ovals -- they can double as negative rake scrapers!)

Katherine

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#9

Brad Vietje

And inside a BOWL ?

Brad Vietje

John,

Thanks for the research into cutting spindles with various scrapers. I thing the big issues there are clean cuts and adequate support to make the finer cuts. Scrapers will need a very light touch to avoid vibration or snapping finer spindles.

It seems the real safety concern comes up when using scrapers as cutting tools inside a concave surface, such as a bowl. That's when a small catch can get wedged into the wood and become a big problem. This is what I was thinking when Reed mentioned hollowing out bowls with scrapers. Hogging out wood with a sharp scraper is fine, and has been done for many years. When scrapers are scraping, they're fine. When a scraping tool is being used as a cutting tool with bevel rubbing (inside a bowl or HF), problems can happen real fast, due to the wedge effect.

This is like using boring bars with rounded cutters (little 3/16" scrapers) on the inside of a bowl or hollow form in such a way that the bevel rubs, which I find to be dangerous. This could happen when cutting well below center on the inside, or by rotating the tool to cut well above center with the bevel in contact with the inner wall of the vessel.

Given how well skews and long-bevel spindle gouges cut fine details on spindles, I'd have to be pretty darned impressed with the results to consider using scrapers for those cuts. Inside a bowl, scrapers are a very useful tool -- when scraping, but I'm not going to recommend using them with the bevel rubbing.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#10

Ditto

John Lucas

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#11

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

John Lucas

I hate to disagree with such a knowledgeable person and maybe we are just stating things differently.

A scraper still has 2 bevels if you want to call it that. A flat one on top and then what we normally call a bevel on the bottom. Lets assume I grind the bottom bevel so the included angle is 45 degrees. Now I take what we call a negative rake scraper with grinds on the top and bottom. I now grind this so the included angle is 45 degrees. In affect I have a tool that cuts the same. The only difference is the angle I have to present the tool to the wood. With a negative rake scraper the "blade" would be roughly horizontal to the floor. With the regular scraper the "blade" would have be tilted down(handle raised) to hit the wood the same way.

For those who don't know what we are talking about. A negative rake scraper is kind of like a skew on it's side. You have a long shank and then a short bevel that meets another short bevel on the bottom. If you take a regular scraper and grind a downhill bevel on the top you have the same thing.

I hope I'm correct in that, it was the way I understood what Stewart Batty was saying and the article in American Woodturner. He will be at our symposium this weekend. If I get the chance I'll try to discuss this with him.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#12

Katherine Kowalski

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

Katherine Kowalski

Hi John,

"Negative-rake" refers to the way the tool is ground, not the way presented to the wood. In the beginning of your paragraph, you refer to a regular scraper, but in the end, a negative rake... (which do you mean?)

A "regular" scraper only has ONE bevel -- the bar is not a bevel. The reduction in cutting forces is due to each bevel being on a different plane than the bar... that is what creates the negative rake. (Therefore, NO "regular" scraper with a single bevel could ever be a "negative rake" scraper.)

Also, the bevels can be of the same length, as in a skew, beading & parting tool, arc tool, etc. or they can be of different lengths, as you mentioned.

For those who are new to negative-rake scraping -- the burr does all the work -- once you have no burr, regrind. Negative-rake scraping works best on very hard woods like cocobolo and blackwood, etc. The burr should be used facing upward on side/cross grain, and burr down on end-grain.

I've taken Stuart Batty's 3-day course and have seen many of his presentations. I heartily encourage you to speak to him on this issue.

Katherine

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#13

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

John Lucas

Katherine I'm sorry I didn't mean to state that a regular scraper was a negative rake scraper. I only meant that if they have the same included angle and you present the regular scraper at an angle so the top of the tool is at the same angle as a negative rake scraper then they will cut the same. How could they not. The wood only knows that a V angle of such and such sharpness is presented to it. It doesn't know that the top of the regular scraper is a long or short bevel.

this is one of those things that If I could present a photo or drawing would probably make sense but words can be interpreted differently by two different people.

You are definitely correct about the burr. That's why Stewart was going to make the negative rake scrapers out of V15 steel. It holds a burr longer but we are still talking about seconds, not minutes.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#14

Katherine Kowalski

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

Katherine Kowalski

Hi John,

I expect that we might disagree all day on this topic, so I won't say much more than this post.

In response, the wood does "know" the difference, because of the pressure exerted on the tool, and it shows up in the finish. (See diagram -- hopefully I've embedded it correctly). (This is just a quick hand-drawing, didn't have time to whip out my drawing program).


The downward force of the wood on the regular scraper is much greater because of the cutting edge's parallelism to the bar, and tends to result in tear-out.

In contrast, using a negative-rake scraper cancels some of that force, and gives a MUCH gentler cut.

The test is the finish -- in using a regular scraper tilted downward, (in my experience), one will never get as fine a finish as using a negative-rake scraper. (This might also be because of the wood types I use. Perhaps different types of wood have given a different experience??? I'd certainly be interested to find out.)

In any case, as with all of woodturning, we each use the techniques and tools that work best for our own particular style, and I'm certainly glad we can have this friendly discussion in an open forum! :-)

Katherine

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#15

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

John Lucas

Darn I want a knock down drag out fight not agree to disagree. :) Later tonight when I have access to a scanner I'll show what I'm saying. Then you can kick me. :) Next thing you I know you'll be asking to sit next to me at the State of Union address. Hope you take all this as tongue and cheek.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#16

Betty Scarpino

Re: And inside a BOWL ?

Betty Scarpino

Brad, you are right ... it's definitely not a good idea to use a scraper with the bevel rubbing on the inside of a bowl ... that's a recipe for a huge dig-in disaster.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#17

Katherine Kowalski

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

Katherine Kowalski

LOL! Well, if that's what ya want! Let me get out my fightin' words! (Ooops, where did I put 'em... oh darn, I think I lost 'em in a pile of woodchips!)

:-)

Katherine

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#18

OK you two, take your scrapers and.....

JamieDonaldson

...go sit in the corners- the opposite corners!!!! :D

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

keith tompkins

Interesting topic! Some thoughts; I've spent lots of time trying to figure out why some grinds cut better than others...First, I think that if you regrind a round-nose scraper to a 45 degree angle, you have converted the tool into a round-nose chisel. Imagine your bench chisels...flat on one side with just one bevel. They are still chisels. As far as the negative rake scraper, it's the presentation that is important..in metal turning, cutters are ground with a negative rake, otherwise, you'll jam up the machine in a hurry; a flat cutter is too agressive. I think technically John is correct; raising the handle of a regular scraper makes it BEHAVE like a negative rake scraper. But, what makes a negative rake scraper work well in scraping mode makes it a lousy tool to attempt riding the bevel....now, it becomes a double-bevel chisel, the top bevel pulling our tool into the cut at the slightest miscalculation. ( Just like our friend the skew chisel.) Speaking of the skew, Peter Child, who is considered the father of the bowl gouge, did not advocate the use of the skew in spindle turning; rather, he preferred a straight chisel. Why? Controllability...a straight chisel responds directly to user input. Like a spindle gouge, raising the handle results in a deeper, more agressive cut, while a conventional skew requires a twisting motion into the cut to control the depth of cut. If using a high tool rest, as most turners suggest, turning a bead requires rolling the tool, keeping the short point in contact at all times. This required raising the handle while rolling the tool...something many turners cannot grasp. Any part of the grind above the cutting point is unsupported, and will catch if it touches the wood. The tool is making contact with the tool rest on only a small point, (a fulcrum) which acts as a lever against the turner. On the other hand, a straight chisel may be used at any point along the cutting edge. and presents a more natural approach when making planing cuts...a regular skew, with the cutting edge held at a 90 degree angle to the axis is cutting straight into end grain, and is a major cause of many turner's difficulties with the tool. I've spent a lot of time with the straight chisel; nothing else makes a peeling cut as fast, just raise the handle. Great for tenons.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#20

trying to explain my point 

john lucas

I hope this drawing helps. I have 2 tools both with identical 45 degree angles. One is a regular scraper held high so the top of the tool is at the same angle as the top bevel on the negative rake scraper in the lower drawing.

I could be wrong but I find it hard to see how the two can cut ( or scrape) any differently. That was my assumption that the wood doesn't know the difference in the two tools.

Now if the top tool were ground to a larger angle, say 70 degrees and the negative rake scraper was sharpened at 35 degrees, then definitely they would cut differently.

Anyway it's always interesting discussing these things because I learn something new all the time. I know better than to argue with a woman. :) I'll go sit in my corner now.

Re: bevel rubbing a scaper

#21

Katherine Kowalski

Re: trying to explain my point

Katherine Kowalski

LOL!

Thanks for the drawing -- that's what I was envisioning. I still tend to think that the pressure on the wood when using a single-beveled tool would be greater, but it may result in a similar finish with certain woods.

Talk to Stu when you see him -- he's studied the physics of woodturning extensively, and he should be able to give a definitive answer on this question.

Katherine