Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Skew grinds.

Posts

Skew grinds.

#1

Leo Cuellar

Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

Just thought I'd post a few of the different skew grinds I've been playing with. This has been a tool that has been very hard for me to control when attempting detail work, beads & coves especially. I got to thinking that maybe I didn't have my tool rest positioned correctly. I had assumed that the correct setting would put the cutting edge in line at 90 degrees from the top, or just below the center line, depending on the width of the tool. I found out tonight, that I have much better control if I set the rest about 1/8th to 3/16th inch above the center.

Skew 1 is home made from leaf spring 3/8th inch thick with the newer swept back point. Excellent for planing square to round. 1&1/2" wide.

Skew 2 is Grizzly with traditional grind great for planing & beading.

Skew 3 is a re-purposed carving tool. I just came up with this grind tonight, it works great for beading & coving.

Skew 4 was also a carving tool now with a Drozda style grind. Works great for coves, but haven't figured out how to control it so well on beads.



While I'm obviously not good at it yet, you don't see too many catch spirals on these, whereas a week ago I couldn't have done any of this with a skew. (The wood is hemlock 2"x2", because I get it free.)



So, if you have any tips about grinds & tool rest positioning I'd really appreciate the input.

Thanks!

Leo

Re: Skew grinds.

#2

Re: Skew grinds.

john lucas

Like you I've played with a lot of different tool grinds. I think the most important part of the skew is what you are doing right now. Practice practice practice. Personally I think the sharpness angle of the skew is what makes them different to use, not the actually shape of the edge. I find a 35 degree angle measured from bevel to bevel the easiest to use.

When I've been turning a lot a 25 is good but I still get catches when turning beads if I haven't been using it a lot. I thing the reason is it cuts so fast you tend to over rotate the tool and come off the bevel, and of course a catch happens. You have to make yourself slow down and let the tool do the work.

45 degree and thicker has 2 problems. One is the bevel is too short which makes it harder to stay in control. It is handy for cutting coves and better than a long bevel. The other problem is how far you have to move the handle when cutting beads. A sharper angle tool requires less movement of the handle which makes it easier to control on beads with the exception noted on the 25 degree angle.

This is of course just my opinion and your mileage may vary.

Cutting beads with the Drozda tool will duplicate my problems with short bevels on the skew. You use it like a spindle gouge but you have to move the tool quite a bit more unless the grind is much sharper. Try regrinding it so it looks more like a spindle gouge and less like a scraper. I've never seen her tool in person so I don't know the grind she uses. I have seen her work so she obviously knows how to use what ever it is.

Re: Skew grinds.

#3

Re: Skew grinds.

Jorge Casta�eda

Leo,

Try with the tool rest even higher, say 1/2" above center-line and you will be surprised how easy many things become.

After much experimenting with edge shapes and angles, I am back to straight edges, with no concavities or even slightly convex.

Somewhere I have a rounded edge skew I use occasionally as a scraper on the inside of bowls.

The other thing, they must be surgically sharp, if they are not you will be very frustrated.

Re: Skew grinds.

#4

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

Thanks, John. I didn't think about the shortness of the bevel on the Drozda style. I'll have to find a thicker blank to use for that one, as it is rather thin. I haven't seen a good photo of one, so I was guestimating quite a bit on how that was set up. I could try just putting a bevel on one side.

Leo

Re: Skew grinds.

#5

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

Thanks, Jorge. I'll try the rest higher like you suggest. I've been working on my grinding methods to try to get the bevel as flat as possible. I also discovered last night that sharper is better. I started polishing on a fine rubberized silicon carbide wheel as an intermediate step before power stropping. I found that to help quite a bit. I'll have to take the time to hand hone once I get the mechanics of the cutting figured out.

Leo

Re: Skew grinds.

#6

Re: Skew grinds.

john lucas

I didn't look at the angle you ground on the round tool. If it's somewhere from about 45 degrees or sharper it will probably work. Quite often I see tools like this ground about 60 degrees or even blunter. That's why I said what I did concerning the bevel. Actual bevel length is not critical it's the sharpening angle that matters. Bevel length only comes into play when your turning concave surfaces like bowls or coves.

Re: Skew grinds.

#7

Re: Skew grinds.

john lucas

Tool rest height is kind of relative because it depends on how tall you are and how tall the lathe is and even how thick the tool is. I think What Jorge was telling you is to cut higher on the wood. This often means a higher tool rest height. When planing wood with the skew I am usually cutting about 11 oclock or even almost across the top.

Flatness of the bevel isn't critical. Sharpness is. I've been playing with convex bevels, concave bevels and flat bevels. I prefer the concave bevel with the area right behind the cutting edge being flat. This is because I sharpen with a diamond hone. The concave area simply lets me sharpen quicker because I remove very little metal.

Re: Skew grinds.

#8

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

OK, John, if I understand, you were concerned about the angle nearer the heels. That it shouldn't be as great, making the tool a little blunter when viewed from the photo POV? Makes sense actually considering how well the grind on #3 worked.

Incidentally, I did start grinding back the heels on my bowl gouges, and it helped quite a bit with the heat issue. I might not have the correct grind for general bowl turning, however they take beautiful continuous shavings in dry end grain. Found that out making a small mortar & pestle Friday.

Re: Skew grinds.

#9

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

For planing cylinders I usually work with the rest parallel to the center, but because my favorite skew for this is so wide, it really makes little difference. I can't seem to control one that has any kind of a concave grind. A slight convex grind is OK, but then as you said, you have to move the handle too much. I'm slowly getting them as flat as I can near the cutting edge. Once I finally get the angle/bevel combination that works for me, maintaining the edge should be pretty easy.

Yes, once I moved the rest higher I noticed an immediate increase in my ability to control the tool when attempting the detail work.Since I am fairly short, 5'7" in shoes, I hadn't considered raising the lathe as well as raising the rest height. This is something I should try as I have always favored a higher work surface.

Thanks again,

Leo

Re: Skew grinds.

#10

Re: Skew grinds.

charlie belden

I think the Spindle Master is a Sorby tool. In cross section it's about 3/8ths of a circle. Flat top, fingernai-ish grind - it's neither fish nor fowl. From the bottom it looks sort of like a spindle gouge. From the top it looks like a scraper. From the side it looks like a squashed down a little spindle gouge. It is used like a mixture of spindle and a single bevel skew - a bedan. The lack of the long scary point that the skew has makes it seem less intimidating

Putting a curve on the traditional skew pulls the point back out of the way a bit - and makes it less intimidating - and easier to use.


From reading how others see and use the skew I guess I'm a Bumble Bee. Not knowing any better, I apparently use it differently than the conventional methods. I usually start a rolling cut with the long point - with it pointing down, the skew above center, cutting down and into the cut. A little roll and I'm on the bevel. As long as the long point doesn't get into the far side of the bead - no worries.

Where a curved edge skew excels is as a negative rake scraper - for tuning a profile.. The finial on the lid of this winged box was blended into the box lid with a small curved edge skew.


Re: Skew grinds.

#11

Re: Skew grinds.

John Lucas

Charlie I never liked the long point ground away like that. I use the long point a lot to reach into area and for cutting reverse "v" shapes. It's easier to see what's happening with the point sticking out. The same is true for "tucking in" beads.

I still don't buy the argument that the ground off point makes it safer. If you get above the 1/2 way point on a skew you are probably going to get a catch before you ever get out to the point. Either skew will catch if that happens.

Re: Skew grinds.

#12

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Skew grinds.

Katherine Kowalski

I've worked with Cindy Drozda for quite some time, (she's my "neighbor" here in the Colorado area), and she doesn't use her Arc Tool as a skew at all... she uses it as a negative-rake scraper for cleaning up curved surfaces. (This may explain some of the difficulty you're having using the tool as a skew! ;)

One thing I learned from Stuart Mortimer -- he uses a slightly convex bevel on his skew. (And once I started to, I created a catch-less skew!) A concave bevel allows the tool to bind very easily, especially in tight v-grooves. I use a 3/8" skew for all my skew-work, and grind the angle at the top to a shallow 18'.

Another item that affects performance is the stock -- are you using an oval skew, one from square (rectangular) stock, or a square-stock with rolled edges? (I like a rolled-edge skew, but you'll find many different opinions on this!)

Another tip -- if you have a disused square-stock skew -- grind it to have one bevel -- it makes a fantastic end-grain parting tool. (Think parting off the bases of goblets with no tear-out).

Katherine

Re: Skew grinds.

#13

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

Thank you, Katherine! That is some very valuable information. I hadn't considered that it was used as a scraper. When I first started, all my tools were made from files. I had made 2 single bevel skews, a right & left. At that time the only way I could use one was as a scraper. My angle was probably a little too sharp as well.

My big one is a half oval, just the side that sits on the rest. My 1" has slightly rolled edges as do the smaller ones. I cant say that I've developed a preference for one style over the other.

Thanks again,

Leo

Re: Skew grinds.

#14

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

Hi, Charlie. Thanks for the pic. In light of what Katherine said I might be better off regrinding that one to the Spindlemaster shape and give that a try.

I'm still undecided about the point issue. They are handy to have for the reason John mentioned. I seem to find myself working mostly at the heel end, which I understand is supposed to be a big no no also. In trying to analyze where I'm going wrong, I must be drifting backwards just enough to cause catches. In any event, more practice is indicated.

The winged shape is looking real good!

Leo

Re: Skew grinds.

#15

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Skew grinds.

Katherine Kowalski

Though there are many different methods of using the skew, using the lower point, (the "heel"), is absolutely a correct way!

(I put the term "heel" in quotes because I like to refer to it as the "lower point" to avoid confusing this with the heel at the end of the bevel).

In any case, Stuart Mortimer taught me to roll beads with the lower point. When starting out using the skew, turning coves is easier with the long point, but with practice the lower point is more effective/gives you more control. Before his tutelage, I had quite a bit of difficulty with the tool, and these techniques helped perfect my usage. I find that leading with the long point to roll beads is very catch-prone.

When rolling beads, always lead with the (lower) point of the tool -- cutting in the middle of the tool is where you are going to get your catches.

(I also use Stuart's method of roughing and planing, which is to drive the cut with the lower point, instead of cutting in the middle of the blade. For roughing/planing, the tool rest must be high, and further away from the workpiece than you might normally use it. Cut on the "brow" of the wood. (Think "forehead"))

One of the reasons I use a straight-edged skew, (as opposed to a rounded end, like tool #1), is that it's MUCH easier to see when the tool gets down into the bottom of the v-groove. When I've used a curved edge, it's impossible to see the leading point, and v-grooves become a guessing game.

Katherine

Re: Skew grinds.

#16

Re: Skew grinds.

John Lucas

Leo Use whatever cutting edge works for that cut. I agree with everything Katherine said. I cut mostly with the heel but don't have a bit of problem using the toe (long point) of the tool. It's good to experiment with either end and see what you like. You might discover something new.

My best friend claims he can't use a skew. He grew up using what's called a spear point tool. (looks like your Drozda tool but is V shaped when looking from the top. The funny thing is he uses it just like I use a skew. He just doesn't know it.

Re: Skew grinds.

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew grinds.

keith tompkins

Hey John, I must be careful here, because I'm marketing a skew chisel simiar in design to your friend's tool, and don't want to appear to be promoting it here. The secret is a single bevel; combining both right and left handed single bevel skews results in a "v" configuration. Most turners don't have the luxury of spending years perfecting the useage of the skew, they just want to make stuff. Most people feel they are somehow less of a turner because they can't use the skew chisel. I tell them...relax, it's not you. It's the tool. How many people, in comparison, will say "I can't use a bowl gouge?" or "I can't use a spindle gouge?" I'll bet it's a hundred to one.

Re: Skew grinds.

#18

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

Thank you yet again, Katherine! I remember now where I heard that, in a video about planing with the skew, and my faulty memory applied it to everything. I'll have to make some time before work today to try out your tool rest suggestion.

Leo

Re: Skew grinds.

#19

Leo Cuellar

Re: Skew grinds.

Leo Cuellar

Thank you, John. I appreciate all the help. I'm looking forward to getting in some more practice this week. I may try grinding it to a point & see what happens. I was playing around with my parting tool, trying to use it like a bedan. I'm going to have to make one soon.

Re: Skew grinds.

#20

I think it's a learned response

john lucas

They hear over and over, I can't use the skew. It's really not any different than other tools it's just we are taught to be scared of it from the beginning. Nick Cook as started teaching beginners using the skew as the first tool. He finds it's easier for them to understand how the bevel works because it's just flat and on the other side not curved like the gouges.

Re: Skew grinds.

#21

Katherine Kowalski

Re: I think it's a learned response

Katherine Kowalski

You said it John! I've heard sooooo many people say they're scared of the tool.

I was very fortunate in that (years ago) I had only been turning for two months before Allan Batty came to town and held a class. I simply didn't know that I was supposed to be scared of the skew! :) Allan taught me how pilot the bevel to make v-grooves and straight cuts. I was fortunate to avoid scare or preference issues. (It came as a great surprise to me that anyone should have a "favorite" side of a bead to roll....!)

When I teach and demonstrate, I try to get past this scare factor by explaining how other tools do such-and-such a cut, "which is exactly like a skew." I find that understanding of the way turning works and how the bevel controls the cut helps people improve their technique and eliminate some of that fear.

Katherine

Re: Skew grinds.

#22

Re: Skew grinds.

charlie belden

How many people, in comparison, will say "I can't use a bowl gouge?" or "I can't use a spindle gouge?"

Uh - that'd be me. A skew, bedan, my 1/4" bench chisel and even my 1/16th inch parting tool all have the cutting edge in a single plane. Keep track of that plane and you know where it will cut. With a fingernail grind bowl gouge - or a spindle gouge for that matter - the cutting edge IS NOT in a single plane. Rotate the tool either around its long axis or pivot it off the tool rest and you can engage a whole lot of cutting edge - very quickly. So even with the bevel rubbing, when you've got a long cutting edge contacting wood - there's more force you must resist.

I think playing with a bedan - or if you don't want to spend the money on a bedan - a 1/4" bench chisel is a great tool to play with in preparation for using a skew. You may find that a bedan or bench chisel will let you do the cuts you're after - and you won't get to the skew.