Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

3520B ideal floor???

Posts

3520B ideal floor???

#1

3520B ideal floor???

Richard Kennedy

Hi

I am in the very lucky position to be taking delivery of a new PM3520B (albeit under the Jet branding - I'm in the UK where Powermatic sell under the Jet livery) Its arriving in February and so I have plenty of time to reorganise my workshop to accept it. This however is where the issues begin! When my workshop was built it came with a timber floor. I had put down a concrete pad and asked for the shed walls to be built on this but sadly this request never made it to the guys who built it. So now I have a floor that sits on joists that sit on a concrete pad the actual floor is comprised of a double layer of 3/4 inch tongue and groove chipboard flooring. My question is this. Do I need to cut holes in the floor to put in concrete pads to support the 337kg lump of lathe or will the wood floor be sufficient?

I have upgraded from a Record CL3 and so have never had the opportunity to turn larger items. I will be looking to make some bigger stuff and maybe some off-centre work.

I would appreciate any thoughts or ideas

Richard

bolegallery.com

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#2

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

john lucas

I'm not an engineer but if the joists are setting on the concrete I'm pretty sure that would be plenty strong. The biggest problem would be if the legs are not sitting directly over the joists. How far apart are the joists. That will have some bearing on how strong the 2 layers of flooring are if the legs are not sitting over the joists.

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#3

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Howard Norman

Could you put a 2x under the legs to be sure that you are spanning the floor joists?

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#4

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Jerry Hall

Richard,

One nice thing is that you will be very much happier standing on a wood floor v. concrete. I agree that with the joists on the concrete, and I guess as you describe it, a 1-1/2 inch thick floor it is well worth a try. If the height works out putting 2x4 or even 4x4 under the legs, even overhanging a couple inches, will give you great stability and span across the joists. If you do this you might want to put the adjustable feet under the timbers spanning the legs to level and stabilize the lathe. Having a good "understanding" on all four legs is essential. Jerry

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#5

Richard Allen

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Richard Allen

!! Congratulations !! That is a big gloat!!

The new lathe is a huge upgrade. You are going to love the new lathe. I turned on a CL3 for 4 years when I started out. I really liked that lathe. When I upgraded I quickly found out that the CL3 was a lot less of a lathe than I knew.

You could put concrete piers under each foot so the support goes to the concrete slab. But I would suspect that yout existing floor is more than enough support. A sheet of 3/4 plywood glued and screwed on 4" spacing (yes that is a lot of screws) should ensure enough stiffness that the floor won't be a concern for supporting your new lathe. If you bolt the legs through the floor you will never worry about large out of balance pieces. Mind you even bolted down you can make any lathe shake.

When I first started using the CL3 it bounced around when spinning larger out of round pieces. I added a plywood front, back and loaded 500 pounds of sand to the stand. Nearly eliminated and vibration issues.

The biggest change for spinning large out of balance wood on your new lathe is the electronic variable speed. Doing initial roughing at 100 - 200 RPM is going to help you eliminate your lathe stability concerns.

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#6

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Keith Inscho

If your joists are sitting on concrete you should be OK. If not, the floor will support it but you may get some bounce at certain speeds.

I took delivery of my new 3520B about six weeks ago and mine is sitting on an 1 1/4" floor with 2x8 joists on 16" centers. I put 4x4 cross braces under the floor with steel screw jacks supporting them. This seems to work OK but I still get a resonance at about 550-600 rpm even with well balanced pieces. I plan on adding a ballast box, and failing this, I will cut the floor out and add a concrete pad to sit the lathe on. Good luck. I know you will like the new lathe. :D

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#7

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Terry Scott

Richard

Even if the joists are sitting directly on The concrete floor you are bound to get some movement .The forces that your heavy lathe

will place in all directions when under load with an out of balance piece on inboard you will get some vibration.As a Builder Id cut the floor out and poor a pad on your existing concrete to floor level .Use some old bricks to full in some of the void 1/2metre of concrete Job done

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#8

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Dick Wilson

Richard, My big concern would be the vibration developed on a wood floor.

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#9

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Richard Kennedy

Hi and thanks for all your responses. At present I am laid up with a broken foot so can't do anything much. Add into that the fact that the lathe is going to my which is workshop 250miles away in Scotland. When I am fixed and get up there I will have to check how well the wooden joists sit on the concrete pad. I know because I laid the pad that its not completely level - there are undulations in the concrete which means that there are gaps between the joists and the ground. With this in mind I do begin to wonder if I would be better creating concrete piers for the legs to go on Apart from the guaranteed stability it would also lower any noise or resonance coming from the shed which I guess my neighbours would appreciate. I have heard that the 3520B is a quiet machine anyway but by isolating it from the shed I would imagine it will be even quieter?? I know it is a lot more work to achieve but I think that having gone the extra mile to get the thing in the first place I should make the effort to site it in the best possible way.

Thanks for all your advice I imagine I may well be back asking about the best way to construct the concrete pads 4 individual ones or 2 strips or 1 big one? As it is I also have to demolish some of my workbench just to get the lathe in (my workshop is a bijou 3mx3m (10' x 10')) but as it is only turning that I do I figured it would be fine!

Richard

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#10

Aage Rendalen

I have your identical floor and it's ok

Aage Rendalen

I've experience no problem with two three-quarter inch chip board floor boards. I used double joists underneath to be sure, but I don't think that would have been necessary. My problem has been adjusting the height. It now rests on a couple of 2x6 boards, perpendicular to the joists. That alone provides quite a bit of extra support.

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#11

I strongly suggest that you try out.....

JamieDonaldson

..the lathe on the present floor, and address any shortcomings later. A shop arrangement is always a work in progress, and you might wish to relocate the lathe several times to find the "perfect" spot for smooth workflow. :D

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: 3520B ideal floor???

Brad Vietje

Richard,

Congratulations on the new lathe! I have the same lathe, but not the same floor. Mine's currently on concrete with sandbags on a lower 2x6 shelf, but not bolted down. For really big chunks of wet wood, bolted to the floor would be even better.

I agree with Jamie and others that you should set it up and enjoy it, and only make changes as you find them necessary. You can work out the lathe placement and height, among other issues. If you find you need more stability, another retrofit option would be to cut holes in the floor and pour concrete pads under the legs of the lathe, leaving the wooden floor where you will stand and work.

Soon I'll be moving my lathe to a building with an old wood-over-concrete floor (1.5" pine over 2x2 stringers laid on the concrete), and fully expect to pour two small concrete pads for the legs at either end, complete with bolts and all, since I like to work large odd-shaped pieces of green wood. If you tend to work with lighter or more balanced stock, you might never need such measures.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT