Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Fuming with ammonia?

Posts

Fuming with ammonia?

#1

Fuming with ammonia?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have been wanting to try fuming some White Oak for a while, and have a fairly nice tree which my fireplace is consuming at the present. I didn't know if sapwood turned or not, but after a search, found that it doesn't, so my plans just got smaller.

However,was wondering if anyone had any information about Catalpa, whether it will darken. I have a really large tree out there that I need to get back to, and would like to try it.

Also, in the past, I thought most of the articles I had read, suggested heating the ammonia to produce steam. But I just read one, which mentioned just using about 1/4" depth in some flat trays. I am now wondering if I couldn't just put a turning in a big plastic trash can with a lid, or even some of those lidded storage bins that you can buy at Walmart or Target.

I'll just be using whatever ammonia I can buy at the hardware store. Have any of you got any experience or advice for me?

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#2

JL

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

JL

I've used blueprint ammonia. It runs about 24 Baume or so (25%). It works well.

Household ammonia is a bit weak to fume with. That typically runs about 10% ammonia or less.

I've used bags and sealed containers. Make sure that you have a shallow tray (non metallic) in the bottom to hold the ammonia. I would recommend a stand and holding the piece on "points" as whatever is not exposed to the fumes won't darken as much.

Wear an air-purifying respirator with ammonia cartridges - also wear goggles. If you have a full face respirator use that. Ammonia can be nasty and the fumes will affect your eyes.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#3

Double duty

Jack Savona

If you do use household ammonia (maybe even blueprint) and if you could do it in your kitchen oven overnight, it will also clean the oven by making whatever is baked on come loose. A two-fer.

Of course follow all safety precautions.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#4

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

bill Crommett

A few years ago I fumed a new stand of red Oak for an antique Butter churn. I put a container of household ammonia in a plastic dish and set it in a Walmart storage container with an airtight lid re-enforced with packing tape (for air tight)

It took several days to get to the dark color of the churn, but it did match fairly well. It was summer, so I worked outside.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#5

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

Dan Oliphant

JL has it right, use the 25% ammonia for a more positive result. I have fumed a fair amount of white oak and the results will very from piece to piece because the amount of tannon in each piece of oak will very.

I strongly recommend only using the ammonia in a VERY well ventilated area, not inside your house!!!!

Check the pieces every six to eight hours so as not to over darken your wood

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#6

I'd probably forget and turn the oven on.

John Lucas

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#7

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

Craig Daymon

I have fumed several small projects using household ammonia. (MUCH safer than using blueprint ammonia. I think the ammonia from the hardware store is slightly stronger than household, but still MUCH safer than blueprint.)

The effect will vary depending on how much tannin is in the wood. This is somewhat easy to gauge based on if your hands get some black coloring on the palms when working the wood. (Especially easy if it is a turning.) I found Lyptus has a high tannin content this way.

I use an Igloo (brand really not important) cooler that seals nice and tight. I make a platform to sit the piece on out of a piece of MDF with small holed drilled in it. I insert toothpicks in the holes on which the piece will sit. Number of holes/toothpicks and size of platform vary based on size of piece. I pour ammonia into one or more pyrex dishes and put them in the bottom of the cooler. Close it up with the piece inside and leave it alone for a day or two.

Let it air out at least as long as it spent in there (or until it doesn't smell like ammonia) before applying finish.

Here's a pic of a Chestnut bowl (LOTS of tannin) that I fumed with household ammonia. I did a white oak (and yellowheart) candlestick as well, but I can't find the pic. It was posted on Woodcentral, so it should be in the archive somewhere.


Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#8

Tea

Bill Howatt

Can you wash the piece with tea or something to increase the tanins before fuming?

Bill

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#9

Re: Tea

Craig Daymon

Yes.

I haven't tried it, but I read that in the Fine Woodworking article on fuming several years back. They, again, recommended blueprint ammonia, but I personally believe that household is sufficient if your container is air tight enough and you have the patients to wait a little longer.

I think you can also buy tannic acid in a powdered form that you mix with (distilled) water before applying. (I would use distilled to avoid impurities.) Using the powdered form (which, if I remember, is available in grocery stores...for what I don't remember) would let you make it as strong as you want.

The FWW article did get some good results on Cherry that looked like aged Cherry. Also on Butternut, making it look like Walnut.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#10

Jim Evans

Re: Tea

Jim Evans

I use non detergent ammonia because it seems to be a little stronger than household ammonia.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#11

Re: Tea

Bruce Pratt

Try quebracho bark powder as a tannin source. You can get it from leather tanning suppliers.

Bruce

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#12

Just looking in wiki

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

"Although tea contains tannin and various types of polyphenols, "contrary to widespread belief, tea does not contain tannic acid."

But I am finding some things that I can make a tea from which does have it, like sumac berries.

By the way, I have a test running, and the green W Oak is already dark after about 6 hours, and the dry Catalpa burl is just moderately changed.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#13

Re: Why bother

gtwilkins

G'day,

For the life of me I can never understand why people want to fume wood with ammonia! Why mess with a very toxic substance when you can achieve the same finish with dyes that are far safer.

Just my opinion. Trevor

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#14

It isn't that much bother.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Actually I am finding it to be a lot easier that I expected.

I don't know how dangerous it could be to pour a little into the bottom of a container just before putting a lid on it. When I finish, I will pour it back into the bottle.

I'm just using the stuff that people have been using to clean with for generation. If breathing a little ammonia fumes was all that bad, there wouldn't be a chicken farmer alive. After having raised 150,000 about 40 years ago, I am not that concerned about a little exposure from this.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#15

Re: It isn't that much bother.

Craig Daymon

I agree. If not using the blueprint ammonia for the job, I find it quite safe. (After all, what do you think smelling salts were?)

Fuming perfectly distributes the coloring across the object and penetrates significantly into the surface, allowing (light) touch-up sanding afterwards. I'm pretty sure that you can glue the fumed piece to an unfumed piece after the process is complete with no ill effects. (Allowing sufficient time for the fumed piece to off gas before doing so.)

I picked up the Winter 2011 issue of Woodwork magazine and Aled Lewis has two white oak tables in there where portions of the top are fumed and portions are not. I have hopes to do a chess board some day in a similar fashion. That way I can have all the grain on the board run natural to the original board and still have the coloration, something that would be more difficult with conventional finishes.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#16

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I recently did some experiments as part of a demo for my woodturning club in which I showed the results of fuming with household ammonia for three days. Each piece was rough sanded and then cut in half, one half to remain as is and the other to be fumed. All sixteen samples were fumed simultaneously for three days using one-half cup of household ammonia in a 5-gallon plastic paint bucket with lid. The wood samples were placed on a rack above the ammonia. After three days the fumed and unfumed samples of each wood were glued back together, allowed to dry for a few days and then sprayed with one coat of lacquer. In every case, fuming made a distinctive darkening and change of color of the wood, although not necessarily an improvement.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#17

Dennis, Thanks for sharing that.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

You have some woods there that I wouldn't have thought should have reacted, like the maple and sycamore.

The Oak looks pretty coarse grained, is it in the Red Oak family?

Were these samples green or dry to start with, or does that matter? I took my green Post Oak sample out after about 6 hours, because it was already darker than I was wanting.

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#18

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Dennis, Thanks for sharing that.

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Keith, I was somewhat surprised too. As far as I know, pine does not have a lot of tannin, but darkened quite a bit. It makes me wonder whether tannin content is actually needed for fuming. Regarding the oak, we have native red and white oak varieties and I am not sure which this was. All of the woods were dry. In general, because of my limited photography skills, the pictures generally understate the changes produced by fuming.

Dennis

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#19

Impressive

Bill Howatt

I didn't think you'd get results like that especially with the household ammonia and on some of the species.

I have a feeling the household ammonia bottle is heading for the shop.

Bill

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#20

very informative...

GaryG in MD

Dennis,

If one picture is worth 1000 words... you know the rest...

Very interesting indeed -- who would have guessed? This is a great, natural, and easy way to get some different coloration to woods that we may be getting bored with (colorwise).

Thanks for a great post!

...Gary

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#21

Use household ammonia. It's not rocket science

wilbur

I just tried fuming a project I made with white oak last week. It's a wall hanging cross some friends asked me to make for their house. It was really easy to do. I used household ammonia. I did my fuming in my basement shop with no problems. I had a 64 oz. bottle of household ammonia, poured it into a large shallow dish, built a quick and dirty frame to hold my project over the container, put everything into a contractor's garbage bag, closed and rolled up the opening, and put a chunk of wood on the rolled up part of the bag so it wouldn't come open. That's it. I fumed my project for 48 hours.

My wife, who has a bionic nose, didn't smell a thing.

As to the household vs. industrial ammonia issue, I read reports on the internet saying that aqueous ammonia was necessary for fuming, and recalled using aqueous ammonia in chemistry lab in college (I was a chem major) and my first thought was, "There's no way that stuff is coming into my house!" That's the sort of stuff I would only use in a hood.

All the aqueous ammonia will do is speed up the process and cause damage to your corneas. It's a chemical reaction that causes the color change, so even though this is the first time I tried this, I think I remember enough chemistry to predict what would happen.

If you have time to let the workpiece sit and bathe in the ammonia, the household ammonia should be fine.

If you need to impart a color change in an hour, then you'll need the industrial stuff. But how often are you going to be operating under that sort of deadline?

If you have a large piece, the household ammonia should be fine. You'll just need a chamber big enough to house it, and time.

Two other things that I think helped: First, a low flat container is better for allowing the ammonia to fume out. That's what I used. Think baking dish, not pasta sauce jar.

Second, I bought the jug of ammonia the day that I used it. At less than $1.50 for a 64 oz. bottle, I don't see any reason not to use ammonia fresh out of the bottle. I saved the ammonia that I used, but next time it might take a little longer to fume a piece, in which case I'll get a new bottle.

Here's the final result. The oak that I used started at a color that was several shaded lighter than the sample in Dennis' picture above. Sorry it's not a turned project, but I'm planning to fume the next bowl I make from white oak.


Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#22

Re: Use household ammonia. It's not rocket science

Craig Daymon

Wilbur,

My guess is that you have yet to apply a finish to that project. It still appears to have that gray cast color that fumed objects get. Please, if this is the case, post a picture with the finish applied so those unfamiliar can see the full effect. (I expect it to go to a classic chocolate brown mission finish.)

Thanks,

Craig

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#23

Re: Use household ammonia. It's not rocket science

wilbur

That's the finished piece -- I applied shellac and wax after the fuming was done.

I might have gotten to a chocolate brown finish with more time, but I wanted to deliver the cross to my friends this weekend, and it had hit the shade that I was looking for. The grey cast is probably due to white balance issues when I took the photo with my camera.

I haven't done this much, but I played around with color temps and exposure in iPhoto, and this version of the picture is probably more representative of what it looks like, although I think the cross is a bit darker than this.


Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#24

Steven Antonucci

It does.

steven antonucci

I have fumed like Wilbur, except that I used a large storage bin instead of a bag. (I use the garbage bags for DNA soaking so I didn't need 30 gallons of the stuff).

Just snap the lid off and on to check progress and give it some time. I might have used a quart of ammonia when I did it, and it worked great. I would highly recommend that people avoid the other stuff, as it is not for household use.

S

Re: Fuming with ammonia?

#25

Dennis, Thanks for that info, and ....

JamieDonaldson

...I wonder is these same woods would react in a similar fashion to ebonizing with vinegar/steel wool solution?