Use household ammonia. It's not rocket science
wilbur
I just tried fuming a project I made with white oak last week. It's a wall hanging cross some friends asked me to make for their house. It was really easy to do. I used household ammonia. I did my fuming in my basement shop with no problems. I had a 64 oz. bottle of household ammonia, poured it into a large shallow dish, built a quick and dirty frame to hold my project over the container, put everything into a contractor's garbage bag, closed and rolled up the opening, and put a chunk of wood on the rolled up part of the bag so it wouldn't come open. That's it. I fumed my project for 48 hours.
My wife, who has a bionic nose, didn't smell a thing.
As to the household vs. industrial ammonia issue, I read reports on the internet saying that aqueous ammonia was necessary for fuming, and recalled using aqueous ammonia in chemistry lab in college (I was a chem major) and my first thought was, "There's no way that stuff is coming into my house!" That's the sort of stuff I would only use in a hood.
All the aqueous ammonia will do is speed up the process and cause damage to your corneas. It's a chemical reaction that causes the color change, so even though this is the first time I tried this, I think I remember enough chemistry to predict what would happen.
If you have time to let the workpiece sit and bathe in the ammonia, the household ammonia should be fine.
If you need to impart a color change in an hour, then you'll need the industrial stuff. But how often are you going to be operating under that sort of deadline?
If you have a large piece, the household ammonia should be fine. You'll just need a chamber big enough to house it, and time.
Two other things that I think helped: First, a low flat container is better for allowing the ammonia to fume out. That's what I used. Think baking dish, not pasta sauce jar.
Second, I bought the jug of ammonia the day that I used it. At less than $1.50 for a 64 oz. bottle, I don't see any reason not to use ammonia fresh out of the bottle. I saved the ammonia that I used, but next time it might take a little longer to fume a piece, in which case I'll get a new bottle.
Here's the final result. The oak that I used started at a color that was several shaded lighter than the sample in Dennis' picture above. Sorry it's not a turned project, but I'm planning to fume the next bowl I make from white oak.
