Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Scrapers and Bowls long

Posts

Scrapers and Bowls long

#1

Scrapers and Bowls long

robo hippy

All of God's children are different, and some of us are more different than the others.

I started fooling around with scrapers some years ago (can't remember when) just to see what those who did use them regularly knew that I didn't. Well, I found out it is a very efficient tool for roughing, when flat on the tool rest, and an excellent tool for finish/touch up cuts that remove tool marks and tear out when used in a shear/angled cut mode.

Look at it this way. I think most turners will rough a bowl blank by using a scraping cut. When you use a gouge, you have it rolled on its side, and most of the time you are pulling, although this can be pushed. Some times the gouge handle is dropped, some times it is held level. The bevel does not rub. This is some times called a shear scrape. The nose part of the gouge, because of its curved shape is shear cutting, and the flute is scraping, cutting part of the tool is at 90 degrees to the wood rotation.

My scrapers are 1 1/4 and 1 1/2 inch wide by 3/8 thick. I prefer a swept back design, so like half of a swept back bowl gouge profile. Three main advantages over a bowl gouge:

One is there is more mass which means less vibration, which reallly isn't much of an advantage, because as long as you don't hang out too far off the tool rest, vibration isn't a problem.

Two is, because of the more rounded profile, you can push or pull, keeping the steel in the wood at all times, rather than going down a bit, then coming back to the top to start another cut. Now, this is a roughing technique. Cutting with and against the grain, when removing bulk, makes no difference. You aren't trying for surface quality, you are getting 'that which is not a bowl' out of the way. This does speed things up quite a bit. Note, as you get close to final thickness/shape, you make lighter cuts, and tear out is less, then I generally will use a gouge for a final cut, and a scraper at a shear angle for any clean up. Another note here is when doing the inside, I do push and pull, just like on the outside, but, I work the rim down in stages, just like with a gouge. Under no circumstances will I use a scraper flat on the tool rest for any cut on a bowl, once the wall thickness is done, and the rest of the bowl has been hollowed out. Just touch the rim, and you can say "KABLOOIE!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Three is that when using a scraper for roughing, the chips are ejected up over the top of your hand, not across the top. So, since doing this, I have lost my bowl turning callus on my pinky finger of my left hand. I never did wear gloves.

The only reason not to use scrapers is that you don't get the practice you need to perfect gouge skills.

As for the guy who was getting beat up, and broke the tool rest, when learning any skill, if you are fighting it, you are doing some thing wrong. You are not using the tool properly.

When doing a bowl turning demo, I turn one with a gouge only, and another with a scraper. The only real difference is that the one with the gouge finish is a bit more shiny than the scraper one. This is because the bevel rubbing does burnish the wood a bit. I have had a number of people comment to me, "I may have to rethink my views on scrapers".

The real limiting factor in how fast wood can be removed is horse power. I can stall my 3 hp Robust, in the low gear range. I talked to Bill Grumbine about this, and he commented that he could stall out a VB36, which I think has 2 hp. I haven't tried a lathe like Mike Mahoney's which I heard has a 5 hp motor. Perhaps another limiting factor is gouge sweep. A swept back gouge has in inch or more of blade you can put into the wood. A 45 degree sweep/45 degree bevel on a 5/8 gouge will have maybe 1/2 inch.

I know, "Hippy, get off your rear end and do the magazine article, pictures, DVD, tour."

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#2

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

john lucas

I'm still playing with scrapers and they do rough out a bowl pretty quick. I disagree about not rubbing the bevel with a gouge when roughing. I always rub the bevel. If I'm doing a pull cut The side is rubbing the bevel as well as the nose. I usually start at the bottom of the bowl with a pull cut and then turn it into a push cut as it goes out toward the rim. When it turns into a push cut the nose is really rubbing the bevel and so is the side. I'm taking a huge amount of wood off.

Since talking to you I've been switching back and forth when roughing using my 5/8" bowl gouge with swept back wings and my copy of the Easy rougher. It's about 50/50 on how much wear and tear my body gets. The scraper might be a little better for taking off those little knobs that stick out and hit once per revolution. I still think the bowl gouge faster for shaping the bowl.

Of course you turn a lot more bowls that I do so I will continue to play and trying different cuts.

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#3

Steven Antonucci

Three sides to every story

steven antonucci

yours, his and the truth...

I am with John in that I am absolutely rubbing the bevel when I rough with a bowl gouge, and not getting beaten up at all. I use the handle low (touching my hip- I'm 6'1" with my lathe set low for hollowing) and the flute around 10-11 o'clock. I vary the width of my shaving with a subtle twist or raising if the handle, and I actually have to exaggerate it in a demo to be seen. Folks can't get their minds around how such a small movement can create such a big difference.

Back to your original point. There is more than one way to make a bowl. We may present different ideas from time to time, but in the end, only the make knows what he or she did to get there. I suspect that the buyer doesn't know or care about cutting and scraping- so it doesn't matter what you do if you are doing it correctly.

And yes, I'd love to see a video of this in action. Perhaps we can set up a bowl turning duel between us. "When a man with a scraper meets a man with a bowl gouge, the man with the scraper is a..." :)

S

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#4

Re: Three sides to every story

Ralph Lindberg

Yup Steven, the only wrong way to turn a bowl is one that doesn't work.

As for a race, be careful of what you wish for, ever seen the you-tube video of the race between a spring-pole lathe and a Polewood (2HP) lathe?

Robin Wood (on the spring-pole) was done first, with a better formed (more consistent wall thickness) bowl.

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#5

The powered lathe won but only by a few seconds

john lucas

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#6

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

Jim Sebring

I'm a real amateur compared to you folks. I do appreciate threads like this one since I learn a whole lot. And, Reed, please do write that article.

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#7

Here's the link-enjoy and be amazed  *LINK*

john lucas


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tDgIGzw4VtA

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#8

Betty Scarpino

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

Betty Scarpino

The February issue of American Woodturner will have an article on using scrapers (primarily for spindle turning), written by Matt Lewis, based on Myron Curtis's methods. The journal was mailed to members yesterday. The online version will be posted to the AAW website February 1.

Russ Fairfield was also a proponent of using scrapers and wrote an article years ago for the journal. He might have more information about scrapers on his website. I heard that there are local volunteers who will be keeping his website up and active.

I learned to turn using scrapers exclusively and did so for many years before I was introduced to gouges and cutting in the early 1990s. I still employ scrapers often.

Reed, it looks like you've actually come close to writing the article. This is the sort of technique article that I like to have in the journal. Let me know when you are ready to "get off your ...." :) I'll be glad to help (with editing the article).

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#9

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

Grant Wilkinson

As a relative newbie to bowl turning and turning in general for all that matters, I would really appreciate any additional info on using scrapers for rough outs. My instruction to date has me using gouges and I'm getting there. But, if there are other ways to skin the bowl, I'd be interested in trying them. FWIW, I was not taught to use a shear scrape for the rough out. I use either a pull or a push cut, but I'm riding a bevel with each of them. When I lose the bevel, the result is quite exciting. :-) I do use a shear scrape to take out tear out later in the process.

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#10

Steven Antonucci

A fun contest...

steven antonucci

My club members know me well enough to know the answer to the question: So, how long did that take to make? Most of them thought I was messing with them until one day someone challenged me to "prove it".

The truth be told, if I (or Reed/RoboHippy or any competent turner) put our minds to it, you can really compress the amount of time it takes to make a bowl down to a bare minimum. I suspect that I could probably turn a bandsawn block (8x5 ish) into a ready to sand bowl in 5 minutes. We spend a lot of time fussing at the lathe (I know I do, at least), but the actual "play time" is probably only 5 minutes. (I think they timed an NFL game of 11 minutes out of 60 with action...)

If I get a minute, maybe I'll shoot a quick video...

Steve

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#11

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

Bill Howatt

On another forum somebody said the advantage of a gouge is that you can do every bowl turning task with it unlike a scraper. To prove the opposite, I turned a green cherry bowl about 8" in dia from start to finished thin-wall thickness with a scraper.

There was nothing slow about it. A good burr on the scraper will take off wood at a very respectable rate but it doesn't match the rate the green cherry would fly off the General with a bowl gouge.

Until I got my spindle gouge under better control I used to do a lot of African blackwood small spindle work with scrapers. Left a very nice finish. Of course, woods like the blackwood are ideal for scraping since they are very hard.

I get very annoyed when people say a tool is obsolete or only amateurs would use it or.... . We all have different ways of achieving the goal and we all need to have various options in our toolkits for the thorny issues that arise.

Bill

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#12

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

A Crown round-nosed 1" x 1/4" scraper was one of the first four tools that I purchased. When I turn bowls I switch from the gouge to that scraper any time that the wood wants to misbehave. The scraper also seems to catch less. Most of the time there is very little burr on it. I have never learned how to put a good burr on. Psychologically I know that I should use the gouge more but, that idea is quickly replaced by the successful completion using the scraper.

I have sinned. I have admitted my faults. Is this the first step in the twelve point program? ;)

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#13

I turned my first bowl in high school.......

JamieDonaldson

...shop class, 1959, and still have it. Laminated from cherry, walnut and poplar, scraps from the "real" woodworkers in flat shop, and the hide glue is not now in great shape. I have no recollection of what tools were used, but they were probably scrapers. I've never researched the history of early bowl gouge configurations, but still have 2 of the "bull nosed" fluted gouges in my "collection." Scrapers were undoubtedly the first turning tools, and many of us older turners probably still have those big monster scrapers in our infrequently used tool arsenals. ;)

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#14

Blessing be to you my son, for .....

JamieDonaldson

..you have sinned. For penance you must perform several extra hours of sanding! :D

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#17

Brad Vietje

Careful, Grant!

Brad Vietje

Hi Grant,

I may not have understood your post, so just to be sure, I'll offer the following: When using a gouge, riding the bevel is good -- should give you a nice cut. However, when using a scraper, stay away from that bevel! Scrapers cut without bevel support, and trying to ride that bevel can get real exciting and produce a nasty catch as the tool wedges into the wood.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#18

Re: Careful, Grant!

robo hippy

Riding the bevel with a scraper is possible, but difficult, and I would not advise it. Especially since a gouge rides the bevel a lot better. I do have one scraper with about an 80 degree bevel, and the profile looks like half of a swept back gouge, coming to a point. I use it for going across the bottom of bowls. I would not attempt the same cut with a round nose gouge. Cutting near or above the center line of the scraper, when at a shear angle puts you at a mechanical disadvantage. It can slam down flat onto your tool rest. If you are shear cutting with a scraper, best to keep off the bevel.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers and Bowls long

#19

Re: Blessing be to you my son, for .....

Grant Wilkinson

Brad: I did not intend to say that I used the bevel on my scraper, just on my bowl gouge.