Scrapers and Bowls long
robo hippy
All of God's children are different, and some of us are more different than the others.
I started fooling around with scrapers some years ago (can't remember when) just to see what those who did use them regularly knew that I didn't. Well, I found out it is a very efficient tool for roughing, when flat on the tool rest, and an excellent tool for finish/touch up cuts that remove tool marks and tear out when used in a shear/angled cut mode.
Look at it this way. I think most turners will rough a bowl blank by using a scraping cut. When you use a gouge, you have it rolled on its side, and most of the time you are pulling, although this can be pushed. Some times the gouge handle is dropped, some times it is held level. The bevel does not rub. This is some times called a shear scrape. The nose part of the gouge, because of its curved shape is shear cutting, and the flute is scraping, cutting part of the tool is at 90 degrees to the wood rotation.
My scrapers are 1 1/4 and 1 1/2 inch wide by 3/8 thick. I prefer a swept back design, so like half of a swept back bowl gouge profile. Three main advantages over a bowl gouge:
One is there is more mass which means less vibration, which reallly isn't much of an advantage, because as long as you don't hang out too far off the tool rest, vibration isn't a problem.
Two is, because of the more rounded profile, you can push or pull, keeping the steel in the wood at all times, rather than going down a bit, then coming back to the top to start another cut. Now, this is a roughing technique. Cutting with and against the grain, when removing bulk, makes no difference. You aren't trying for surface quality, you are getting 'that which is not a bowl' out of the way. This does speed things up quite a bit. Note, as you get close to final thickness/shape, you make lighter cuts, and tear out is less, then I generally will use a gouge for a final cut, and a scraper at a shear angle for any clean up. Another note here is when doing the inside, I do push and pull, just like on the outside, but, I work the rim down in stages, just like with a gouge. Under no circumstances will I use a scraper flat on the tool rest for any cut on a bowl, once the wall thickness is done, and the rest of the bowl has been hollowed out. Just touch the rim, and you can say "KABLOOIE!!!!!!!!!!!!"
Three is that when using a scraper for roughing, the chips are ejected up over the top of your hand, not across the top. So, since doing this, I have lost my bowl turning callus on my pinky finger of my left hand. I never did wear gloves.
The only reason not to use scrapers is that you don't get the practice you need to perfect gouge skills.
As for the guy who was getting beat up, and broke the tool rest, when learning any skill, if you are fighting it, you are doing some thing wrong. You are not using the tool properly.
When doing a bowl turning demo, I turn one with a gouge only, and another with a scraper. The only real difference is that the one with the gouge finish is a bit more shiny than the scraper one. This is because the bevel rubbing does burnish the wood a bit. I have had a number of people comment to me, "I may have to rethink my views on scrapers".
The real limiting factor in how fast wood can be removed is horse power. I can stall my 3 hp Robust, in the low gear range. I talked to Bill Grumbine about this, and he commented that he could stall out a VB36, which I think has 2 hp. I haven't tried a lathe like Mike Mahoney's which I heard has a 5 hp motor. Perhaps another limiting factor is gouge sweep. A swept back gouge has in inch or more of blade you can put into the wood. A 45 degree sweep/45 degree bevel on a 5/8 gouge will have maybe 1/2 inch.
I know, "Hippy, get off your rear end and do the magazine article, pictures, DVD, tour."
robo hippy






