Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Black Palm

Posts

Black Palm

#1

Black Palm

Cindy

I was just wondering if there is a trick to turning black palm? I am new at turning and my first pen is beautiful, made of eastern cherry. My second attempt was not so good. The wood seemed to come off much less smoothly. I was at the end and on my last trim and three little sections broke off to the metal. Very sad because it is beautiful wood! Help?? Thanks - Cindy

Re: Black Palm

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Black Palm

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Cindy,

I also have used black palm to make pens, it's very splintery (is that even a word?).

Before I turn it after I square the blank I soak some thin CA into the end grain and let it set up, I have found that helps hold the fibers as you near your final sizing working near the bushings. I use this CA trick on any wood I am suspicious of, last thing I want is that last pass breaking away a chip near the bushing on the "Money Cut" (Becoming the "Oh S%#@ Cut", LOL).

I work from the centre towards the edges as I turn it, so more down hill to the bushings, I use a sharp skew for this.

I hope that helps,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Black Palm

#3

Re: Black Palm

Cindy

Thanks Jim - I will try again and use your technique - I'll post the results - hopefully good ones!!

Re: Black Palm

#4

Jim Evans

Re: Black Palm

Jim Evans

Black Palm is a grass, as such a sharp tool is a must.

Re: Black Palm

#5

Re: Black Palm

Ralph Lindberg

I have been known to cheat :\

Knock the corners off with a gouge, then shape it with 36 then 40 grit J weight sand paper

No, I'm not kidding

Re: Black Palm

#6

Re: Black Palm

Keith Inscho

+1 on the thin CA. :D

Re: Black Palm

#7

Rob Wallace

Slight correction..... A palm is a palm...

Rob Wallace

.....and not a grass. Perhaps you have confused this with bamboo, which IS a grass!

Palms do not produce "normal" wood in the hardwood or softwood sense. There are no annual rings or earlywood/latewood made of dead secondary xylem cells. Therefore it wil behave differently when cutting and turning it.

Palm "wood" isn't really normal wood, per se, but is a dense collection of vascular bundles (you could call them "veins" in the stem, or trunk, of the palm) that grow together and provide structural support as the tree grows. You see these as the dark, dense, stringy material running through the piece. In some cases these vascular bundles are interlocked and fused into a tightly-branched matrix, which can be quite rigid and strong.

The reason that palm is so prone to chip out when turning (hence can be described as "splintery", as has been noted!) is that the bundles are not particularly well bonded together, unlike the cells of normal wood which are quite literally glued together with lignin. Thus, the soaking with thin CA that has been recommended provides a greater amount of bonding between the fibrous vascular bundles. The resulting "stabilized" fibers should behave more like a "normal" wood, although the dense vascular bundles are usually quite a bit harder than typical hardwood is.

It is correct that very sharp tools will help shear the bundles more easily with less energy while turning, and thus reduce the chances of fragmenting the bundles from their relatively "loose" arrangement, even when bonded with CA.

Note also that it is quite typical for palm "wood" to contain a fairly high amount of silica which has a significant (and sometimes rapid) dulling effect on turning (and other cutting) tools. This might result in having to sharpen your turning tools a bit more frequently.

Good luck!

Rob Wallace

Re: Black Palm

#8

Jim Evans

Re: Slight correction..... A palm is a palm...

Jim Evans

See, that's what I get for believing my forester friend.

Re: Black Palm

#9

Re: Slight correction..... A palm is a palm...

Cindy

Rob,

Thank you so much - that is quite helpful and informative. So much to learn, but really loving the lessons!!

Cindy

Re: Black Palm

#10

Re: Black Palm

Dick Coers

Sanding that stuff is not easy either. The "strings" are hard, the fill is really soft. So if you oversand it, the surface will not be flat. I glue sandpaper to a small board instead of using my fingers. Seems to stay smoother. In my opinion, this stuff must be related to corn. The stacks are about the same. Too bad corn stalks are all white!

Re: Black Palm

#11

Re: Black Palm

Barry Irby

Cherry to Black Palm. First Cherry and then Black Palm? Pretty much opposite ends of the spectrum. There is a lot of stuff in between. Talk about the "steep part of the learning curve". You have gotten good advice. Welcome to Wood Central if you are new here. Think of Palm as a bundle of very small of straws in sort of loose formation. The CA will help.

Re: Black Palm

#12

Yes, Rob, but...

Ralph Lindberg

There is a reason Palm is "commonly" called a grass.

It's because it's a Monocot (Monocotyledon), which includes grasses, orchids, bananas, onions, etc. But not "trees" (other then Palms)

Yes both (most) trees and Palm are flowering plants (Angiosperms). But grass is more "closely" related to Palms then to a Eudicots (hardwood), Magnoliids (Magolia and relatives) or Conifers (softwood)

Re: Black Palm

#13

Re: Black Palm

Keith Inscho

Cut a section of corn stalk, place in a vase with a bit of water, colored with your favorite food color. Let stand a few hours and the stalk will draw the color up through the veins. Let dry and you might have an interesting material for a pen.

Re: Black Palm

#14

Re: Black Palm

Nelson

If you have piece of palm wide enough make a pen with the "end grain" makes a unique pen.

Re: Black Palm

#15

Re: Black Palm

Cindy

Hi Barry,

I will ask more questions when I go to buy my blanks! I just thought it was pretty - and I have

learned that I need to use more than pretty wood!! lol

I will use the CA and see how that works - everyone here is very helpful!!

Thanks everyone!

Cindy

Re: Black Palm

#16

Rob Wallace

I agree, Ralph, but...

Rob Wallace

if the statement, "Palms are grasses" was included as an answer on one of the exams in my Plant Systematics course, I would still need to mark it wrong. Completely wrong! (....and no partial credit for, "well, palms are commelinoid monocots, so it's close enough...!" ....sorry!)

Palms are not grasses, regardless of how "relatively related" they are to other monocots, magnoliids, Eudicots, paleoherbs, Amborella, or any gymnosperms. Involving a 'habit' criterion for "tree" also isn't relevant to the argument of relatedness or classification - whether the organisms in the group are predominantly trees, shrubs, lianas/vines, herbs, etc. does not influence the conclusion that palms are not grasses, from any perspective. It probably does help to confuse the issue, and I agree that this may be a common misperception - one that we're trying to change.

Whether they are 'commonly' considered grasses or not, really isn't my point - which is to provide clarification that palms can not, and should not [ever] be correctly called "a grass", even in the most informal settings. It goes against every fabric of my being (and instincts as a professor) to allow major inaccuracies to continue when people have the capability and such easy access to correct information! People deserve to get reliable facts when they're interested in the subject and probably should know about the materials they are working with as woodturners - that's the kind of information I'm hoping to provide! Putting my money where my mouth is - my two demonstrations at the AAW Symposium this coming June will be on how to get started in identifying (and not just recognizing) wood!

Thanks also for the comments and the confirmation that others find plant systematics and classification interesting!

(and BTW - 73, DE WA0RW)

Rob Wallace

Re: Black Palm

#17

Re: I agree, Ralph, but...

Ralph Lindberg

I still recall my father telling stories of the ID classes he took in Forestry. Tables of branches with needles and cones and they had to ID them all.

My interest is a little more practical... :D