A Hypothesis
charlie belden
Because they CAN, turner's who have a BIG lathe - 2 to 3 hp motors, 20+ inch swing,
800 to 1100 pounds - tend to
a) turn BIG pieces
b) turn mainly green wood
c) turn mainly only a few types of pieces
- plates, platters, bowels, lots of natural edge bowls and some hollow forms
d) like to, or must, hog off a lot of wood quickly - before the green wood dries and
starts cracking
Turners with smaller min/mid lathes - 1/2 to 3/4 hp motors, 10" or 12" swings and
usually under 100 pounds - tend to
a) turn smaller pieces (duh!)
b) turn more dry wood than green
c) turn smaller versions of what BIG lathe turners turn
d) turn more things like lidded boxes and delicate finials which require DRY wood
that BIG lathe folks seldom do
e) favor more delicate cuts and pieces that require precision.
As one who turns on a JET Mini VS, and admittedly I may have a personal bias, it
seems to me that folks with smaller lathes tend to try more different types of turning
than do the folks with larger lathes. And I think I know why
- THE INTIMIDATION FACTOR.
Trying between centers multi-axis turning is far less intimidating when you're
playing with a 3/4" x 3/4" x 6" blank that playing with a foot long 4x4. Hollowing
a Christmas ornament sized hollow form is far less intimidating than hollowing
something 6 to 8" in diameter and 8 to 12" deep. Turning an 8" long 2x4 "propeller"
is much less intimidating than turning a 4x6 that's a foot and a half long, or longer.
If you doubt that, attend a Jimmy Clewes demo where he does one of his winged
Chinese hat lidded boxes. When his blank spins up to speed, even turners with two
or three decades of turning under their belts - get out of the line of fire REAL QUICK.
Turning a small lidded box is much less intimidating than turning a four or five
times larger lidded canister.
The perceived risk of trying something new on a smaller lathe and at a smaller size
is way lower than the risk of trying something new on a BIG lathe and at a LARGE scale.
At the smaller scale, if something goes horribly wrong, a little piece of wood - that might
bruise you and/or require a band aid (and maybe a change of underwear) - is what you
have to deal with. If something goes terribly wrong when turning a BIG piece, roof or
wall repair may be necessary and a trip to the emergency room could be involved
- perhaps followed by a hospital stay and some time in a rehab facility.
So you BIG lathe turners out there
- how often do you turn small/ smaller pieces?
- how important is it to be able to hog off a lot of wood in a hurry?
- how often do you turn dry wood?
- are there types of pieces that you just don't turnm either because they require dry
wood or seem too intimidating to try - at your usual size?
Mini/midi lathe turners out there:
- how often do you turn at the upper end of your lathe's capacity?
- how often do you turn green wood?
- are there types of pieces that you tried and succeeded in turning
that you'd never even try at a larger scale?







