Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A Hypothesis

Posts

A Hypothesis

#1

A Hypothesis

charlie belden

Because they CAN, turner's who have a BIG lathe - 2 to 3 hp motors, 20+ inch swing,

800 to 1100 pounds - tend to

a) turn BIG pieces

b) turn mainly green wood

c) turn mainly only a few types of pieces

- plates, platters, bowels, lots of natural edge bowls and some hollow forms

d) like to, or must, hog off a lot of wood quickly - before the green wood dries and

starts cracking

Turners with smaller min/mid lathes - 1/2 to 3/4 hp motors, 10" or 12" swings and

usually under 100 pounds - tend to

a) turn smaller pieces (duh!)

b) turn more dry wood than green

c) turn smaller versions of what BIG lathe turners turn

d) turn more things like lidded boxes and delicate finials which require DRY wood

that BIG lathe folks seldom do

e) favor more delicate cuts and pieces that require precision.

As one who turns on a JET Mini VS, and admittedly I may have a personal bias, it

seems to me that folks with smaller lathes tend to try more different types of turning

than do the folks with larger lathes. And I think I know why

- THE INTIMIDATION FACTOR.

Trying between centers multi-axis turning is far less intimidating when you're

playing with a 3/4" x 3/4" x 6" blank that playing with a foot long 4x4. Hollowing

a Christmas ornament sized hollow form is far less intimidating than hollowing

something 6 to 8" in diameter and 8 to 12" deep. Turning an 8" long 2x4 "propeller"

is much less intimidating than turning a 4x6 that's a foot and a half long, or longer.

If you doubt that, attend a Jimmy Clewes demo where he does one of his winged

Chinese hat lidded boxes. When his blank spins up to speed, even turners with two

or three decades of turning under their belts - get out of the line of fire REAL QUICK.

Turning a small lidded box is much less intimidating than turning a four or five

times larger lidded canister.

The perceived risk of trying something new on a smaller lathe and at a smaller size

is way lower than the risk of trying something new on a BIG lathe and at a LARGE scale.

At the smaller scale, if something goes horribly wrong, a little piece of wood - that might

bruise you and/or require a band aid (and maybe a change of underwear) - is what you

have to deal with. If something goes terribly wrong when turning a BIG piece, roof or

wall repair may be necessary and a trip to the emergency room could be involved

- perhaps followed by a hospital stay and some time in a rehab facility.

So you BIG lathe turners out there

- how often do you turn small/ smaller pieces?

- how important is it to be able to hog off a lot of wood in a hurry?

- how often do you turn dry wood?

- are there types of pieces that you just don't turnm either because they require dry

wood or seem too intimidating to try - at your usual size?

Mini/midi lathe turners out there:

- how often do you turn at the upper end of your lathe's capacity?

- how often do you turn green wood?

- are there types of pieces that you tried and succeeded in turning

that you'd never even try at a larger scale?

Re: A Hypothesis

#2

Re: A Hypothesis

john lucas

Charlie I turn mostly work under 10" on my Powermatic even though it will turn 20". The reason is simply. The heavy lathe just turns with less vibration. On the occasion when I do need larger it's there. The other reason is that smaller simply goes faster, sells easier, and it's easier to find wood that size.

As the saying goes, you can turn small on a big lathe ( I think I've proved that with my goblets) but you can't turn big on a small lathe.

Re: A Hypothesis

#3

Re: A Hypothesis

Skip Beardsley

Charlie,

How does you hypothesis extend out to those of us who have both size lathes? I find I agree with most of the things you say but not necessarily for the reasons you put forth. I turn mostly bowls because that is what sells in my limited market place. I turn green wood because mostly it is free for the asking although I have been known to purchase prepared blanks. It seems silly to me to pay fifty bucks for a nice figured maple fifteen by six bowl blank and then put ninety percent of that money on the floor, in the form of shavings.

For me, both lathes have a place in my shop, and while I use the large lathe a bit more than the mini, I would not be without it, given the choice.

Re: A Hypothesis

#4

Re: A Hypothesis

Ken Ward

I only have the Nova 1624 and turn anything from 1" 16" I turn as many larger bowls as I can,because they sell pretty good for me.,but I have turned a few larger pieces when I turn outboard,but I don't have the right outboard setup an it gets kinda scary.

Re: A Hypothesis

#5

Re: A Hypothesis

Keith Newton

Turning green doesn't require me to work fast. A spray bottle and plastic bag keeps the checking under control.

Re: A Hypothesis

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: A Hypothesis

Ellis Walentine

So you BIG lathe turners out there

- how often do you turn small/ smaller pieces?

Pretty often. I have only one lathe at the moment, so it needs to turn all the small stuff I need, from drawer pulls to ornaments to muddlers.

- how important is it to be able to hog off a lot of wood in a hurry?

Important, not. Preferred, often. Hogging is the drudge work you need to get past before the fun stuff begins, so it's good to move right along if possible. I'm not convinced that higher horsepower is needed for roughing though. I had an old J-line lathe with a 1HP motor that provided all the power I needed for roughing pieces.

- how often do you turn dry wood?

Seldom, mostly for small parts, tool handles, drawer pulls, lidded boxes and such. Occasionally I rough and dry bowl blanks, but not often. To me, the way a green wood piece moves after it's turned is part of the statement the wood makes and can be another design element.



- are there types of pieces that you just don't turn either because they require dry

wood or seem too intimidating to try - at your usual size?


I'm not intimidated by anything except the skew, and there is no usual size work that I turn, so these things aren't an issue for me.

Ellis

Re: A Hypothesis

#7

Betty Scarpino

Re: limitations lead to creative solutions

Betty Scarpino

Years ago, the primary reason I started making stands for the plates I turned was because my lathe at the time could only turn something up to about 13" diameter. I wanted my work to look larger, so creating a stand and having the stand be part of the plate was a good solution to the "wanting-it-to-look-larger" problem.

In essence, my approach was to use the limitation as a opportunity for being creative in a way that I might not have been had my lathe's capacity been much larger. Below is an image of my first "altered" plate from the mid 1990s.

So, Charlie, your hypothesis can be applied to me and my lathe at the time, for the plates, anyway.


Re: A Hypothesis

#8

Steven Antonucci

I would refute a few personally

steven antonucci

I turn mainly green wood because it is free. If I had to pay for wood, I would have to sell work faster than I could produce it. Size is not a consideration for me.

I am not particularly intimidated by anything, but I do have a very health respect for what can happen if you do something stupid. I never understand what folks are thinking sitting in the front row of a demo directly in the line of fire? Don't care who is behind the gouge, people shouldn't be there. Know what is necessary to do the job safely and the risk is minimal.

What I do think is different is HOW (not what) I turn when I am stuck on a mini-lathe (yes, I said stuck!) I cannot lean on it for stability. I cannot take big cuts without stalling the motor. I cannot start off balance and "fast" and use the lathe to find balance. I cannot turn big.

2 cents

S

Re: A Hypothesis

#9

Jim Evans

Re: A Hypothesis

Jim Evans

Charley,

One thing you forgot is which hand does the turner favor, left or right hand?

I have a Jet 1236 and a Ricon mini lathe. When I turn deeper bowls or hollow forms I like to use the Ricon because I'm left handed and it is more comfortable to turn from the back side of the lathe. I have a foot operated power switch means I don't have to lean over the lathe in order to power up or down.

When I spin at higher speeds ala Jimmy Clewes I use the Jet.

Having said that, I don't turn large vessels, larger than 12-15" in length, because of lathe and experience limitations.

Re: A Hypothesis

#10

JL

What about the middle of the road??

JL

I have a Jet 1642 EVS. By your descriptions, it is neither a big lathe or a small lathe.

I turn kiln dried wood mostly - but that is because I do furniture. I do turn larger pieces of green wood for bowls (and I have an "in" with the local National Forest Service Rangers).

Re: A Hypothesis

#11

Re: What about the middle of the road??

Norm Smith

I have one lathe , a powermatic 3520a. 95% of the wood I turn is dry.

75% could be turned on a small lathe.

Norm

Re: A Hypothesis

#12

Re: A Hypothesis

Bill Neddow

Charlie, I have a big lathe -- a Oneway 2436 with the outboard attachment so I can turn a bowl up to 48 inches in diameter. I got it because I found my market was in the over-14-inch salad bowl. Thus, the decision to buy a big lathe was determined by what I could sell. As time has gone on, my main market has moved from the 14-inch to the 18-inch bowl.

I turn both green and dry wood. I start green on the big pieces -- but use the two-stage method of turning green and finishing when dry. Over the years I have generally turned a bit more green wood than dry for bowls, so I now have about 3,500 dry bowls ready to finish. I had one on the lathe yesterday that was turned in 2001 (according to the date on the bottom). That means I am now focusing on turning my backlog, so am turning more dry wood than I ever have.

I also turn a variety of things -- even bottle stoppers. They are also turned on the Oneway. It is a little embarrassing when one of my buddies drops by and I have a bottle stopper in the chuck -- driven by a 3-hp motor. But, I find it comfortable to work on the lathe I have been using for over a decade. I bought a Nova to do the small stuff, but found I never used it. Eventually I sold it.

If one is going to sell at studio tours and through galleries, it is best to have a variety of products. An artist friend of mine calls my bottle stoppers "lunch art. She claims that:"No matter how bad the sale is, you will always sell enough bottle stoppers to buy lunch!" How true. Also, not everyone wants an 18 inch bowl. Elderly couples are often looking for a 10 inch one, because there are only two of them to eat salad.

I like to hog off the excess wood in a hurry. The American Association of Woodturners says never to use a spindle roughing gouge on the outside of a bowl. This is true, as far as it goes. The tang on most of these gouges is very fragile and tiny and will bend or break, causing an accident. This type of spindle roughing gouge should be taken off the market as it is a danger to even spindle turners. There are a couple of good spindle roughing gouges out there, one made by P&N and the other by Doug Thompson. They have good, big tangs. The one on Doug's 1 1/4 inch gouge is 3/4 of an inch thick. I use this in a solid aluminum handle to quickly clean off excess wood on the outside of a bowl. Do not, however, try to use it on the inside of a bowl. It hogs off so much wood that the spigot cannot stand the stress.

Re: A Hypothesis

#13

Re: A Hypothesis

Jorge Casta�eda

Charlie,

I have 3 lathes, the Powermatic 2035b, the Nova 3000 and the Delta Midi.

They came to me in the reverse order, and I outgrew the Delta in a very short time, the Nova allowed me to make bowls in the 14"-15" range that are my best sellers even now, but I was not able to work really fast, neither the green wood I start with most of the time, nor the second turning when the roughs are dry, so I went to the big lathe, my production doubled. Like Bill Neddow, my favorite roughing tool is a 1 1/4" roughing spindle gouge for the outside and a 3/4" bowl gouge for the inside, both from Doug Thompson, so now I rough a 16" to 18" bowl in a bout the same time I was spending to do a 12" in the Nova.

So most of my work starts with green wood, but then it dries and, so it is 50/50, but then there are the wood blanks I buy to have variety, most of this are dry and then the balance moves to something like 40% green 60% dry.

I do turn small stuff on occasion and use the Delta for that, the Nova that I dislike it for being so sloppy, mine is a lemon, is a dedicated vacuum pump station to do the foot in bowl and platters up to 16"

The Powermatic doe everything else.

Re: A Hypothesis

#14

There is a corollary to your subject Charlie,...

JamieDonaldson

.. that is especially true for beginner turners. We most often start our turning adventures on a small lathe, then soon "outgrow" its physical limitations and desire a larger and larger lathe. After a few experiences of turning larger pieces on the larger lathe, we understand the punishment that is often associated with making huge pieces! Then we are satisfied that the capability to "go big" is achieved, but smaller is much more enjoyable and less physically abusive. Has something to do with "the grass is always greener......" syndrome! :D

Re: A Hypothesis

#15

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: A Hypothesis

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I have two lathes, a full sized General and a Jet Mini. Other than size and swing I don't choose one over the other based on the lathe. I do mostly spindle turning and do choose to use the Jet mostly for pens, but I have also used the General for pens as well, just that the Jet is more portable and easier to take to shows to do my demo's and seminars.

I think power would be more important to me over size, I do all my drilling on a lathe so the General is used often for that, but that is the only Other factor that size means something to me.

I have never turned green wood, I seldom turn any wood at all now.

Same can be said for my table saw, I almost never use it, I am mostly a band saw user, the table saw is over sized for my shop and I may well one day cut the side table away or even reduce my saw needs to a smaller foot print, the Nahm saw is not important anymore for many who have learnt how amazing the band saw really is.

Take care,

Jim

Re: A Hypothesis

#16

Re: There is a corollary to your subject Charlie,.

Bill Neddow

True, Jamie. But I think you have to add age as a factor. Those big ones are getting heavier and heavier.

Re: A Hypothesis

#17

Re: A Hypothesis

robo hippy

Hmmmm.......

I have a Robust American Beauty with 3 hp, and a Jet 1224 VS. Mostly I turn bowls, so the need for the bigger lathe. Having more hp makes the roughing and finish cuts a lot easier. Seeing 1 to 1 1/2 inch wide shavings flying off is mesmerizing, especially the Madrone shavings which are pinkish, and look very pretty stacking up in the window sill with the sun shining through. I don't consider roughing to be drudgery work at all. Part of the process. I do turn some dry wood on my big lathe, rolling pins, table legs, and brush handles.

The main reason for me to turn green wood is that there is almost no big pieces of dried bowl stock, and if you do find a piece, it costs a lot more than fire wood.

I bought the mini lathe for one reason only, and that was for turning threaded boxes. Took a workshop with Bonnie Klein. Finally found a good use for all those pieces I couldn't throw away or burn. Don't really turn anything else on it. I have turned only one pen.

I am getting out of production work, and will be doing more art work. I will probably do 99% of it on the Robust. It is a lot easier to work on, and the power makes for more efficient roughing work, and being dainty (finish cuts) doesn't depend on your lathe, it depends on your tools.

The variable speed on a 3 phase motor is hugely superior to the dc motor.

My favorite tool for roughing the outside of a bowl is a scraper. It really outperforms any gouge out there.

My favorite tool for roughing out the inside of a bowl is the McNaughton. Most cored bowls are then finish cut with a gouge, and finished with gouge and bowl scraper at shear angle. If the bowl isn't cored, I use a scraper for roughing.

robo hippy

Re: A Hypothesis

#18

Re: A Hypothesis

Bill Howatt

I don't fit the hypothesis.

Like others it seems:

I turn green because it is free. My General is 20", 2HP but vast majority of stuff is under 12" and hardly ever do I come near the 20" inboard limit. Extra dia is handy for sliding banjo and steadies around under the workpiece.

Most recent work was blackwood column and finial with diameter of 1/16". Never turned a pen until I got the 20" lathe.

Like they say, you can turn small stuff on a big lathe but not the other way around. Like the heft, power and electronic VS of the lathe.

Re: A Hypothesis

#19

Steven Antonucci

Outside with a scraper faster than a bowl gouge?

steven antonucci

I have to assume that you have the wood with the grain perpendicular to the ways, and in both cases you are cutting in via the face grain? I can't imagine that the scraper would beat a bowl gouge for roughing...expecially if you are pulling 1-1.5" per cut (I don't have the HP to make more than a 1" cut on the wings...)

On a good day, I am round in one pass. Bowl shaped in 3-4. How much faster can you do it with a scraper? Must be some pretty big steel?

S

Re: A Hypothesis

#20

Mike Stafford

Re: A Hypothesis

Mike Stafford

I chose to buy a Stubby because of its versatility and stability. I can turn boxes on it and I can turn large platters on it which is something I wanted to do before I bought my lathe. All I have to do is slide the bed a smidgen and I can turn platters up to 30". I am still looking for the right piece of wood to do that....

The stability that this lathe affords is wonderful as I have proven on a number of occasions that I can stand a nickel on edge while the lathe is running and it will remain standing. It is also very quiet.

I have a Jet mini and I can stall it while hollowing boxes unless I take it slow. It is a fine machine within its limitations.

Re: A Hypothesis

#21

That Brings Back Memories

Barbara Gill

Back when I firsst joined a turning clum we had a guest turner who said a scraper was all anyone needed for turning a bowl. That demonstration was hard to watch. It was painful to watch how his arms vibrated as he took off the wood. The tool rest broke with the stress. The last I heard there was supposed to be some sort of contest between the scraper and bowl gouge.

All I could think of while the demo was going on was " why would anyone want to use a scraper when we have bowl gouges?".

Re: A Hypothesis

#22

Re: A Hypothesis

charlie belden

john:

Every rule has an exception that proves the rule. Your micro-goblets turned on a BIG lathe is the exception to my hypothesis that If You Have A BIG Lathe You Usually Turn BIGGER Pieces.

Skip:

Ah the dangers of assumptions. I was assuming that most turners have limited floor space and/or money - and therefore only have ONE lathe - at a time. Having come to turning from Flat Work, I only had a small corner of a four car garage left in which to fit a lathe. And having blown my woodworking budget on all the stuff for Flat Work, there was a budget constraint by the time I got to purchasing a lathe. I also saw the lathe as merely a way of quickly making round pegs, drawer pulls, magic wands for kids in the neighborhoodand maybe a finial or two for a piece of furniture. I had no exposure to turning and therefore had no idea of what COULD be done using a lathe - and chucks - and the host of turning tools and techniques I NOW know of.

Starting with, and staying with, a small lathe and turning things that are interesting or fun to turn has kept it fun. I'm not tempted to turn Stuff That Sells and thus perhaps turn things that I find not interesting and/or not fun to make. I can satisfy my "I wonder if I could . . ." apparent creative need. Had I a NEED to earn part of my living by turning I'm sure the flatwork equiptment would have been sold and the money would be spent on a VB36in keeping with my Buy Once, Cry Once approach to machines.

Keith:

Coming from Flat Work, the idea of intentionally spraying water on or around cast iron surfaces gets me clenching my jaws - RUST Is THE Enemy. Keeping it at bay is a constant battle. That bias may not be applicable to lathes but I doubt I can get pased my Fear Of Rust.

Ellis:

With your ability to approach challenges methodically and given the range of woodworking pieces you've done I'm surprised that you're intimidated by a skew - my favorite turning tool.

Betty:

You bring up one of the benefits of having limiations - thinking up creative ways around what at first seem like limitations. Faced with unlimited capability/capacity it's easy to find something you like - and stay with it - just doing it bigger and bigger. I Go With What I Know - or - I Go With What I Know Will SELL can become a barrier to further exploration. With smaller lathes with limited capacity - in terms of SIZE - one may find, after running up a capacity limitation for a particular type of piece, other types of pieces to try. And once that creative view of things gets going - and is reinforced by success - it tends to be self perpetuating.

Steve:

Personally, if I have to "lean into" the work I figure I must be doing something wrong.

If it's an out of round starting point that wants to shake. rattle and roll the lathe - MORE WEIGHT ca, up to a point, take care of that problem.

In stick framing, it was always the Long Hammer kids that would show off how they could drive a nail with one blow. The reality was that they couldn't drive a day's worth of nail with one blow each. The older hands COULD drive a nail in a few more blows, but could keep that up all day, all week or 'til the framing was done.

Bill:

like several other respondents that sell their piece, you turn for your market. Makes total sense - if you're selling your work. But I'd ventured that only a small percentage of turners out there turn pieces to sell either in order to Support The Habit, or supplement the household income. Most turners probably turn for the fun and enjoyment, satisfying a need to be creative - to make something.

You're description of being almost embarassed getting caught turning a bottle stopper on you lathe is probably pretty common. Big capacity - big turnings.

Jamie:

It may be a Siddhartha thing - the need to leave your starting point behind, go out and see the world, finally returning somewhere near where you began.

Re: A Hypothesis

#23

Limitations that Produce Great Things *LINK*

Jennifer Indy.USA

Betty I think one of the most wonderful use of one's limitations that I've seen is when you were in residence at The University of Indiana, PA. They had new lathes on order with a 20" swing or something like that but for weeks all you had was a lathe with a 10" swing and so instead of you stalling until the new larger swing lathes arrived, you looked beyond your altered platters and used the length of the lathe to start something new. The result was your series of tall, slender, pod cuddling sculptures that I have always loved. It was a wonderful use of your limited lathe swing and looking beyond what we are comfortable and familiar with. I LOVE this seres of yours and would love to see more!

Jen


PS: I think you should post your swimming spider picture :)


Betty's Work

Re: A Hypothesis

#24

Re: Limitations that Produce Great Things

charlie belden

It's fun to play Outside The Box. This piece is an example of playing Inside The Box - and finding a little corner inside which was unexplored - then exploiting it. To most, a padded cell would be unpleasantly restraining. To a gymnist/acrobat, a padded cell is six surfaces to play on - semi-safely.

HOW you look at things determines WHAT you see. Rather than focus on what CAN'T be done, if you focus on what CAN be done - interesting pieces can result - as this piece Betty did clearly shows. Limitations can present opportunities to think - and see - things differently. There's a lot to be found in a little slice of the big pie.