Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Curly willow: offer and/or question

Posts

Curly willow: offer and/or question

#1

Curly willow: offer and/or question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some time in the next few weeks, we're going to dig out a small curly willow tree. Curly willow branches grow in this strange spiral/wiggly shape (the trees remind me of Bob Dylan from his early electric stage, about the "Blonde on Blonde" album, on). I'm not clear whether the grain pattern continues when the branches turn to trunk.

The question is this: is this worthy turning wood?

This is a small tree: 10" across at the butt, with the main trunk being 6" or so, about five feet high. If it is something worth turning, and you're interested, you'd have to pick it up in Sebastopol, CA (an hour north of San Francisco).

If this is worthwhile turning wood but no one here is local and/or interested, I'll offer it on Craigslist for a turner (or at the Habitat store - not sure if they do this kind of thing or not); so I am interested in knowing whether this wood turns well and interestingly.


Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

Jesper, Denmark

Willow is usually not worth turning.

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#3

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

Terry Scott

Maybe for mushrooms but not for much else

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

Rob Wallace

Bill:

Willow wood is not very good for turning in general - it's even not of any real value for burning wood either. I remember the line from a Boy Scout poem on choosing firewood, ".....and willow wood is never used, by a camper keen." If burned, its high water content robs fires of heat, and also stinks pretty badly too.

Even if the tree were much larger to save some decent sized blanks (10" really isn't that big), willow wood is very fibrous, relatively soft, and does not have much color or any attractive figure. People tend to avoid it entirely for any kind of useful application. About the best thing it is used for is landscaping and soil stabilization in wet areas where few other trees will grow. I wouldn't waste my time on saving any of it. I tried turning willow ONCE, just to say I did, and promptly discarded the two bowls I turned.

Try it if you want, but don't expect too much in terms of 'quality'.

Rob Wallace

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#5

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

Terry Quiram

Turn the wood for the experience. It will make you a better turner for having dealt with different wood conditions. Besides you never know what the wood looks like until get inside. You may have a gem.

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#6

Sauna

Jorge Casta�eda

Rob,

When I lived in upstate New York, a flood uprooted a huge willow, the owner of the property, a japanese gent, had it milled into 1" boards and put it aside to dry.

The following year I was hired to build him a sauna, the building itself from hemlock and the benches and paneling from the willow.

It is widely used in Japan for this purpose, as it contains no resin, it is the safest wood, you never get burnt when sitting on the hot bench or resting in the paneling.

My $0.02

Jorge

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#7

Denis Putland

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

Denis Putland

Hi

Here is a picuture of a willow crotch piece.

A very soft wood but can be rewarding at times,

Denis

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#8

Steve Kubien

You can...

Steve Kubien

...carve some pretty and functional spoons from willow. The piece on the left with the S-like curve looks promising. Split it along that S-like and seal up the ends for a while. Then, get yourself some spooncarving kit from Del Stubbs. HUGE FUN!!!!

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#9

Thanks all

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I didn't make clear that I'm not interested in it for my own turning - getting back to turning requires finding room for a lathe in my shoplet, something not happening any time soon (although I have two lathes lined up and ready to install, if I ever figure out how to fit one in, or get a larger shop).

Right up to Denis Putland's post, it sounded like this wasn't worth offering; but I think I may put the word out there on local For Free! listing sites before schlepping it off to the yard waste sites for composting.

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#10

NOT SO FAST !

bill Crommett

I keep a chunk of black Willow around to replace any chunk of bark I knock off when turning a natural edge piece. Just sand down a piece of bark to dimension and match, then glue it in place.

A story about Black Oak: A tree removal man gave me an equipment trailer load of Black Willow logs about thirty inches in diameter. I cut a section off and buried three wedges in it trying to split it. It took two chainsaw blades to retrieve my wedges so I hauled the logs out to the sawmill to be sawed into paneling planks for my basement recreation room. After several months and many calls to the mill I drove out to see what the hold-up was. The sawmill was gone, the lot was empty and no one knew who was the miller or what happened. I was glad the logs were free.

Re: Curly willow: offer and/or question

#11

Re: NOT SO FAST !

Barbara Gill

Bill when I was younger I had customers bring me logs like that. I couldn't disappear though so I ended up sawing them. LOL