Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

"Bowl Saver" geometry?

Posts

"Bowl Saver" geometry?

#1

"Bowl Saver" geometry?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

I am doing a project for a friend, turning a 16-18" shallow bowl to be used as a fruit bowl for her table. I have a blank that is 18" square and 4" thick.

Is a "bowl saver' type device capable of coring out a shallow 'blank' from this one? Shew wants a second smaller 12" bowl/platter as well and I've love to get both out of this blank.

Henry

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#2

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

John Veerkamp

With the McNaughton the large knife set can do this for you. Coring this wide shallow form will take some care. I use the tail stock to support the piece until most of the way done. The torque out on the edge is pretty fierce.

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#3

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

Barry Irby

Geometry is the correct question. The coring tools must cut a segment of a circle, which when rotated generates he surface that is the segment of a sphere. You can "fold" the tool inward and create something akin to the tip of a football, but if you try to go Te other way and open the tool up to get a surface larger than the radius of the tool, you can end up with a shape similar to the end of an apple. I tried to do it with my 12" knife and ended up with the inner platter (the core) have a dimple in the bottom that nearly came through the bottom.

Take a large compass or trammel point and draw the arc that would lie within your blank and then see if your cutter can follow that arc.

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#4

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

Bruce Pratt

With the largest Oneway knife (16"), you should be able to get approximately a 12"-13" core out of the the block with a 1/2" - 1" wall thickness at the base of your outside bowl. Very strongly recommend that you check with Oneway for specifics on the geometry and measurements before purchasing their system. If you don't already have a coring system, this is going to be a very expensive bowl.

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#5

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

Bill Neddow

Perfectly correct. There is a myth out there that you can only make different "shapes" with a McNaughton. I use the Oneway exclusively and do this all the time. Use a bigger than normal knife and set it to go shallow. And -- check the geometry.

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#6

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

I do not already have a coring system, and have no immediate plan to acquire one. Hence my lack of knowledge on the capabilties of these types of systems.

Actually i was hoping that someone near me might consider coring this blank for me. However before I put that request out there, I wanted to know if the geometry was even do-able.

Thanks

Henry

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#7

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

robo hippy

Henry,

It is definitely doable. I would not recommend that you get a coring system for just this one project. If you are taking it to some one else, have the outside profile done, and a recess or tenon on the back side. Do ask the person who is coring it for you what they need. If you lived near me I would do it.

My preference is for the McNaughton. It has the flattest curve blade, which would be more suitable for this job in my opinion.

robo hippy

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#8

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

What Bill said...

So tired of this line of thinking. But I have realized that swimming uphill is not worth the effort.

I have owned both, and am very happy with the options I have with the Oneway.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: "Bowl Saver" geometry?

Steve Kubien

The same sort of thing can be done with the Woodcut Bowl Saver/Centre Saver (whatever it's called) but to a lesser degree because the large blade is so much smaller than the Oneway blades. Still, if it was your only option, better than nothing.