Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Your assistance would be appreciated.

Posts

Your assistance would be appreciated.

#1

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Your assistance would be appreciated.

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Friends,

As some of you may be aware I regularly test products and submit my findings to "Woodturning" magazine here in the UK.

I am about to test run Pentacryl, Polycryl and Wood Juice from the USA.

They are not very well known over here and since it is an American product I would appreciate the views of those most likely to have tried it for themselves.

I have studied the web site of the manufacturers and will of course have my own findings eventually but I would really appreciate personal experiences from you.

If you think the products are rubbish, I would still like to know your reasons.

I have a limited amount of each for test so will be using ONLY a brush method with each.

Please email me, unless you feel your experiences are of use to the members of the forum.

Regards Peter.

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

#2

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

Sam Scalzo

Peter,

I have used the Pentacryl here in Arizona and have been very pleased with it. Have not used the other two products.

Sam

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

#3

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

Fred Holder

Pentacryl is the only one of the products that I have any experience with. I first became involved with in in 1998. In August 1999, I published the following:

Pentacryl is a different product that can just be painted on the wood. You should paint it on until the wood will take no more. I recently turned (1999) a wet redwood bowl, rough turned to a 1-1/2" wall thickness and painted with

Pentacryl. I dump some Pendacryl into the bowl and paint the inside and then

held the bowl up and painted the outside.

The endgrain areas are most important. I sat that bowl on the shelf and two weeks later it was very light. So, I final turned it, the chips coming off were dry. On a 15 inch diameter rough turned bowl there was a 1/8" difference between the two directions. There were no cracks and it sanded very well. I had to cut away the pith which had a damaged area so that the final diameter was 13-1/8". I did the same with a walnut bowl, but haven�t final turned it yet (in 1999). It doesn�t seem to be cracking nor does it seem to be warping much. Other than some top blanks that dried in about a month, without cracking, and turned beautifully, I have no other experience with Pentacryl. It supposedly stabilizes

wet wood, but I don�t think it can harden punky wood. It doesn�t seem to

affect any finish material that I�ve tried, but they say it can give you problems with sanding. I had no problems on my stuff.

Incidentally, the walnut bowl turned out very good. That was eleven years ago.

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

#4

Steven Antonucci

It does what it says...but

steven antonucci

I won't use it any more.

Multiple reasons:

1.) Imparts a very "oil-like" color cast to the color of the object

2.) Smells bad, and that smell doesn't go away for a long time (years...)

3.) Cost ($16/qt the last time I bought it)

4.) Finishing issues (sanding clogged the paper so I used a lot more paper, trouble getting finish to absorb...)

That said, I haven't touched the stuff in 10 years... so my info might be dated.

Let us know what you figure out.

Steve

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

#5

Re: It does what it says...but

Peter Lamb

You might like to try Cedar Shield also called Turners Choice. This product is for use in treating green wood. Made by Cedarcide in Texas. I use it a lot and am very pleased with the results. Soak for 24 hours wait for 72 hours and turn no matter how green. No split, cracks and very little distortion.

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

#6

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

John Scheideman

I'm with Steve. Same experience at about the same time. I've never again used it.

John

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

#7

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

john lopez

I've used it with good results.

Yeah, it does smell funny but not terrible.

I think the label says safe and biodegradable.

I would probably still not want to use it on food implements.

I had some red ironbark that came to me green

but highly figured.

Using the pentacryl kept it from moving so

there was very little wasted wood.

Would I use it again ?

Yes but only on very special timber.

Re: Your assistance would be appreciated.

#8

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

My thanks to all who responded.

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)