Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Why it's tough to make a living turning

Posts

Why it's tough to make a living turning

#1

Steven Antonucci

Why it's tough to make a living turning

steven antonucci

Walking through the Morrocan Pavilion at Epcot the other day, I spied this little box made from Thuya Burl. The fit and finsh on the exterior look to be about 400 grit and the lid fit tightly with a pop when opened.


I picked this one because I thought it had the best burl figure, although some were better shapes. It was $9.75 before taxes. At Disneyworld! (water costs $4)

It is a fine illustration of why it's tough to make a living as a turner.

Steven

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

Mike Stafford

It would be tough to buy a piece of thuya burl large enough to turn a box that size for $9.75 plus tax.... :(

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I thought it would be at least $15...

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Any one sign the bottom?

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#4

If it was periced it would be at least $25.. 

Dave Belser

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#5

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

Eduardo sarmiento

I see that everyday here in lima,I make all sorts of things in the lathe exept pens ans mortars ans any pyrografy etc a bunch of french pen makers came to lima to see the sigths and to show theirs pens 40us and up a kid made one pen far better than theirs with a nail and sold it for 50 cents and this guys left the country for ever,andy wolfe is very good,but here woman with a nail will carve a complete city on a gore for 10 bucks she could not even make a horse and this woman will eat her alive,ellis has been here and he has seen what this artisans can do for pennies,my2c

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#6

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

Donna Banfield

Steve, your post makes me feel very sad.

However, I love to turn and carve, and if I can do what I love, that makes me feel much better. Doesn't put food on the table, but hey, I could stand to drop a few pounds anyway ;^)

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#7

Steven Antonucci

Thought the same thing

steven antonucci

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#8

Steven Antonucci

Faceless turner working in obscurity

steven antonucci

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#9

Steven Antonucci

Good point- probably turned with minimal tools too

steven antonucci

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#10

Steven Antonucci

I am sure the maker puts food on the table turning

steven antonucci

I think one of my points was that we sometimes take this stuff too seriously. Here is an example of a finely crafted item, probably turned on a crude lathe with homemade tooling made by expert hands that the world will never know.

In addition, there maker probably got less than a dollar for this piece and most of that $9.75 is in someone else's hands. I suspect that in the maker's eyes, this is a good deal, otherwise he would probably sell fewer many fewer pieces and live much poorer.

Some sort of social undertones in my original post (value of water vs craft, etc)and thoughts on capitalism, living simply, appreciation of craft (even if it isn't a signed Stafford ;) )...

Steve

P.S. The Japanese shop sold small kokeshi dolls (3") for $40...more thoughts in that to compare and contrast with what we already know....

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#11

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

Barry

The Thuya Burl blank would cost much more than that!

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#12

maker somewherenear bejing

bob davis

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#13

Ellis Walentine

Lotta bargains in Peru

Ellis Walentine

You're right, Eduardo, there are a lot of Peruvian artists and craftsmen who are able to work very cheaply, at least compared to US or European artists. We saw some very accomplished original art in Miraflores for truly bargain basement prices. So affordable that our son bought 40 or 50 paintings and sold them here in the US for several times the price.

On another note, we found out the hard way that even Peruvian artisan prices can't compete with Chinese knockoffs, at least in the ceramics business. I imagine that holds for woodworking too.

Ellis

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#14

Steven Antonucci

It says it was made in Morocco?

steven antonucci

Hope that truth in advertising means something.

S

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#15

As I remember in my pea brain, Morocco.....

JamieDonaldson

...is a regular source for thuya, as well as briar for high quality smoking pipes.

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#16

Steven Antonucci

Correct, sir!

steven antonucci

Everything in the shop was supposedly made in Morocco, and everything wood was made from thuya burl. It must grow on trees there!

S

Re: Why it's tough to make a living turning

#17

carl

Re: Correct, sir!

carl

Was there any curly maple, hickory, ash, sycamore, cypress. What would the price be if they would have to import these woods. I bet it would not be $9.75. And i bet the craftsman/women would throw up their hands and say, " sorry,not for that price" and as a result they would not be relying on crafts for the tourists. Here in the USA we offer almost all woods, not just native woods. Carl