Going Carbide
Jim in River Oaks, Ont.
Hi All,
A few weeks ago I began to investigate using a carbide tool when working with man made materials for pens. I have been using standard HSS skews for a long time, they work with great quality and efficiency for most of my turning, but with my pen work now being mostly acrylics and Tru Stone I have been dealing with some issues that impact my quality and also my yield at the lathe.
The biggest issue I have had is heat, as my HSS tools try to cut a man material they dull faster so I spent more time honing and resharpening, this is not a problem but just that the duration of the edge is a shorter period of time and thus the cut quality degrades too quickly. Heat builds up and a few things happen, the material expands on the mandrel (going out of round quickly), the glue bond heats up and can break easily (CA or even epoxy) and the material itself can crack as it absorbs heat differentially through the blank as it is being turned.
Another factor is material hardness, some are so hard that even with attentive honing and sharpening it would take you 5-10 times longer that what most would consider an appropriate amount of time to turn, increasing fatigue and stress and opportunity for failure of the turning, DAMHIKT, LOL.

I borrowed a carbide tool from a friend this weekend and put it to the test, turning the three hardest Tru Stones I know, the Dino, Blue Lapis and black Onyx.
Here are my results,



On the softer Tru Stones it was a breeze, so smooth and clean were the cuts my sanding schedule started at 400 rather than 320.


I found that they turned with a lot let heat, a cleaner quality of cut and smoother control movement. The only issues I had were learning how to control the round carbide cutter as with a skew , the carbide tool has it�s clean advantage of cut, but tool control is a skill to be learnt. With the skew the bevel is my guide, with the carbide my index finger against my tool rest was critical to control depth of cut and also traverse the length of the pen.
I will be looking at some carbide tools on the market to see what else is out there, I think my dependency on the skew has just shifted to carbide.
Take care,
Jim





