Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Going Carbide

Posts

Going Carbide

#1

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Going Carbide

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi All,

A few weeks ago I began to investigate using a carbide tool when working with man made materials for pens. I have been using standard HSS skews for a long time, they work with great quality and efficiency for most of my turning, but with my pen work now being mostly acrylics and Tru Stone I have been dealing with some issues that impact my quality and also my yield at the lathe.

The biggest issue I have had is heat, as my HSS tools try to cut a man material they dull faster so I spent more time honing and resharpening, this is not a problem but just that the duration of the edge is a shorter period of time and thus the cut quality degrades too quickly. Heat builds up and a few things happen, the material expands on the mandrel (going out of round quickly), the glue bond heats up and can break easily (CA or even epoxy) and the material itself can crack as it absorbs heat differentially through the blank as it is being turned.

Another factor is material hardness, some are so hard that even with attentive honing and sharpening it would take you 5-10 times longer that what most would consider an appropriate amount of time to turn, increasing fatigue and stress and opportunity for failure of the turning, DAMHIKT, LOL. ;) :( :\ :)

I borrowed a carbide tool from a friend this weekend and put it to the test, turning the three hardest Tru Stones I know, the Dino, Blue Lapis and black Onyx.

Here are my results,

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

On the softer Tru Stones it was a breeze, so smooth and clean were the cuts my sanding schedule started at 400 rather than 320.

Photobucket

Photobucket

I found that they turned with a lot let heat, a cleaner quality of cut and smoother control movement. The only issues I had were learning how to control the round carbide cutter as with a skew , the carbide tool has it�s clean advantage of cut, but tool control is a skill to be learnt. With the skew the bevel is my guide, with the carbide my index finger against my tool rest was critical to control depth of cut and also traverse the length of the pen.

I will be looking at some carbide tools on the market to see what else is out there, I think my dependency on the skew has just shifted to carbide.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Going Carbide

#2

Re: Going Carbide

john lucas

Jim I don't know which carbide tool you are using but with the Hunter tool you do have a bevel to ride. It's small and for turning pens you have to find the right angle. I will go to the shop and put a small piece in the chuck and photograph the angle I use for pens. There was a learning curve as it wasn't the same as I use for bowls and platters.

I like these tools for 2 reasons. One is the sharpening angle is equal or less than my skews so it gives a cleaner cut, the other of course is that I never sharpen them. I don't use really abrasive material like you do so I will be interested in your results.

Re: Going Carbide

#3

Alan Zenreich

Re: Going Carbide

Alan Zenreich

I use Easy Wood Tools carbide chisels for acrylics, Tru-Stone, M3 metal, Inlace Acrylester (very brittle stuff) and corian.

With a fresh edge I can quickly go from turning acrylic directly to MicroMesh.

I find that these tools dramatically cut the time necessary to produce pens from these materials AND yield very high quality results.

Can't ask for much more than that.

Re: Going Carbide

#4

Alan Zenreich

Re: Going Carbide

Alan Zenreich

I forgot to mention, that strangely, I use the round cutter for "roughing" pen blanks. For finish cuts I use either a square or radiused square cutter. I also rather like the rounded diamond shaped tool for some detail work.

Cool toys.

Re: Going Carbide

#5

JL

Honing carbide?

JL

How do you hone/sharpen your carbide turning tools then?

I've touched up router bits with a diamond paddle. I have a replacement "tip" for my Hunter tool, eventually I'll need another after a while.

I usually sharpen my HSS tools as needed. I don't really have a set-up for sharpening carbide (just ask the sharpening service I use for my table saw blades). Do you have replacement tips available and send off the old ones as needed? Do you hone/sharpen with diamond paddles?

TIA

Re: Going Carbide

#6

Re: Honing carbide?

john lucas

JL I've used my #4 Hunter off and on for over 2 years. I've rotated it occasionally but it's still cutting well. The replacement cutters aren't that expensive. I think it would be pretty easy to make a jig to hold on in a drill press. Then you could just put a diamond hone against it.

Re: Going Carbide

#7

Hunter tool usage photo

john lucas

This is a Hunter #4. The #5 would work well also. The tool is rotated about 45 degrees and rubbing the bevel so I have control of the cut and shape. This photo the tool is going from left to right. If you rotate the cutter 45 degrees the other direction you can cut from right to left.

Re: Going Carbide

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Is that a carbide on the tool??

Re: Going Carbide

#9

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

Mike Brazeau

Jim - they are two entirely different designs. The tool you used is a scraper. The Hunter tool cutting action is more like a gouge and make a shearing cut. It is made from an extremely fine carbide. Have a look at Mike Hunter's website and you will see the difference. I have a couple of them if you want to see one. Won't let you use it on stone though. Does an awesome job on endgrain wood like boxes and vessels.

Re: Going Carbide

#10

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

john lucas

It is solid carbide but the edge is very thin which is why it cuts so cleanly. It is very sharp. Much better than carbide router bits. I have not tried cutting anything with stone in it yet. I did try cutting aluminum and brass and it does cut those.

Re: Going Carbide

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Thanks Mike,

I have not paid attention to turning tools for a long time, I have never heard of these.

When is the next GHWG meeting?

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Going Carbide

#12

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

Vince Welch

I too have started using Hunter tools and the carbide tip does leave a very nice tool finish. In fact, I have started carrying Hunter tools on my site. Shipping is included with the purchase of abrasives. John is correct the replacement cutters are not real expensive and the cutter tips last a very long time. Definitely worth looking into too.

Vince

Re: Going Carbide

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

Mike Stafford

I use Hunter tools for many operations. The harder the material the better the Hunter tool cut its. For end grain work I have not found anything that will cut better. With careful tool control and a high RPM (Hunter tools seem to like higher RPM) it is possible to achieve a cut surface on most woods that needs little sanding. Frequently I am starting my sanding on the inside of my boxes at 320. Sometimes I don't sand at all and just buff the surface with a non-abrasive pad.

The Hunter carbide cutters remain sharp for a long, long, long time. Did I mention that the cutters last a long time? :b

Re: Going Carbide

#14

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

Mike Brazeau

Hi Jim.

A week Thurday, the 20th. Annual Meeting & Eugen Schlaak on Sanding & Buffing.

Re: Going Carbide

#15

Re: Hunter tool usage photo

Grant Wilkinson

Jim: I mentioned in another thread you started that I use a Hunter on all sorts of pen blanks now. I have the number 5 Hunter. I bought it to do the inside of bowls, but quickly found out that it does a very good job on all of the man made materials that we use for pens. I've tried the more square carbides, too - the ones typically sold as replacements for Helix heads. They do the job, but not as well as the Hunter's do. The edge on the Hunter is much finer and the bevel angle is different. FWIW

Re: Going Carbide

#16

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Thanks Mike

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I will see you then, could you please bring a Hunter with you please.

take care,

Jim

Re: Going Carbide

#17

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Thanks Grant

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Grant,

I appreciate that you wrote, I know you understand my concerns with hard pen materials. I am also concerned with a supplier in Canada, I do not buy across the border if I can help it, I like to keep my money here in Canada supporting a Canadian. Where did you source your Hunter and what do you do for replacement cutters?

Take care,

Jim

Re: Going Carbide

#18

Re: Thanks Mike

Nelson

Jim, I have a Hunter tool and Easy Wood Tools,both are good tools and are a joy to use,I have sharpend the EWT using a 8000 diamond stone because they are flat you can do this. Because the Hunter cutters are dished out and a very thin I think it would be impossible to sharpen them. The cutters last a long time and are not that expensive so its best just to buy new ones.

Re: Going Carbide

#19

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Thanks Grant

Lyle Jamieson

Mike (Hunter) is traveling today, but when he sees this thread Im sure he can let you know of a Canada source. They are correct the Hunter, Nanograin carbide cutters can not be sharpened. They are designed to be replaced. Yes, they will last a long, long time.

Re: Going Carbide

#20

Steve Kubien

Re: Thanks Grant

Steve Kubien

Call John at Woodchuckers. I know he carries the #1 for the Jamieson hollowing rig. I believe he carries others.

Re: Going Carbide

#21

Re: Thanks Grant

Grant Wilkinson

Jim: I bought mine directly from Mike Hunter. I see that others have said that John at Woodchuckers is carrying them. You've likely dealt with John. He is great. I don't see Hunters on his site, but he may well have them.