Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

A Chuck Gripping Question

Posts

A Chuck Gripping Question

#1

A Chuck Gripping Question

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Let�s say I have a blank that I have carefully turned, between centers, to a five inch diameter cylinder. I am now ready to cut a tenon on one end of my blank so I can get some serious chuck gripping established.

Let�s also assume that I only have one set of jaws for my chuck and that they will compression grip between 1.5 and 3.0 inches.

For maximal gripping power, should I make my tenon just slightly larger than 1.5 inches, thus placing most of the chuck�s diameter in contact with the wood; or, should I cut the tenon just under 3.0 inches so I will have a larger diameter enclosed in the chuck, albeit with gaps between the fully expanded jaws?

Are the jaws of a fully expanded scroll chuck weaker? Does the greater diameter of the fully extended chuck outweigh the nearly continuous band of steel when the chuck is close to minimal diameter? Does the size/weight of the blank come into play?

I have pondered this situation for over five years and I can see it both ways? Does anyone have any convincing mathematical proof, or other evidence, one way or the other?

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

keith tompkins

Hi Emmett, Think about this for a minute...turn a big dowel, 3" diameter on one end, and one inch diameter on the other. You hold the one inch end, I'll hold the three inch end. Each of us tries to rotate the dowel in opposite directions...I have the mechanical advantage, and would easily twist the dowel out of your hands. In your comparison, the jaws are holding by the same surface area in either case, but the larger tenon has the mechanical advantage.

It's probable that the jaws make better contact with the tenon near where the jaws form a perfect circle.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#3

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

Jim Sebring

SOP is to turn the tenon to just slightly over the jaws closed size to get max contact area on the blank.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#4

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

robo hippy

I would want to get another set of jaws for the chuck so they are closer to 3 inches. Some chuck jaws have serrated edges, which will bite into the wood. Never used them. I do use dove tailed jaws as they have a mechanical advantage over straight jaws. Another point to consider is how long is the cylinder. If it is 3 to maybe 6 inches, you might be able to get away with a smaller tenon. If it is longer, you want a bigger tenon, and a steady rest.

robo hippy

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#5

Leo Cuellar

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

Leo Cuellar

The orientation of the wood grain also comes into play. If you are working a piece with the grain running with the lathe you can work with a smaller diameter tenon. A cross grain piece will need the larger tenon to resist splitting off at the chuck if you put any sideways force on the piece without supporting the opposite end.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#6

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

john lucas

My take on this. When you expand the jaws you are only gripping by 8 small points. If you use the 1/5" setting you have almost a complete grip. That's why Oneway developed those odd shaped jaws. In my opinion they have more grip over a wider range but less grip at any range than the mostly closed jaws.

Now we are assuming you have a solid piece of wood. If I suspect the wood being weak at all, such as punky then I go with the larger tenon.

My preference of course as Robbo said, use bigger jaws and close them down.

I'd love to figure out a Mythbusters style test to see. Perhaps a piece of wood bored to hold a very long metal bar. Then you slide a weight out the bar until it pulls the wood from the chuck. The further it goes the stringer the grip. Or maybe you could simply attach a set of large fish scales to the end and pull down checking the force until it pops. I'm guessing we would have to put metal straps around the wood to keep it from splitting while applying the force. I may actually have the equipment to do that test if I have a piece of wood I want to ruin. I have a chunk of pine but I think you want something harder for this test although I suspect the wood is where the failure accurs, not the jaws so maybe a soft wood will tell us something.

I need a break from cleaning the other house so I might just do this tomorrow.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#7

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

John Veerkamp

As others have said, there are many factors at play here. I usually don't worry too much about the Holding power of the tenon size, but focus more of what I'm turning. Depending on the size and shape I may want a larger or smaller tenon. If I want to incorporate the tenon into a foot I will opt to make it larger in Dia. And concurring the wood strength and orientation are important considerations. I've lost more pieces because the tenon split off than from losing grip. It is amazing how little tenon surface it takes for a secure hold.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#8

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Everyone seems to be listing the obvious and dancing around some sticky points. No one has answered a question which should be known, by someone -- are the jaws of a fully expanded scroll chuck weaker? Could a jaw come loose? Also, with only the 8 points of contact, will be blank be more likely to wobble off center if the jaws are fully extended?

We have to consider not only gripping power, but safety, and the impact of these chucking factors upon turning.

Of course, the ideal situation would be the largest set of jaws possible, closed down to near minimal diameter, but those conditions were stated not to be possible in the provided example.

This is a complex issue and almost certainly does not have a simple answer. There is probably not an operational formula which incorporates jaw diameter, blank diameter and length, blank weight, etc.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#9

Bigger tenon is stronger.

Doc Green

Here is my take, which repeats most of what has been said in the other posts.

Two forces come into play. One is that the tool and cutting action tends to lever the tailstock end of the blank upward, pulling the bottom part of the tenon out of the jaws. Applying the tool at a greater distance from the chuck increases this effect. Doubling the size of the tenon doubles the amount of levering force the grip can withstand.

The other consideration is the rotational force the jaws must supply to the workpiece to rotate it against the tool. Again, bigger is better because the jaws must supply less sideways force to the wood to achieve the same amount of rotational force (torque).

When attempting to core a blank having a fairly small tenon, say 2.5" diameter, I have had the chuck jaws spin on the tenon, and most of the time the piece will spin out of the chuck. I've never had this problem when I use a larger tenon, say 5" diameter.

Relating to contact area, when the contact area is large, the gripping force per unit area (pressure) is LESS than when the contact area is smaller. This offsetting factor tends to make the contact area less important as far as gripping power is concerned, meaning that contact area doesn't matter. However, if you are working with degraded (spalted) wood, you want the greatest contact area possible to avoid the tendency of the jaws to crush the wood.

I don't think the mechanical strength of the jaws is significantly weaker at large diameters.

~Doc

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#10

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

Bill Howatt

I use Oneway chucks and jaws and for normal bowl operations, I use the profiled jaws, not the dovetail.

The jaws aren't going to come loose if they are extended and I have seen no indication that the jaws are weaker although there are fewer threads of the scroll holding them. Oneway jaws have a pin that limits the travel to 2 settings on the chuck and I presume their engineering department have set the travel within the safe limits.

I normally chuck in compression mode and I can honestly say I've never had a piece fly out of the Oneway profiled jaws with a severe catch. Most times it doesn't even seem to knock the work off true. The profiled jaws typically hold with the "corners" of the jaw it they are opened much beyond the closed state. I've never really looked to see the grip area when they are virtually closed. Like another poster, I have had the tenons shear off straight grained wood a few times and I've seen this with very large tenons.

I did have another chuck with dovetail jaws and its holding power was poor compared to the Oneway jaws. I don't really care about marking up tenons because I always remove/reshape them anyway since I dislike bowls with a foot that looks like the tenon was left on.

Bill

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

keith tompkins

Another thing to consider...a large tenon with a poorly cut shoulder will not be secure in the chuck;much of the holding power of the chuck is due to the shoulder of the wood securely resting against the chuck jaws. Emmett, are you having difficulties holding your stock?

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#12

Ellis Walentine

Agreed

Ellis Walentine

I'm late to the discussion as usual, but I think there's a principle of joinery that may be generalized to this discussion. As Keith says, it is the concept of the shoulder. Think of the chuck and workpiece as a mortise and tenon joint. The thing that gives a joint its strength is the perimeter of the shoulder against the leg or rail, or, in the chuck analogy, against the face of the jaws. The shoulder means that the jaws only have to overcome the pulling-out forces on the tenon, not the side deflection forces. Absent any shoulder, the jaws have to do a lot more work to keep the piece from wobbling off axis. This is equivalent to a bare-faced tenon in conventional flat-world joinery.

As for the extent of contact and expansion of the chuck, I would guess that the four worm gears taken together exert equal pressure on the tenon regardless of the diameter, as long as they are tightened to the same torque. The torque itself shouldn't vary unless the jaws are extended to the point that not as many turns of the gears are engaged, and even then, I suspect that the holding power is directly proportional to the torque of your tommy bars or chuck key. The other variable, of course, is the density of the wood itself. Dense wood will not compress as much as soft wood, but that's a two-edged sword. The teeth will bite better in soft wood, but they will also tear fibers more easily, which could end up weakening the pull-out force.

Interesting question and a great discussion. I'm not sure there's a one-size-fits-all answer though.

Ellis

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#13

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

Jorge Casta�eda

Emmet,

By chance I received a set of #3 serrated "tower" jaws for my Stronghold, not what I ordered, but decided to give them a try, I am glad I did, they became my workhorse.

I like to use the biggest tenon possible with the jaws almost closed and the "tower" jaws allow a lot deeper tenon as well, which adds to the strength, specially welcome when deep hollowing. Make sure you make a good shoulder, square and ample.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#14

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Thanks to everyone for some great input and food for thought. I am not having any particular chucking problems; rather, I just wondered if I was overlooking something important. Really, most of my concern about wood coming off the lathe occurs during the phase when asymmetrical wood is between centers and before the much more secure tenon-held-by-scroll-jaw stage.

Relative to tenon size, my operating rule of thumb has been: big pieces of wood, use the largest tenon feasible, even if the jaws are near maximal expansion; smaller pieces of wood, use a tenon size just a little larger than the minimal jaw diameter. I have reached this happy state largely via intuition plus some trial and error.

I am pleased to learn that, except for the knuckle busting hazard, I don't have to be concerned about fully expanding the jaws. Also, I had not considered the influence of grain direction, but that certainly makes sense and fits my experience.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#15

Secure, between centers . . .

Doc Green

Emmett, when you are worried about a piece staying between centers, drill holes for the centers to fit into. I do this a lot with punky wood when I'm concerned about the piece staying on the lathe.

For example, a drive center I use frequently is 1 inch in diameter. I drill a hole for this center 1 inch in diameter and about 1/2 inch deep, then seat the drive center in this hole. For the tail center, I use the same (spade) bit and drill a shallow recess, then insert the point of the tail center into the recess.

Works for me. ~Doc

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#16

Re: Secure, between centers . . .

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Doc,

Great idea, drilling the support holes. And, when dealing with punky wood, stabilize the wood with some thin CA glue.

If I am really worried about the wood, I often drill a hole and use a Glaser screw chuck to secure the headstock end.

I like your idea and will use it.

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#17

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

robo hippy

A deeper tenon gives more strength if it is end grain. If you are turning flat grain, as in bowl orientation, it is weaker. This was pointed out to me by Stewart Batty at a turning workshop I did with him and his dad. Makes some sense when I thought about it. 1/4 inch max for bowl tenons.

robo hippy

Re: A Chuck Gripping Question

#18

You are right!

Jorge Casta�eda

I was just thinking of the situation he asked advice for, I should have mention the other orientation as well. Thanks!