A Chuck Gripping Question
Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN
Let�s say I have a blank that I have carefully turned, between centers, to a five inch diameter cylinder. I am now ready to cut a tenon on one end of my blank so I can get some serious chuck gripping established.
Let�s also assume that I only have one set of jaws for my chuck and that they will compression grip between 1.5 and 3.0 inches.
For maximal gripping power, should I make my tenon just slightly larger than 1.5 inches, thus placing most of the chuck�s diameter in contact with the wood; or, should I cut the tenon just under 3.0 inches so I will have a larger diameter enclosed in the chuck, albeit with gaps between the fully expanded jaws?
Are the jaws of a fully expanded scroll chuck weaker? Does the greater diameter of the fully extended chuck outweigh the nearly continuous band of steel when the chuck is close to minimal diameter? Does the size/weight of the blank come into play?
I have pondered this situation for over five years and I can see it both ways? Does anyone have any convincing mathematical proof, or other evidence, one way or the other?



