Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Which Lathe Chuck

Posts

Which Lathe Chuck

#1

Which Lathe Chuck

David Lykins - Dallas GA

I�m in the market for a lathe chuck, as I�ve never broken down and purchased a good chuck for bowl turning and such. I�ve narrowed it down to two lathe chucks of which I�ve listed below. I know that your guys have a wealth of knowledge on this subject so I�d like to hear the Pros and Cons of either of the chucks.

Thanks a bunch for your input.

1. Penn State Industries - Barracuda2 T/N Plated Special Edition Lathe Key Chuck System

The Barracuda2 seems to have everything I�d ever need for turning bowls and anything else my little mind can come up with, its $200 but currently out of stock. However, I�m confused as to whether or not it comes with the large flat bowl turning chuck. It shows it in the picture, but list it as an �optional� in the �specifications�. Anyone know if its included�

http://www.pennstateind.com/store/CSC3000CTN.html

2. Grizzly Industrial - H6265 4 Jaw Wood Chuck 1" x 8 TPI (plus attachments), H6269 4" Dovetail Jaws For 4 Jaw Chuck, H6268 1" Pin Jaws For 4 Jaw Chuck, its about $180.

http://www.grizzly.com/products/4-Jaw-Wood-Chuck-1-x-8-TPI/H6265

I remember reading some reviews about this chuck here on Wood Central when it first came out and it seemed to be work well. However I couldn�t find a large jaw plate for bowl turning on Grizzly�s site like the one pictured with the Barracuda2.

If there are other "like" options I'd also like to hear about them.

Thanks again for your help.

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#2

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

john lucas

Go with the Grizzly. It is a copy of the Vicmarc which I think is the best chuck on the market. I have one of the Grizzly and 3 of the Vicmarcs. It is very close to as good as they are.

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

Leo Cuellar

I recently upgraded to that model of Grizzly chuck w/ the same selection of jaws. I bought it based on what Russ Fairfield had to say about it on his website, and the future compatibility w/ Vicmarc jaws. I have no complaints w/ it, and it is way better than their smaller "cheaper" chuck. I haven't swapped the jaws out yet, and am considering getting a couple of more chucks so I won't have to worry about it. Grizzly doesn't sell the insert adapters, but they can be found at other sources if you upgrade to a lathe w/ a larger spindle.

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#4

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

Bill Youngblood

I know a few people with the Grizzly's that are a couple of years old. They have broken the handles and the gears are starting to feel a little rough. I have had Vicmarc's for 4 or 5 years and they still work like a Swiss watch. Spend the extra money and get a good one. Just my two cents worth. :\

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#5

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

john lucas

My take on this. When you expand the jaws you are only gripping by 8 small points. If you use the 1/5" setting you have almost a complete grip. That's why Oneway developed those odd shaped jaws. In my opinion they have more grip over a wider range but less grip at any range than the mostly closed jaws.

Now we are assuming you have a solid piece of wood. If I suspect the wood being weak at all, such as punky then I go with the larger tenon.

My preference of course as Robbo said, use bigger jaws and close them down.

I'd love to figure out a Mythbusters style test to see. Perhaps a piece of wood bored to hold a very long metal bar. Then you slide a weight out the bar until it pulls the wood from the chuck. The further it goes the stringer the grip. Or maybe you could simply attach a set of large fish scales to the end and pull down checking the force until it pops. I'm guessing we would have to put metal straps around the wood to keep it from splitting while applying the force. I may actually have the equipment to do that test if I have a piece of wood I want to ruin. I have a chunk of pine but I think you want something harder for this test although I suspect the wood is where the failure accurs, not the jaws so maybe a soft wood will tell us something.

I need a break from cleaning the other house so I might just do this tomorrow.

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#6

Not sure why this posted here- I can't edit it

john lucas

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#7

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

Bernie Weishapl

I bought a Vicmarc VM100 and found out the jaws would fit the Grizzly chuck. I now have 4 of the Grizzly's with the oldest being 4 yrs old. They are all still working as well as the Vic. Never had a problem with any of them. I bought Vic jaws and put them on the Griz chucks because I hate changing jaws. Read lazy.

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#8

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

bernie feinerman

Grizzley does sell inserts for their chuck. The insert number can be found in the manual that comes with the chuck. I bought a chuck to fit a Craftsman, then upgraded the chuck to fit a Jet Mini.

Bernie

Re: Which Lathe Chuck

#9

Leo Cuellar

Thank you, I did not know that...

Leo Cuellar

Bernie! I don't generally read them unless I'm having a problem. My uncle Manuel always called them "destruction" manuals. :D I just wish they would get on the ball & get me the new drive pulley for my lathe. I've been waiting a few months now... it still works, just a lot of vibration if I turn it all the way up.

Leo