Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Do you quench your tools...???

Posts

Do you quench your tools...???

#1

Leo Cuellar

Do you quench your tools...???

Leo Cuellar

in water to stop heat buildup while turning? It just occurred to me that I should be doing this when I get too aggressive on roughing out. I was wondering if others do this?

Thanks!

Leo

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#2

JL

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

JL

No, I can't say that I ever do - for spindle work or for bowls/platters.

I do back off and let my drill bits cool a bit though. They can get quite warm.

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#3

Walt Bennett

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

Walt Bennett

Only when reshaping a tool on the grinder and that's for my own comfort and safety (rather not burn my fingers!). If you get a chance, look at the AAW DVD from a couple years back about tool sharpening. I think it's Bonnie Klein that gives a talk on how hot different rated hardness tools can get before they'll loose their temper. For even M2, its above black/blue. For my favorite 2030, it's beyond red/yellow.

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#4

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

john lucas

Boy you must be turning at high speed. Only on dry woods running fast have I heated up a tool enough to make it uncomfortable to my left hand. You could cool it. It wouldn't hurt a thing. You could simply pull the tool away 1/4" and let the air from the bowl cool it. If you do this frequently it won't heat up to beging with. That's the technique I use when removing a lot of metal from a tool I'm grinding. I make a pass across the wheel and then pull it back across the wheel without touching the wheel. This keeps it cool.

I quenched my tools after sharpening for years before I read Jerry Glaser's advice against it. I could never tell that it hurt a thing and I use to be a bad sharpener holding the tool there longer than necessary and often overheating the edge. Now I'm much better and don't overheat the tools and don't quench either.

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#5

Steven Antonucci

one instance I can think of.

steven antonucci

If I am drilling a center hole with a spindle gouge, it will often heat up past the point of being touchable. I will put the steel in the water bath on my Tormek and wipe it dry with a paper towel before I finish drilling.

At these temperatures, it is all about comfort. I have never heated steel on the lathe to the point of inducing a color change, and I'm not even sure that it would be possible? I have to think that the wood would begin to char long before that temperature, thus preventing any material property changes.

steve

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#6

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

When I drill pen blanks on the lathe, I use a constant air blast on the drill bit as it enters the blank. As the bit is retracted to clean and break the chips, I keep this air going. This cools and helps to clean it with less retraction. I use a cheap pistol grip gun with a 3" small snout from HF. This will prevent charring the waste in oily, exotic blanks. I actually set fire to the waste early-on before I learned better.

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#7

Good Idea- Thanks

Barbara Gill

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#8

Re: Good Idea- Thanks *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I keep the tip of the gun about a 1/2" away from the entry point.


HF gun

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#9

I have had discussions with several....

JamieDonaldson

... metallurgical experts over the years regarding tool heat generated during grinding, and the concensus pro/con quenching has been split about 50/50. Some aspects of damage to alloys such as edge microfracturing, hardness shifts, etc. may be true in theory, but not significant in applications such as with turning tools. I have water quenched many "grinder heated" tools over the years, and never noticed any difference in working characteristics between water quenching and allowing a hot tool to air cool.

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#10

Leo Cuellar

People have mentioned heat cracking...

Leo Cuellar

on thin walled pieces before, and I wondered if this was a "secret" technique for controlling this. I haven't had this issue yet, but I am getting my wall thicknesses down.

This was mainly about finger comfort. I"d need another couple 1000rpm's...to set the piece on fire. :D I do spin at the highest rpm that the piece feels safe at. My tools are ground at the steeper end of the range of grinds, and I haven't yet begun grinding the heel back as many of you have begun to do now. My grinder is very low speed, but it is still possible to "burn" steel if I work really hard at it.

I would suppose that tool quality is another factor... I gather from your posts that most of you are using Thompson gouges now. Maybe I should order myself one as a belated B'day gift?

Thanks again!!!

Leo

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#11

Re: People have mentioned heat cracking...

John Lucas

Well I won't talk you out of the Thompson gouge, I love mine, but in reality it won't solve your problem. Making the bevel shorter will reduce the friction and may reduce the heat.

I've noticed in the last 10 years many of the pro's are going to shorter primary bevels. In Mike Mahoney's case, extremely short. I'm slowly working toward that with my own. Each time I sharpen I take a little more off my secondary bevel. I've been too lazy to go to courser wheel and just grind it away.

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#12

Joe Fleming

Re: What is quenching?  Long

Joe Fleming

I offer these observations on the metalurgy involved here, and I am only discussing high speed steel or powdered metals - nothing else.

As others have implied, the heating of a high speed steel tool, or a powdered metal tool (eg: Thompson or Glaser) requires WAY more heat than what will be generated under normal turning in the hardest and driest of woods. You may blister your fingers or hands, but the tool temperature remains significantly below the temperature with which the tool could be damaged if it were dipped in water. Even when sharpening, if you keep your tools cool by frequent dunking, you will not damage the steel. Think of water-cooled sharpening systems.

Now, if you sharpen the tool until is glows, you are approaching the temperature where quenching can do damage. High speed steel is the most tolerant, if I recall my metalurgy correctly. The powdered metals are more susceptible to quenching damage after heating on a grinding wheel.

So my advice is as follows: 1) While turning, if the tool is too hot to hold, back off if possible. 2) On a long, continuous cut, however, a stop/start is not always desirable. In these cases, I bought a pair of leather work gloves from Home Depot and cut off the fingers like bike gloves. So, when I do an overhand grip on a bowl gouge, and the hot chips fly into the side of my hand, I can keep turning. 3) While turning, feel free and safe to dunk your hot tools in water to cool them - while turning. 4) If you want to keep your tools cool during sharpening, water cooling is ok ONLY IF you cool them frequently. In other words, you must KEEP the tool tip cool. Once you heat it up on the grinding, quenching risks damage to the steel. My practice is to water dunk after every pass of the edge on the grinding wheel. How hot is too hot? This is where my metalurgy knowledge has faded. Glowing meanings it is too how - let it air cool. My practice is if I hear the water sizzling as I dunk, I've waited too long between dunks. A tiny "tsst", I don't worry about, but a sizzle with or without a puff of steam is too hot. No sound is best.

One other point for those that fear they have already ruined their tools by quenching. Assuming that you have really done damage, the damage will be limited to the very edge of the tool. Grinding back past the tip with appropriate cooling care will remove the damaged metal. This is not 1", 1/2", 1/4" or even 1/8" of steel. We are talking about very little to remove the alleged damage. Maybe 1/32" or a bit more depending on the angle of the cutting edge. The more blunt the cutting edge (like scrapers) the less length that needs to be removed. This is because the bar of steel itself acts as a heat sink and pulls heat away from the cutting tip. A more blunt tool has more metal mass immediately behind the cutting tip to take away damaging heat more efficiently.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#13

Leo Cuellar

Re: People have mentioned heat cracking...

Leo Cuellar

Thanks, John. I was thinking that was a part of the issue. I was just getting the basic techniques down and didn't want to introduce too many new variables until I had the mechanics more to my understanding. Impatience on my part is obviously a big hurdle for me to overcome. I'll definitely have to get a Thompson to try out. But first I'll get another cheap Grizzly to play with other grind angles.

Leo

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#14

Leo Cuellar

Re: What is quenching?  Long

Leo Cuellar

Thanks, Joe. Good input, my question was more concerning heat transfer to the turning itself. I've heard several people mention higher speed for cleaner cutting, but that imparts heat. My grind of course is probably not the correct one for the speed. I was just curious if this was an issue for others, and what they might be doing to combat it before I started re-profiling my gouges. Really great tip about the gloves, I'll definitely give that a try. I haven't been doing this long enough to thicken the skin on the backside of my hands :D

Leo

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#15

Leo Cuellar

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

Leo Cuellar

I don't do pens or too much small boring, yet! That is definitely an idea to remember, Bill, thanks. I do like to deliberately char the wood if I'm setting a cold tool into a handle though. I have been trying epoxy now, still haven't decided which method I like better :\

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#16

Joe Fleming

Re: What is quenching?  Long

Joe Fleming

Leo,

I totally missed that point (heat to the wood). Sorry. For what it is worth, In 11 years of turning, I don't think I have ever had wood crack due to heat from the tool, but I have definitely introduced hairline cracks into exotics, and some domestics, due to oversanding. I think the abrasives are much more dangerous to your work from a heat perspective. Joe

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#17

Joe Fleming

Re: What is quenching?  Long

Joe Fleming

In terms of how fast your tool is going, think of it this way: if you turn a 3" table leg at 2000 rpm, your tool tip will cut a mile of wood in just over 3 minutes. If you are turning at 3000 rpm, your tool tip will cut a mile of wood in just over two minutes. This is about 30 miles per hour. Your tool takes a huge amount of abuse which means it will get dull quickly, which translates into more heat. The moral is to sharpen often.

I alsways get a chuckle when I attend our local woodworking exhibit and show at the San Diego County Fair. The flat-board guys making chairs hone/sharpen their tools the first thing every morning whether they need to be sharpened or not. :-) Joe

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#18

Re: What is quenching?  Long

Wayne Kuhn

Joe, good post. You have reinforced my belief that if you are getting your tools hot enough when sharpening to change the molecular structure of the steel when quenched, you are doing something wrong.

Wayne

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#19

Re: What is quenching?  Long

john lucas

Joe there are two factors here. Speed of the wood and how fast the tool goes through the wood. You can get the same cut at 500 rpm as you do at 2000 rpm if you move the tool at a different rate. Sure the tool is moving much more slowly across the wood at 500 than 2000. So in theory you can simply not push the tool as hard and slow down the lathe and get the same cut.

OK here's the problem. Let's assume it takes 30 seconds for the tool to move 1 inch. It is important to move the tool in a smooth flowing line. I think you can see that to move the tool that short distance in such a long time can be difficult and require a lot of concentration. Now lets speed the lathe up so that it takes 5 seconds to travel the same distance. It is much easier to move your body in a smooth flowing fashion over a shorter period.

What often happens in real life is when the wood is moving slow people tend to force the cut consequently they take off more wood than the wood wants so the cut is not as clean. With the wood moving faster you tend to take lighter cuts which helps you not to force the cut. You are more relaxed which also helps make a smoother body movement.

There are limits of course. Higher speed means potentially more danger. My suggestion is to start turning slow and safe. Gradually increase the speed of the wood as you get more comfortable. You will get to the higher speeds naturally and safely.

This does vary if you have voids in the wood. Higher speeds let you sort of skip over the voids but at the same time wood with voids has a great chance of flying apart.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, Learn to relax and let the tool do the cutting. If you feel you can turn at higher speeds safely then will probably help you, but do so with caution.

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#20

Leo Cuellar

I hadn't done the math on that...

Leo Cuellar

and it is really quite amazing when one stops to ponder that, Joe! Puts a whole new spin on "miles to go before I rest" :D

I used to be the same way about sharpening, but I've learned most edges hold up much better than one would think. Still a quick touch up makes the work go faster, and I've only cut myself badly by trying to get one last cut from a dulled tool(flat work).

Sanding is a whole different issue, but I'm starting to acquire some of the little accessories that make it a less tedious job.

Thanks again!

Leo

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#21

Leo Cuellar

Thanks for phrasing that coherently for me!:) 

Leo Cuellar

Re: Do you quench your tools...???

#22

And the same would apply to......

JamieDonaldson

...turning, because if you are generating much heat in the tool then something is wrong, like a dull tool. Grinder time out!