Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

"Blending" a finial / pull

Posts

"Blending" a finial / pull

#1

"Blending" a finial / pull

charlie belden

Finials and pulls often look like After Thought additions to a piece. Getting them to not look like a Stuck On can be disquised with a bead or groove - but the flow from piece to finial or pull gets interrupted. If you turn a Stuck On in order to blend it into what it's on, you end up with a delicate knife edge - at best, or loose some of it while doing the blending.

Here's a way to blend a finial / pull to a piece. Not the most elegant example - but it illustrates the method.






Yes, i need to do some more work on the reverse curve of the pull

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

#2

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

john lucas

Charlie I will actually make several some times if I don't think the first one looks right. Sometimes I'll make finials out of pine and dye it black just to see how it looks. The black takes away the grain and color and lets you judge the form better. Once I get it right, or at least what I think is right, I'll pick the proper wood and make one.

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

#3

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

charlie belden

John:

You only get one crack at this because the pull or finial must be glued in place so it can't move when you do the blending turning. Tried it with just a friction fit but the cutting force coming off the lid into the pull or finial can create forces that overcome the tenon's friction fit. Once that starts things happen pretty quickly - and none of what happens is fun.

This particular example is almost a worst case since the pull is short and the diameter is pretty small so there's not a lot of space to work in the cove. But it's what I'm working on and available for the photos.

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

#4

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

John Lucas

I understand. Been there. My only suggestion would be to photograph the piece and print it out. Then you could make sketches on the printouts until you think you have a reasonable idea of what you want. Changing it from 3D to 2D often helps me because you really get to look at just the form.

Shoot it against a white background with no light on the front. This will silhouette it making it easier to see the form when you print it out.

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

#5

Another odball option

John Lucas

Since your into thinking outside the box. You could make the collar out of wax. You can buy turnable wax at metal supply houses. This would let you play with the shape. If you get it wrong just stick more wax back on and try again or remove and put another plug in. Then you could simply melt it out after photographing it and put the wood on and copy the wax pattern.

OK I know that's little far out. I'm just thinking about how clay artists have an advantage over us because they can easily shape a part, remove it if it's wrong, add more clay on and play some more. A clay friend of mine says woodturning is a negative process. In other words all we do is remove wood. We can't put it back on. Of course he is not including gluing parts on.

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

#6

Thanks for the idea

David Walser

Charlie,

Thanks for the idea. I'm always looking for new and better ways of getting something done.

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

#7

WAX Prototyping

charlie belden

You may have hit on something with your Wax Thing.

WAY BACK - as in 1973 - I was making lost wax cast jewerly. Though I mainly used an Additive Method - building up pieces by adding wax, I occasionally carved (Subtractive Method) pieces that needed crisp sharp details. I picked up a little UniMat - a small metal lathe and turned hard waxes made for cutting, carving -- and turning. The wax came in three hardnesses - all machinable - two of which you could heat the wax and melt some back onto the piece you were working on - Subtractive AND Additive. Since then, they've come up with a broader range of "carving waxes" and their making designs using a CNC machine.

These carving waxes turn beautifully - as long as you stay at low rpms and make clean cuts or scrapes - friction will soften them. I don't know if you could turn a delicate Drozda-esque finial in carving wax but it might be fun to try.

There's always more than one way to skin a cat - figuratively speaking of course - and you've come up with yet another way!

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

#8

Re: "Blending" a finial / pull

Doug Turner

Charlie,

Unless your collar overlaps the main vessel a littlouge bit when the wood moves due to moisture and temperature changes you will probably end up with a noticeable gap between the collar and the vesse that might detract from the flowing design.

Doug