Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

Posts

Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#1

Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

charlie belden

I don't know if Mel Lindquist was concerned about the longevity of his turnings, but I think it's an important consideration for his son Mark's works. His pieces will remain essentially unchanged - for generations - by intent.

Now think about your turnings. Do you consider how they will change over 10, 20 or 50 years? Will the pyrographed designs you burn into your work be as noticable - when the piece browns over time? That dye you use- will it hold up over decades. What about that wipe on poly? Will it hold its translucency over time or will it yellow? Will that oil finish really cure - or will it become a dust and dirt grabber over time? That almost filigree fine piercing in your pieces - will some of it be lost or damaged in a generation? Do you even worry about any of that.

I enjoy trying to incorporate new technology into pieces - being well aware that anything that requires batteries or has moving parts that can wear out will stop working in a week or two, maybe month or two. It seems the nature of new technology is a short shelf life. That's ok with me since it's the making - and seeing that it works - that I want. If the incorporated technology stops working after a while - that's ok. It's the figuring out HOW and then the DOING that I'm after, not the creation of future antiques.

Do you turn, in part, to create things for future generations? Do you even think about that? Should you?

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#2

I've thought about it

john lucas

I do try to make things that last as long as they can. However some of the piece I make I'm pretty sure will not last 100 years. Maybe not 20 or 30. I've repaired a lot of furniture over the years and learned quite a bit about wood movements and joints. They almost all fail sooner or later. Only solid wood stands a chance of staying together a long time.

Much of the work that I make that I value is made from multiple parts. I try to use the proper joints and glue but I know that sooner or later the glue and wood movement will probably give way.

I reality how many of us will actually make work that will be valued by anyone other than our immediate family very long after our death. I would like to make very serious collectible work and shoot for that quality bit I don't worry myself to death over it because creating the piece is more important to my growth than how long it will last.

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: I've thought about it

Mike Stafford

I am sure a certain amount of collectible work will be retained by an individual collector/buyer's family if it appeals to those who receive it after the buyer's death. If it does not appeal to the recipient I would not expect it to be considered to have much value unless they were made aware of the value while the original owner was alive. The secondary market would end up being a yard sale or flea market. Those collectible pieces that end up in art museum or gallery permanent collections will probably be the final repository of the majority of wood art.

However, utilitarian ware such as well made salad bowls and small decorative bowls, i.e. candy dishes, might be recognized as more "valuable/useful" in the long run by a wider group of people because the new owners will know/have an idea what to do with it.

We have friends who have a 26" cherry bowl that was probably originally created to serve as a bread/dough bowl or something similar. It has a 1788 date crudely carved into the bottom. I don't know if it was turned but it shows no evidence of being hand hewn. It is smooth and well patinated inside and out. My friends always drag this beautiful bowl out at dinner parties and mix up huge garden salads in it.

I would like to think anything that I have built or turned in my shop was still being used by someone more than 200 years from now. I think my best chances may be some of the small thick walled candy dishes that all of my wife's friends and my family have in use almost all the time in their homes. Maybe some of the boxes I have turned that are being used for paper clips will serve that purpose for a few years after I pass....

On a different note I see that in June John C. Campbell Folk School is offering a weeklong class in how to build your own casket. I suppose it would be nice to know that your final resting place was something that you had a hand in constructing......

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#4

Re: I've thought about it

bill Crommett

Mike's comment about caskets give me a chance to remind my successors that there are two urns that I have put away for my ashes. A casket would be nice, but they take up too much space and would have to have a special display room waiting for the final event.

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#5

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

mjonesrdg

Longevity IS a consideration with most everthing I turn, but rather limited to my choice of finish. I make my own tungoil/varnish and use only the best product that I can buy primarily because I don't want a finish to chip, flake, crack, yellow or dull over time. In my overblown egoist opinion, everything that leaves my shop is a stand-alone gorgeous work of art that would be cherished by all that might so fortunate as to behold it...and is bound to be handed down from generation to generation.

(Accordingly, I'll be really ticked off if the world comes to an end in December 2012!) :b

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#6

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

Dave Belser

Excellent topic Charlie, this has come up before and I think it is very important aspect of the work that we create as turners. As John hit on, a lot of turnings are created from a single, solid piece of wood. Because of this they have the potential to exist and survive for an extremely long time (centuries) if well made and kept in a reasonable environment.

For work in this category the biggest single factor for it surviving in an aesthetically pleasing way is -FORM- and finish. All wood will turn brown with age either lighter or darker. Grain and figure will generally diminish and be less dramatic with age - so you are basically left with the form and it better be pleasing. Once you add embellishments then it becomes essential to use materials and techniques that will last. Carving and burning are probably the most durable, choices of paints, dyes and stains are extremely important in addition to whatever finish you choose. I'm not just referring to "High end" art (whatever that is) A well made functional bowl could be finely carved and finished only with oil. This sort of piece can be used and last +100 years with no more maintenance than a good oiling periodically.

For me longevity & durability is an extremely important (perhaps hidden) aesthetic quality) for my mechanical boxes. I've come to this point from starting with the cryptex-tantalus - a huge part of the idea of a cryptex is that it is a secret box that will last for centuries. The small locking boxes that I've made use magnets for the tumbler mechanism - they should remain functional indefinitely.

For these small mahogany I now use metal leaf for the exterior patterns - my original choice of black lacquer almost disappeared on the lid of the first box I made after the wood darkened considerably.

In regards to new technology, I think it is quite possible to make objects that can last indefinitely, but it requires a significant amount of research and careful planing and design. Computer chips, leds and peizo electric devices will function for extreamly long periods of time and there is no reason not to use them. The tougher problem is power sources and actuators. I believe that I will eventually create a piece with a computer controller - think of the amazement of a functioning crafted device with a working micro-controller 100+ years from now. It would be like watching a ancient clock. The technology of the time would make it appear primitive and archaic, what would it have to do to still hold interest?

- Dave

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#7

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Just about every piece I turn I think of longevity. I have the first bowl that I ever turned. Done in high school shop in 1936, so it's about 75 years old. It's walnut and I must have used an oil finish. It still looks pretty good. There are qute a few pieces in my family that I turned 50 or 60 years ago. They have all aged well except in some cases, the finish.

I have a bowl that belonged to my grandmother long before I was born. I'll be 90 in a few months so it's old. It's somewhat oval in shape so it was turned wet. It shows tool marks so it wasn't sanded. It is a utiliy bowl and shows signs of a lot of use. I don't think that it ever had a finish so it's almost black. Still in good shape. I have no idea what kind of wood it is.

Wally

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#8

Still having problems giving my stuff away.

Al Kapocius

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#9

Steven Antonucci

At least as long as I am alive

steven antonucci

My goal is to make something that will last my lifetime, simply because I don't want to have to deal with a repair . It doesn't make sense to worry about what happens after then, as my collectability will increase, but it won't help my personal cause.

Does anyone really know who made those old dough bowls? Does it really matter?

Steve

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#10

I usually give a verbal warranty.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

If it falls apart in the first month, I'll fix it free. After that, you are on you own.

%\],,,,,,,,k

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

#11

Re: Longevity Of Your Pieces A Consideration?

steve worcester

Sure, you don't want a piece to look much different in a few years than the day they bought it. I have quit using woods that will radically change color with direct sunlight, like a platter out of Osage that looses it's beautiful yellow and fades to brown. I shoot finishes with a lot of UV protection for my painted hollow forms and even then tell people when they buy to keep it out of direct sunlight.

As far as construction, that too is intended for longevity, glues that will last.

I hope that in 200 years someone holds up a (then crude) piece of mine and it is a family heirloom. I think we all need to leave some legacy.