I don't want to sharpen the bits. from what I see the Maxi cut is HSS and the Rockler bits are carbide and the price is real close between the 2.
I'm thinking the carbie bits are a better buy based on not needing to sharpen and not needing the Maxi cut extension and holder.
I have some of the carbon/TIN coated cheapo bits and they work somewhat if I sharpen them after each use.
Now I wonder about the difference between full carbide and carbide tipped. The carbide tipped are about 2/3 the cost of full carbide and seem to be just a good.
I now have several hundred dollars invested in the Colt Maxi-Cut Forstner Bits. Personally, I feel they are the best buy for drilling that I've ever purchased. They have neat attachments such as a Morse Taper, and several extensions. You do not have to have the Morse Taper or the extensions to use the bits, but they are nice. I would question whether a carbide bit would ever be as sharp as the Colt bits.
I feel the same way Fred does. I have several of the Maxi Cut bits and plan to buy more of them. The guy who does my saw sharpening told me that they wouldn't be hard to re-sharpen when it comes time either.
You get what you pay for! And though the Maxi Cut bits are not cheap, they are sharper and cut better than any other Forstner style bit that I have found. They are worth the difference in price.
The extensions and Morse taper holders are sheer genius. I had not realized that the gripping part of the shafts of these bits are not round, but rather are a shape repeated three times. Similarly, the Rotastop Morse taper holders and the extensions have a complementary shape repeated three times so that when the bit is inserted and rotated, the bit locks in. No set screws are involved. The shape repeats every 120 degrees, so that a three-jaw chuck will grip the bit accurately and maintain the center.