Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

Posts

Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#1

Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

Dinyar Chavda

As I mentioned below in the thread on hollowing tools, I was on YouTube for a while last night, looking at various turning videos. One that I came across was a rather simple, but unexpected way of turning a perfectly round ball. Take a look at the link below. By the way, note the music, which I initially found distracting (Being hard of hearing, I hate background music in movies/TV shows that is louder than the words being spoken, particularly if there are no subtitles--something the Brits are (in)famous for in their TV shows, and also if the actors have foreign accents (again, something the Brits are infamous for!)--their shows are fabulous, but why can't they give us the subtitles--can you imagine watching The Wire without subtitles, regardless of whether or not you have a hearing problem! But I digress! The music on this demo is actually hauntingly beautiful after listening to it for a while.

Also, while watching all the various demos of different tools, I was reminded of a conversation I had had with Russ Fairfield when I had visited him this January (hit was warmer in Post Falls, Id, than in Philadelphia, with nary a speck of snow on the ground!) We were musing that, with the tsunami of retiring baby boomers looking for a hobby (to keep their spouses from going crazy) and many of them coming to turning, more and more turners would be like me, i.e., turning being their first introduction to woodworking, as opposed to most turners today who seem to have a background in wood working. Russ observed that one could no longer make a statement like "the skew cuts just like a chisel", and have the audience have any idea what you were talking about (I dont!). He felt that there would be more of a need to show things at a very basic level, and not assume the existence of a base of knowledge to build on.

The reason I thought of this is that I have a hypothesis (which I have seen at work in other industries), which is that the customer for tools may come to expect that the product bought has a video accompanying it that shows you how to use it, how you can screw it up, and what to do to avoid that. Given a choice between two competitive products, the one with a video, even if more expensve, will often win. My hypothesis is that the video will be expected to be an integral part of the product, and it will be very difficult to sell a tool without one, either for free, or at a cost.

Looking at the hollowing tool videos, some tools were conspicuous by their absence--maybe there are videos on sale for them.

Also, there was a huge variance among the videos, both in terms of production quality (I don't care for fancy, but I do need to be able to figure out what is going on, and in terms of the ability of the demonstrator to explain clearly what was happening, as Denzel Washington said in "Philadelphia", "in terms a two-year old could understand!"

The concept of the "larger product" may be encroaching upon the turning business.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNCT7Yu-oRc&feature=related

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#2

Leo Cuellar

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long

Leo Cuellar

Thanks for the link, Dinyar. It was interesting to see the machinist's approach. The more I look at what manufacturers are offering for lathes and pricing, the closer I'm getting to building my own. The really good ones, that might be able to handle what I want to do, are 5 times more expensive than any vehicle that I've ever bought!!! I'll use an 8" - 10" i-beam for the heart instead of split rails, that way I'll be able to mount the head & tail stock higher & add a (removable) turret like that fellow has. But now I digress...

That music was both haunting and hauntingly familiar... I know that's a rock song, but I can't remember who performed it, oh well.

I agree that video is what is going to sell stuff. Heck, even a good still photo of a product I'm considering is worth more than a complete verbal/text description. Proving the old adage that a picture is worth a thousand words. A good demo video ought to be worth a lot more.

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#3

Video Is Here.  Why Not Use It?

charlie belden

Like the digital still camera, digital video camera prices keep dropping as their features keep improving. Light, fit in your pocket, with built in flip out USB connector for charging from your computer's USB port as well as transfering digital video to you computers, point and shoot HD cameras like the FLIP can be had for about $150. Digital video editing software is available to edit raw video clips into short interesting videos, with features for sharing the results, including the ability to upload the resulting video to YouTube from within the editing application. iMovie, part of the iLife package for the Mac that also includes iPhoto and Garage Band, is $50 and is intuitive to use - literally Drag and Drop - drag clips or parts of clips into the editing window and drop it where you want it. High speed internet access prices keep falling as well and sites that you can put your videos up on - for free - are available now and more coming.

Given all of that, internet accessible digital video is inexpensive to produce and free to distribute. Folks making and selling turning tools should be putting up vids of their products and how to use them as part of their business plan. And hobbyest turners can demonstrate techniques i digital videos - something that til recently required burning and distributing DVDs - an expensive way to diseminate video information.

While turners are already into digital still photography, the limitations of being able to show only one or two still photos of a piece will be overcome by videos of the piece - on a turntable to convey more of the piece. For dynamic and kinetic turnings, digital video is a must because still images can't convey what the piece looks like in action.

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#4

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long

Paul Zerjay

I've seen that video before and wondered why he didn't show how he completed the turning. Personally, I would have positioned the blank 90 degrees from the way he did. That way the final cuts would be side grain, as opposed to his end grain. Nice jig he's got there though.

BTW the name of the band is Metallica. A highly over-rated group who's lead singer looks like the cowardly lion.

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#5

Steven Antonucci

Oh, the metal gods are not happy

steven antonucci

I had to laugh when I ready your Cowardly Lion Comment, and I assume it was directed at JH not LU... but neither of them has any hair last I saw? They were both caught by time...

If not Metallica, then who (from that era?)

Steve

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

It goes much further than this:

steven antonucci

I think that we're in a revolution.

Years ago, information came from very few places. If you were buying a tool, you might have asked one of two people you knew and the guy at the store. Today, you get it from people you've never even met and never will meet.

How does this change things?

Well, for starters, these people all have equal ability to post their thoughts and opinions in public places where they can be found. Ask a question like 'What do you think of this vendor/product?" and you are likely to get every possible response from good to bad. Customer service needs to designed around the fact that bad news travels at light speed.

However, a lot of bad news comes from the exact issue you bring up: anyone can post a video anytime. Companies NEED to post videos on their websites to market their products, but also as a frame of reference for proper use. Youtube is full of Joe Amateur misusing that companies products. WoodCentral, LumberJocks, AAW Forums, WTR, WOW, etc. is full of links pointing to these videos, which create a negative impression of that company or product. Companies need to develop a social media strategy to go with their videos.

The smarter companies will understand who "power users" are in these networks and get their tools into the mainstream via the network. Perhaps the single best example I have ever seen of this is Doug Thompson. Aside from having a great product, I can honestly say that I have never seen a bad word written about his company or his product AND he has sold almost exclusively by word of mouth via social networking. (Major kudos to Doug!)

Now, just imagine a "big market", and the damage that a few saboteurs could do if they wanted to... I make a hollowing system... I post a video using a competitive product... something bad happens...all under the guise of "Joe Avergae User"... Thankfully, we're not like that (I hope...)

S

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#7

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long

john lucas

Dinyar That's one reason I'm thinking about retiring. Our business is going away from still photography and moving toward video. I don't mind doing video's of turning and instructional type videos. I'm still having a very hard time dealing with the editing. The program they want me to use is very powerful, which is geek speak for if you punch a wrong key accidentally you will be lost in never never land and it will take you 4 hours of cussing and thumbing through the useless manual to find your way back. I really don't enjoy doing the same thing editing a banquet or other meaningless pat the bigwigs on the back kind of video.

Back to Russ's statement. I am learning that new woodturners not only don't have a basis in working wood, they also don't have any mechanical aptitude either. I grew up working on things mechanical, electrical, or just plain old if it broke you tried to fix it. New turners often have a problem as simply as the handwheel on the jet mini coming loose and don't know what to do. Not putting anyone down it's just that we need to teach basic maintenance techniques as well as woodworking. That goes with sharpening as well. When you grew up sharpening knives and chisels and using the grinder to sharpen axes and lawnmower blades it wasn't hard to step into lathe tools.

Back to video's. I think videos are and will be extremely important. I plan to make that a priority in the next year or two. The biggest problem I see is in getting the good video's to the public. Just posting them on youtube with all the others doesn't work unless they know to go there to a particular person. I'm looking at trying to link them to a website or to a newsgroup so we can weed out the bad ones and people will know to go to places like WC or AAW to find quality video's.

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#8

Not Metallica

James Fox

Although originally released by Metallica (with words), this version is by a group called "Apocalyptica."

Try their CD: "When Worlds Collide"

Also an interestingly modified bandsaw in the video.

James

Re: Making a perfect ball, and some thoughts (Long) *LINK*

#9

Re: Not Metallica

steve worcester

I am going with an instrumental, symphonic, version of Cold War Kids, Louder Than Ever.