Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Advice on Hollowing tools

Posts

Advice on Hollowing tools

#1

Advice on Hollowing tools

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Seasons greetings,

I have read through more articles and looked through every possible catalog and I'm just lost. I looked at the WC archives and see that there was a CHAT about this on 10/13/2010. I couldn't however read the thread of that CHAT.

In brief, what are some brands (for the beginning hollower) to look at and why you chose it. Was it price, ease of use, versatility? I would like to try my "hand" at some small vessels to start. My turning skills are good but I'm still building them.

I see several have changeable tips. This to me looks like an ongoing expense once there is nothing left to sharpen. I'm hesitant towards buying these types as the tool manufacturer may change the tool and then parts or tips may become unavailable.

Thanks,

Ray

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#2

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

Randy Gleckler

My personal advice on this.. is find something that looks like it will work and learn to use it. I use the Trent Hollowing system as it's what I was taught on and learned to use. I think I can use it fairly well. I've tried John Jordan's, which is similar, and believe it to is easy to use. I've not tried a captured system, but those who have really advocate and/or love it. Though it doesn't help here on deciding, if some of the local turners to your area have types you can try and feel, that may help you as well.

As for the Tips... I've used the Trent and Jordan's and haven't had to replace the tip but sharpened it many times (I'm not a full time turner by any means). I've only had to remove and replace the tips due to changing one to a different purpose. Otherwise, should you know or find a machinist they should be easy to have made should the manufacturer stop making them.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#3

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

George Guadiane

"Find something that looks like it will work and learn to use it." is excellent advice.

Everything wears out eventually, things need to be replaced...

I LOVE my Rolly Munro hollowers. I got the first two (large and small) before I got my Monster articulated arm hollower (which I also LOVE)... So I learned to hollow by hand first and I learned the tools. The Munro tools are a little expensive, but the articulation more than compensates for the higher price in my opinion. I have an extra link on each which doesn't adversely impact its use in the shallow parts of hollowing, but is IMMENSELY helpful while getting into the outer "hard to reach" areas. The cutters are hooded, which allows the tool to cut aggressively or to just cut the barest of angel hairs. The fact that it shear cuts rather than scrapes gives the trained hand a chance to get an excellent "off the tool" finish.

These things make hollowing a comparative breeze (IMHO).

NOW, about Randy Privitt's Monster articulated arm setup:

When I added this to the Munro tools, I got a combination that could only be described as remarkable. NO ONE has complained about the stock setup, including me. Now I haven't used those parts of the setup, but I believe that they work as advertised (and probably better). If I had not already learned the Munro, I would probably be using the Privitt supplied cutters and loving them.

The one thing I use and took for granted, till someone else pointed it out, is that unlike systems that hook up to the tailstock quill, the adjustability of the Monster base allows a MUCH MUCH greater range of accessibility. This access lets me design many more and varied shapes.

All in all, other than replacement cutters, screws and washers for the Munro tools, the cost is a bit steep, but ultimate in design and use for me. And, because replacing these few parts gives me even better tool control, I can't really complain about the cost. I COULD be buying golf balls or something.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#4

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

steve worcester

Almost any of the hand held tools I can think of are easily adapted to a captive system, like a Jamieson or D bar.

I have more hollowing tools than I care to admit to, and do mostly smaller (sub 10" hemispheres), but the Trent Bosch and John Jordan are real good, the McNaughton tools are good, and I am really loving the Hunter tools. I have done some burls lately with Hunter tools that the others just wouldn't last on (Teak Burl). While it is rare that would happen, and may depend on your wood stocks, the carbide cutters are awesome.

I have also started experimenting with a Vicmarc articulated system and I am quite pleased with it. I looked at the Kobra and it is real nice too.

But you can start with most any of the above tools in a handle, and then go to a home made D bar system, add a laser and see if that fits your style. If you make the D bar to accept a 3/4" bar, you can use Trent Bosch's adapters and go down to a 3/8" tool.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#5

Re: Using Munro tools wiith the Monster

Dinyar Chavda

George:

I have a question about what you're doing. I don't have the Munros, but I use the woodcut Proformes, which are pretty similar. I find that I have to twist the tool into different angles (by rotating the shaft) and that minor variations in that angle can make the difference between the tool cutting well and not. Because of this, I always thought that I could not use the ProFormes with the Monster. How do you get around that?

TIA

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

Lyle Jamieson

This is a big decision that sets the path you will take for all future hollowing. Use it before you buy it. Borrow it or go to a friends shop that has one and give it a trial run.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#7

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

Carole Valentine

Hi Ray,

I started out with the Kelton hollowers and while I have a number of others, they remain my favorites to this day. I use them both freehand and in a hollowing rig and they have done anything I needed, from hogging waste to finishing cuts. Very simple tools but extremely versatile. I think they are an excellent choice for beginners as well as advanced turners.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#8

Steve Kubien

I'm with Carole

Steve Kubien

I love the Keltons. They are less expensive than a lot of others and you can put whatever kind/shape/material of handle you like on them. I use mine on smaller forms (less than 7-8" depth) free-hand (no arm brace) and for larger I tend use my Jamieson rig.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#9

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools *LINK*

charlie belden

Before making suggestions - a few questions.

1. Are you turning on a "mini" lathe, regurlar sized lathe or one that you can turn "outboard"

2. What size "hollowing" do you have in mind in terms of "Outside Diameter", "Depth"

and opening diameter tool must fit through?

If you haven't done any hollow forms, starting with christmas ornament sized stuff, hollowing

through a 3/4" diameter hole would be a good place to start. If you have a grinder, a hacksaw

and some allen wrenches you can make a workable hollowing tool to hollow with - and get used

to turning "blind". For $20 you can get an ornament scale hollowing tool Bob Rosand makes

and uses to turn his ornaments and little birdhouses.

Going up in size, you probably should be looked at a curved "goose neck" tool. Unlike an

"L shaped" tool, the "goose neck" gas the cutting edge in line with the tool's shank. This keeps

the torque on the handle to a minimum. John Jordan makes a hollowing tool like this in

several diameter's of shanks - 3/8, 1/2 and 3/4 if I recall correctly.

If you want a "captured hollowing system there are a lot of choices. When I was looking to

buy one, I went with the MiniMonster because I'm turning on a JET Mini. It's a very

complete set that'll cover the range of hollowing you're apt to do, is easy to set up, doesn't

need a lot of space to store - and it comes with a laser set up that's pretty solid when set.

If you want to look at most of the hollowing systems out there, at least as of a couple

of years ago, try the attached link.


Hollowing Systems Compendium

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#10

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

Ralph Lindberg

Ray, you've had some generally good advise. One more item. I really like hollowing in "reverse", that is with the lathe turning backwards and hollowing on the other side.

The reason is, you can watch and control what you are doing easier.

If your lathe can go both ways, consider if the tool is reversable.

Me, I use a Don Pencil (which is), and a number of cutters, including Don's, Sorby and some custom.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#11

Ellis Walentine

Chat transcript *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

In case you want to see what a raw chat transcript looks like, Ray, here's the first one we had on hollowing back in October. My article is now in print, by the way, in the new issue of Woodworker's Journal. They didn't label the tools I included, and the article is pretty rudimentary, but hopefully it'll be useful.

One thing that others haven't mentioned is the connection between shaft vibration and its length and diameter. In other words, for larger, deeper hollowforms, you need longer, thicker tools. Most of the manufacturers offer a variety of shank sizes for you to choose from.

Ellis


Hollowing Chat (unedited)

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#12

Bill Blasic

Re: Chat transcript

Bill Blasic

I use the Monster Articulating Hollowing System and I use the Kelton and the Jordan hollowers with it. Dream combination as both of these sets of tools work so well.

Bill

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#13

Re: Chat transcript - Thanks Ellis

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Looks like a lot reading but at quick glance I see some very useful info. Much appreciated.

Ray

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#14

Re: Hollowing tools

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Okay. I have some good advice here and a few questions from you.

I own a full size lathe Grizzly G0462. I have some basic lathe tools. A skew, round nose scraper, parting tool and a couple of Doug Thompson bowl gouges. I have a four jaw chuck, calipers, ball bearing centers, etc.

I was looking to start on some SMALL hollow forms. Maybe in the 5-8 inch deep range. I wouldn't rule out smaller if it means it would be easier to get started and to ease the learning curve.

I'm not exactly sure what "captured" turning means in terms of hollowing. The only time I've seen this is with a ring on a shaft.

Ray

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#15

Re: Hollowing tools

Carole Valentine

Ray,

If you have never turned hollow forms before I would recommend that you start with a "semi-enclosed" form - a piece with a wide opening sort of in between an open bowl and a true hollow form. You would get the feel for the cuts required in the shoulder area, but with the large opening would still be able to somewhat see what the tool is doing under various presentations of the cutting edge. In fact, whenever I get a new hollowing tool or cutter, I always try it out first on an open bowl so I can observe the cutting action.

An 8" hollow form is actually pretty large to start with in hand hollowing. I would think 4" deep would be a good place to start.

As for captured rigs, they basically "capture" the boring bar, eliminating torque (which can be considerable in deep hollowing!) and they keep the cutter at the correct height. Articulated systems serve the same purpose. Most of them can be fitted with a laser to gauge wall thickness. I use the Kelton hollowing rig with laser. It is my understanding that some of the articulated systems are not able to hollow as deep as a true "captured" rig without excessive vibration, but I have not personally used an articulated system for deep hollowing. Just my two cents worth! ;)

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#16

Re: Hollowing tools *LINK*

john lucas

Ray I'm a fan of John Jordan's tools. There simple. The cutters are easy to find aftermarket if need be and easy to sharpen. The tools were designed after 20 or more years of doing hollow forms so the shapes work really well.

See the link below for one style of captured bar system. Basically the tools are sitting on 2 tool rests perfectly aligned with the center of the turning. This greatly reduces the chances of catches. Since the tool is fully supported you simply guide the cutter. It takes away a lot of the stresses of hollowing.

I put a link to Lyle's page because it is an excellent description of how the systems work. He also has instructions to build your own if your so inclined. There are several other systems on the market. The Monster Tool articulated system gets a lot of good press on this newsgroup.


https://www.lylejamieson.com/tools/index.asp

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#17

Leo Cuellar

Re: Hollowing tools

Leo Cuellar

Hi Ray. If you have the cheaper Grizzly 4 jaw chuck... buy a good one before you try this. I know from experience they don't have the holding power & accuracy for this kind of work. I use an 0462 also. I forged my own tools from leaf spring, they are patterned after the Kelton tools that Carole recommended, but with differences.



I haven't done a lot of hollow form work yet, but I like the way they cut.

If you follow the link that Charlie gave you, at the bottom of the first page is another link:

To a Compendium of Hollowing Systems ------->

That will show you some excellent examples of what a captured system is :)

Leo

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#18

Re: Using Munro tools wiith the Monster

George Guadiane

Dinyar,

The optimal cutting angle for the hooded Munro (and any hooded cutters I would imagine) is SLIGHTLY above center and 90 degrees from vertical.

If the cutter is rotated down or below center, there is a SLIGHTLY larger opening. that larger opening takes a MUCH bigger (more aggressive) cut and clogs the cutter or grabs and sucks into the wood.

Real success comes from adjusting the "aperture," big opening on the cutting side with slower rotations for hogging out and tiny opening with higher speeds for finishing cuts. SHARP cutters rotated often and I found the carbide cutters well worth the additional expense.

Hope that helps,

G

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#19

EXCELLENT ADVICE!

George Guadiane

:D

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#20

Re:Hollowing tools

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Thank you Charlie. The diagrams were very helpful.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#21

Dick Hines

Re: Hollowing tools

Dick Hines

Ray , my suggestion is to learn hollowing free handed and then try before you buy a hollowing rig.

If you find you don't like hollowing you are not out so much money. And hollowing by hand on small pieces if blast.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#22

Re: Using Munro tools wiith the Monster

Dinyar Chavda

Hey, George after reading your reply last night, I got onto YouTube, and watched various tools with hooded cutters. I also went back and reread the directions on the ProForme. While both Wally Munro and Shane Hewitt (on ProForms) do occasionally tilt the tool, the vast majority of their turning is done the way you describe it, with the cutting tool horizontal in both axes. As an aside, I was surprised at the number of hollowing demos online! There was even a demo of the Munro tool on the Elbo system. So today, I set up my ProFormes on the Monster, and, rather than trying to hollow, I took an old fairly hard and dry piece of cherry, and cut it as though I was making a platter out of it, so that I could see what I was doing. I was amazed as to how well it cut with a sharp tool (the Munro does have an edge over the Proforme in terms of sharpening), with the tool completely horizontal, and what a smooth cut I got. It may not be what I would choose to go into a hollow form with a small hole (the Keltons do a great job for that), but with a reasonably-sized hole, it did an excellent job.

Thanks for your help.

By the way, Ray, if you're reading this, you can get a good exposure to a variety of hollowing tools in action just by going to YouTube, and searching for "hollowing" and then going from one link to another.

Thanks, again, George.

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#23

Re:Youtube for hollowing videos

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Thanks Dinyar. Yes, I read your post. :)

I was actually on Youtube prior to writing my post here on WC. I went back after reading all the replies. I've always learned a lot by just watching people and also by trial and error.

I'm leaning towards the John Jordans or the Keltons. I have to see what my budget will allow....as usual.

Ray

Re: Advice on Hollowing tools

#24

Steven Antonucci

There are two things to consider

steven antonucci

the first is the cutter and the bar it attaches to. You see most bars are just bars, and marked up terribly for the amount of machining that goes into them (a hole drilled, a small flat grind...) the cutters can be discs, carbide, bits, hooks, etc...

The second is the "rear" of the tool. The rear of any system has one function: Keep the cutter level and on centerline. It can be captured, a snake, a platform, etc- but in the end it achieves the objective of flat.

If you want to add a third function, you can add measuring. Laser, calipers or wire... your choice. The idea is to stop cutting before you run out of wood.

Most people spend far too much money on keeping the cutter level, as if it was a difficult task. a wooden box on the ways will accomplish this.

If you want to get a full discourse on hollowing, come up to Peters Valley on Jan 22 for the Water Gap Woodturners meeting. We are going to do a deep dive on hollowing...

Steve