I'm turning a small black walnut bowl. This is my first time working with this wood. I've completed turning the outside on centers, and now I've chucked the bowl and am turning the inside. But as I'm turning the inside I'm having big catches (gouges) happen which make turning this thing not too much fun. I have to stop, reposition the bowl and begin again just for it to happen once more. What am I doing wrong?? I thought it might be my gouges weren't sharp, but for christmas I got new ones and it does it with them also, maybe even worse. After a dozen or so of those explosions my nerves are nearly done and this thing might be firewood soon. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
Are you near a club where you can get some mentoring? Catches with a gouge usually mean that you are doing something fundamentally wrong and until you correct that issue, you will continue to have such frustration.
I can guess that it's probably cutting in the wrong direction with the flute pointed toward the outside of the bowl, and likely off bevel too, because that's the most common issue I see when I teach. Even after seeing it, explaining it, and correcting it multiple times, people tend to go back to old habits. If you are on the inside of the bowl, your gouge's flute should be at about 2 o'clock and only cutting in the direction of rim to bottom.
Lance, your statement that you are having problems even with a new gouge suggests that you may not be shaping and sharpening your gouges before using them. If that is the case, I would echo Steve's suggestion that you get some help from a local club or any of the several books or videos on basic woodturning techniques. I can envision that you may be trying to trying to hollow a deepish bowl with a spindle gouge that has an acute nose angle. Keep at it! Dennis
I hate to tell you this, but Steve is probably right. I just received a 1/4" bowl gauge for Christmas and, even without sharpening, it cut beautifully, with out any catches. I'll admit it was not black walnut but cherry. If you can't find a club or mentor close, get some good DVD's on bowl turning. Good luck and let us see the final result.
If you don't have a club nearby or someone who can help you, go to Youtube.com and look at some of the woodturning and woodturning tool sharpening videos and see what they are doing different from what you are doing. It isn't as good as individual instruction but, it may help you with your challenge. I believe there is also a sharpening video on the AAW site also but, I'm not sure. Whatever you do, don't give up!
If you are following the fundamentals of turning a bowl with a gouge, you should not get a monstrous catch. If the tool is dull, you may not get a nice, smooth cut, but you should get no major catches, either.
My first guess was cutting in the wrong direction, as Steve pointed out. Could it also be possible that you've gotten used to a gouge with a particular shape and profile, and are presenting this new gouge to the wood in a way that might have worked for your old gouge, but is not appropriate for the shape and profile of this new tool? You may need to re-visit the fundamental "rules of engagement" between edge, bevel, and wood.
I know some years ago my dad had gotten very comfortable cutting the inside of a bowl profile with the flute up, taking a "back cut", or cutting on the left side, as you looked down toward the end of the flute. Then he tried it with my new side grind (Ellsworth) profile on the same 3/8" Sorby Bowl gouge, with repeated disasters! He had not really learned the fundamentals of presenting the bevel and the flute to the tool and incrementally engaging the cutting edge -- rather, he knew what angle "worked" for his English grind from trial and error, and tried stuffing my gouge into the wood at the same (wrong, for this grind) angle. Bang! --- #$@%$.... Bang! ^%$#^... BANG!, and thus a return to re-learn the fundamental rules.
One of the best things you could do to get advice here would be to try to replicate the problem while turning the lathe very slowly -- maybe by hand. That will allow you to see what's happening, and if you can take a photo of the tool, the way its presented to the wood, and the resulting catch, we could be more helpful. Otherwise, one-on-one tutoring or coaching from a turning mentor is really the best possible solution.
Hang in there, return to fundamentals, and you'll be making sweet Walnut bowls in no time.
I'm not certain that particular video clip will be very helpful, though we have not heard about the profile of Lance's gouge yet. Though the turner shows good body movement and keeps the tool tucked in nicely, he is entering the wood with a fairly vertical flute (facing nearly "up"), and cutting on both sides of the tip at various times... I would look for an entry that has the flute almost over on its side (facing say 2:30), and carefully controlling the angle of the tool in the 3 principal planes to make a secure, slicing cut without skittering across the bowl face. It can also be helpful to lower the handle and tool rest (cut still at center), instead of keeping things so horizontal.
Bill Grumbine shows the 45/45/45 bowl gouge cut pretty well, which may be a good place to start. Otherwise, we'll have to wait for Lance to offer up a few more details to help.
I would highly suggest buying Bill's video. I posted an Amazon link below. He covers how to cut and how the tool cuts and everything else in between. It's clear and well done and you will learn an awful lot. He covers everything from finding the wood, sharpening the tools and using them. Many of the videos on youtube are not clear enough to see how the tools is held.
I certainly agree with Steve. I think the problem is how you approach the wood with the tools. I don't think you mentioned what tool you were using or the brand. That might help us identify the problem. Some tools come with really bad grinds that are hard to work with even if they are sharp.
I agree with what most everyone else has said. It sounds like you could benefit from some hands-on instruction or mentoring from and experienced turner. One other caution, just because a gouge is new doesn't mean it is sharp. Or, that the edge is shaped for the task at hand. Both of these things can make turning without catches very difficult. Please get some good instruction before you developbad habits and techniques that you will have to unlearn beofre you learn the right way. Before you can learn to turn, you need to learn how to sharpen.
I agree with what most everyone else has said. It sounds like you could benefit from some hands-on instruction or mentoring from and experienced turner.
One other caution, just because a gouge is new doesn't mean it is sharp. Or, that the edge is shaped for the task at hand. Before you can learn to turn, you need to learn how to sharpen.
Both of these things can make turning without catches very difficult. Please get some good instruction now, before you develop bad habits and techniques that you will have to unlearn before you learn the right way.
Thanks for all the great replies. I'm sure I'm at fault here, my technique needs some improvement for sure. I bought the video off of amazon that was suggested, hopefully that helps. I've been turning pens and other small bowls for a few years now, this is the first time I've ever had this problem using walnut. Thanks again, you all are great!!