Automach or Arbortech Mini?
steven antonucci
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Automach or Arbortech Mini?
steven antonucci
Re: Automach or Arbortech Mini?
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio
Re: Automach or Arbortech Mini?
john lucas
I'm guessing you guys are referring to a previous post but don't understand these posts. The Automach and Arbortech Mini are two different machines that do two different things but I think you know that.
Not previous, just which to buy for myself.
steven antonucci
I always have this issue and it's just a poll to see which one folks would choose...
S
Re: Not previous, just which to buy for myself.
Lyle Jamieson
no contest...arbortech
Re: Not previous, just which to buy for myself.
john lucas
It depends entirely on what you are carving. I have the Ryobi version of the Automach and the Arbortec mini. The Arbotec is great for things like carving feet and handles on vessels, roughing out flutes and spirals and or course carving nudes (that's why Lyle likes it). It's not so great for fine detiails or making long gently curves (think John Jordan, Al Stirt here).
Since my style bounces all over the place I'm a bigger fan of the rotary carvers like Dremel and Foredom.
I use the Arbortec for roughing out and rapid removeal of stock. It cuts so quick and easy you have to actually look at it because it's hard to feel what it's doing. You can take some pretty fine cuts but it can also remove wood you don't want to remove at an alarming rate.
The Automach on the other hand lets you cut V grooves and remove very fine amounts of material with lots of control. You can cut up to very steep corners and even undercut things like leaves. These areas you can't do with the Arbortec and have trouble doing with rotary carvers.
I have the same issue you do, John
steven antonucci
I do a little bit of both, and I could potentially do more of either with the tool making it easier. Right now, it's all chisels and a mallet...
Decisions, decisions...
S
Does the Arbortech Mini include the grinder?
steven antonucci
Or is it just the extension for $234?!
S
Re: Does the Arbortech Mini include the grinder?
Richard Allen
The $234 includes the grinder.
Aas others have said this is for FAST stock removal. In between the control of the automach and the arbortech is a band file.
Band files are most often air powered tools but there are electric ones. The band file can remove stock fairly fast and you get good control. Because it is a belt sander you don't get quite as much detail as you might with a sharp edge.
Re: I have the same issue you do, John
Alan Zenreich
"... chisels and a mallet..."
hmmm, how does one mount a laser on the mallet? < vbg >
Ask Charlie Belden
steven antonucci
Re: Not previous, just which to buy for myself.
Lyle Jamieson
I totally agree with John. I do everything with rotary tools. Starting with a chain saw, arbortech, die grinder burs, foredom. The variety of burrs available will get you into any spots you want to reach.
air powered or electric?
steven antonucci
Re: air powered or electric?
john lucas
CAn't speak for Lyle but I use almost entirely electric. Mostly because I haven't had the money to install a new 220 line to the shop so I can run my new (to me) compressor. I do have a mini strip sander, die grinder and air body saw that I use from time to time that are air powered.
Re: air powered or electric?
Lyle Jamieson
Yes, Both. I use a wide fluted burr called "alumacut" in the air powered die grinder to hog off green wood like butter. When I get to finish shaping dry wood with sanding disks and drums, they are usually powered by electric tools like Dremmel, Foredom, or my drill press, or my radial arm saw. Yes, without the saw blade, pull the motor all the way out to the front and put a 3 inch drum sander with a 50 grit drum and you can have a powerful shaper for dry wood.
Thats a whole topic in itself. It takes different tools for carving wet wood and dry wood.
Re: Does the Arbortech Mini include the grinder?
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
Steve, I think you need both, but I probably use the mini more, although your milage may vary. The mini does offer some little sanding pads, which are OK, but the little plastic pad that the abrasive is mounted on is the best part.
After the paper is shot, you can pull it off, then skuff the face up with the coarsest grit you have in the shop. Then spray it with high strength contact. I guess I should mention that I have a set of punches that go up to 2", but I use one about 1 3/8" here. I punch out a cloth pad from an old polartec, and saturate it with the spray contact when I coat the backing pad.
Then I punch out my own disk from sticky back 6" disk which I keep for my Random Orbit sander to use on this pad. You would not believe how nice, fast and clean these things cut. They stay on very good. In fact I have to press them into a scrap to heat it up before I can peel them off.
Rather than change between the mini blades and the sanding disk, I also have a little Proxxon motor, which will also accept these cutters and sanding disk. I didn't like it as much as the Arbortech, for the cutter, but it is perfect for the sander. This is one of the most used tools in my shop.
Re: Does the Arbortech Mini include the grinder?
Terry Scott
I have 3 mini arbotecs that I brought as attachments and added to my own grinders
They sell for $200 to $255 each Nz Here just for the kit very over priced for what they are.They last however Ive only had to replace one set of bearings .It does pay to buy a spare belt or two
There is talk that Arbotec maybe no longer supplying the kits you will have to buy the grinder and adapter all in one
The only down fall is they can be a bit bulky if you are doing fine detail
I also have the Proxxon which is so under powered at 130w Ive burnt it out twice ,It is in the draw as I didn't get it replaced under warranty the second time
Id highly recommend throwing away the blade that comes with the mini arbotec as they run and tear grain like you wouldn't believe Get a Merlin from King Arthur's tools
Good advice.
steven antonucci
Thanks-
I spoke to the CSR's at Arbortech USA and they do not sell the kit detached from the grinder in the US any longer. Too many support issues.
Will look at perhaps fabricating my own...
Steve
thanks- good thoughts
steven antonucci