Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

It's best you don't know....

Posts

It's best you don't know....

#1

Steven Antonucci

It's best you don't know....

steven antonucci

I'm betting that the only reason I managed to pull this off is that I didn't know I was doing it at the time...

I made this goblet today from a piece of ash limb from the firewood pile. When I put it on the lathe, I thought I had moved the pith over enough to compensate, but instead, I had put it EXACTLY on center.

As I started working on the stem, I hit a spongy pith that I knew wouldn't turn out, so decided to leave it. Figured it would be one small blemish, but little did I know...

I decided to make this goblet with a few captured rings, and took the time to cut three of them, but I cut two off afterwards because I thought it looked cluttered. The two rejects are sitting in the foreground...


When I finally took it off the lathe, it blew my mind. Most of the stem was actually only pith! The stem is hollow from the bottom of the bowl at the top, all the way down to the foot of the goblet. I spent about an hour with various picks and such removing the spongy part, and you can see daylight looking through the entire length of the goblet...

About 10" tall with a 3/16" hollow stem...

Happy accidents...

Steve

Re: It's best you don't know....

#2

Re: It's best you don't know....

Guy Bratt

I did one like that, didn't know the pith was mush. Didn't end nearly as well

Re: It's best you don't know....

#3

Ellis Walentine

Would you do it again?

Ellis Walentine

What's the advantage of trying to turn a goblet from a limb with the pith in the center? If you're going to go to all that trouble, wouldn't you want to avoid the pith? I'm curious, because I haven't turned a goblet in many years and would like to do it again the right way. Is there a right way?

(I know I can google this, and probably find something right here, but it never hurts to raise a topic again.)

Ellis

PS Nice form, Steve.

Re: It's best you don't know....

#4

Re: Would you do it again?

Barry Irby

Not Steve, but the answer is no, he would not do it again on purpose. It would be foolish, stands about a 90% chance of failure.

If you want to turn a goblet from a piece with the pith in it, center it so that the pith is off center and not the axis of rotation. You still end up with the pith in the cup and base, but not in the stem. I would suggest you avoid it altogether and use a piece that does not have the pith in it. If you have fire wood, choose a piece large enough to allow you to cut away the pith and work with that.

Re: It's best you don't know....

#5

Re: Would you do it again?

john lucas

I agree with Barry. I've turned goblets both ways and leaving the pith completely out is the best way. You can get by with leaving the pith just off center on some species but you risk checking in the pith and sometimes the stesses in the wood will make the goblet lean.

The best thing I've found for this solution is to turn the stem out of another species. this gets rid of the pith in every part except the bottom of the bowl but I have also drilled that out and left the contrasting wood in the bottom.

I quit making solid wood goblets. It was too much stress worrying about how to clean it, will it stain, what finish will hold up etc. I now make my goblets with glass bowls. I buy goblets and cut the stem off so it becomes a short tenon. Then glue this into the stem and foot. I tried the goblet bowls from Craft Supplies but they don't have a stem so you are forced to glue the bowl to the wood. The glue shows in the bottom and looks terrible. I use clear silicone caulk to glue the bowls in the wood.

Re: It's best you don't know....

#6

Re: It's best you don't know....

Bob Macgregor

This would make a great gag gift for somebody who imbibes a bit too much...a self-draining wineglass!

BOB

Re: It's best you don't know....

#7

Steven Antonucci

Would I do it again?  I just may...

steven antonucci

Thanks for the compliment on form, Ellis.

I made it from a limb on a whim. I was standing in the shop and thought about making something. Not just turning. Actually making something. I have started to differentiate the two in my head lately, as I often turn for nothing but the practice and the enjoyment I get.

This was made with the end goal of having a finished piece. That means that I took a very long look at what I was doing. I made the best cuts I could make. I sanded (gasp!). It was purely an accident that the pith was centered, since I thought I had moved it out of the way by enough that it would have been cut away at the very end. It was my intention to go down to 1/8", but I stopped when I got to the pith because it would have been 1/16" by the time I cut it (and I know I am not that good, ...yet...)

So I decided that I was going to leave it in. As I progressed down the stem, it became apparent that it wasn't one little spot, but more or less a streak. When I finished, I could see that there was a harmonizing of the universe in my shop yesterday. Any more vibration, it would have snapped. A 1/16" to either side, and it would have been off-center. If it was cherry instead of ash, no mushy pith. A perfect storm...

Will I ever do it again? Who knows... but you can rest assured that I will be looking at those limbs in my wood pile for another piece like this one pretty soon...

S