Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

Posts

Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#1

Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

charlie belden

A couple of days or so ago, Terry Scott asked how to CALCULATE a stretcher length between legs of a three legged stool. I posted what I thought was the solution - and was WRONG. So I went back and ground away on the problem and I THINK I've got a simplified version of a solution.

What I need now is a MATH WIZ to review the derivation of the equation and verify that it is, in fact, correct - or not. If it is correct, I'll go on to Step 2 and include the diameter of the stool legs at the point where the stretchers meet the OUTSIDE of the leg rather than where they meet the CENTERLINE of the leg which is what my equation assumes.

Here's a pseudo isometric view of a three legged stool that illustrates the geometric relationships


And here's the derivation of the equation I think is correct


The goal is to come up with an equation and supporting table of the sine of some leg angles that will let anyone with a simple pocket calculator calculate stretcher lengths for three legged stools by plugging in the distance from the top of the leg to the stretcher, the angle of the leg and the distance from the center of the stool's top to the center of the top of a stool leg. Might do an Excel spreadsheet if this solution is correct.

This may be a waste of time, but it's an interesting problem to play with.

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#2

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

Peter Lamb

Charlie, You are amazing to say nothing about very knowledgible!

Great effort! Thanks even if I never use it. For sure others will!

P

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#3

But Is It Correct?!

charlie belden

I THINK this is right - but I'm too close to it to be able to tell if it is. By including all the steps for deriving the final equation I hope a math wiz can spot any mistakes - and let me know.

This is just high school geometry and trig, not rocket science at all. Keeping track of which plane I was working with was the hard part, requiring doing the illustrations. They were the tricky part ; )

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#4

Re: But Is It Correct?!

Doc Green

Charlie, I got the same result using a slightly different method. To clarify the terminology, the angle the legs are splayed out (angle A1) is measured from a line perpendicular to the plane of the seat, and L1 is the distance from the seat to where the stretcher is to be attached, measured along the length of the leg.

My method was to obtain your Eqn 4 for B2 and then use the law of cosines. This avoids having to use the trapezoid.

~Doc

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#5

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

Philip Duffy

If we accept that all these calulations are correct then how does one account for the variances that occur when the legs are not all at the precise angle depicted and the depth of the hole bored in each receiving leg of a stretcher is slightly different? For me, it boils down to adding 3/4 of an inch x 2 to the distance between the facing legs and then adding 1/2 in to ensure that the proper amount of force is applied to each leg. Should I discover that there is too much force during the "dry -fit" stage then a minor adjustment to the stretcher length is cut off. - - just 2cents. Philip

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#6

Forget the calculations

Doc Green

Phillip, you got it; you hit the nail on the head. Practically speaking, the calculations are of little value. ~Doc

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#7

Slip Sticks - Actually Slip Dowels

charlie belden

Terry asked for a way to CALCULATE stretcher lengths and it seems the provided equation, with accompanying Sine Table, will do that.

But I totally agree with the Measure Directly approach. Traditional joinery usually means you can dry fit the parts you have and measure distances between those dry fit parts with slip sticks or slip dowels and a couple of spring clips. No calculations or measuring tape required - and another source of error avoided (was it 14 and 3/8ths or 14 and 3/16ths - or may 14 and 3/4?)

Stretcher lengths are the easy part of chair / stool work. Drilling the holes in the proper place, at the proper angleS is the tricky part, especially on legs. For drilling holes in the seat, the old Brace & Bit, the bit being a Spoon Bit, is still the best bet. With spoon bits, you can adjust your angle some - as you're drilling. And there's something to be said for tapered holes and tapered tenons.

Re: Need MATH Wiz: 3 Legged Stool Stretcher Length

#8

Re: Need MATH Wiz: Thanks guys

Terry Scott

Thanks guys for you input ,this has proven to be a very interesting subject