Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Slurry: a no-no in my shop

Posts

Slurry: a no-no in my shop

#1

Slurry: a no-no in my shop

mjonesrdg

I googled Velvit to see if I could help answer the bleed-back problem posted earlier. I was surprised to see the company advocated sanding up a slurry to fill the pores of the wood. It's a very bad practise, in my opinion, because you will inevitably lose some of the pop or color of your piece. Light slurry gets into the pores of dark wood and vice versa, changing the contrasts between the two. The result can be a dull and lifeless appearance to the surface of the work.

If one wipes the slurry sufficiently to eleiminate that problem, then the value of the slurry is lost. In some cases, depending upon the species you are working, you cannot wipe (or even wash) the slurry completely as it is taken into the deeper pores. The solution then is to sand it back (dry) until you have gotten past the absorbed "dirt". Clearly, it's a no-brainer....don't do it.

The better practice is to seal, dry, dry sand, seal, and dry, until there is a light, dry film of finish, then go to wet sanding...and always wiping and blowing off residue between grits and applications of finish.

What say you? Velvit's recommendation, or no?

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

#2

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

John Veerkamp

I think it depends on what you're trying to achieve. If you have fairly uniform wood and want to fill the pores, then sanding with slurry may be the way to go. As in everything else in woodwork, there is no one answer for anything.

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

#3

Never Say Never in my shop

George Guadiane

Your observations and feelings certainly have value...

But, sanding wet certainly has its place in my shop. I use oil and find it a great help MOST of the time. As I see it, the oil still brings out the figure.

The pores have no figure of their own to show and, in my mind won't change the prominence of existing figure, empty or full of "dirt."

On segmented pieces, where light/dark "dirt" can get into dark/light pores, I prefer dry sanding.

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

#4

Another tool in the kit for the right time

Bill Howatt

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

#5

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

Barbara Gill

The technique of wet sanding has been around for quite a long time. It certainly is not unique to Velvit Products. As others have said; it has it's place.

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

#6

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

Mac Ray

For open grain woods like walnut and mahogany,wet sanding is a good alternative to filling the pores with any other type of filler.......it has worked well for me for many years and on those type of woods I see no muddying of the grain as the oil pops the grain more than enough to offset the filling of pores...........may not suit everyone,but it suits me just fine...............

Re: Slurry: a no-no in my shop

#7

I like a smooth feel to the wood....

adrien