For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
Posts
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#2Re: Click on the pdf left hand corner
Terry Scott
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#3Re: Click on the pdf left hand corner
Jorge Casta�eda
Terry, I
t could be done with trig, but is just geometry is just geometry, make a scale drawing, or life size with cardboard and just measure. you don't need to draw the legs, just the center lines for starters.
Lets hope JL chimes in, he doe lots of chairs and such.
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#4No Trig Solution
charlie belden
My 11th grade Geometry teacher beat a lot of stuff into my head I figured I'd have forgotten by now.
You have Mrs. Graham to thank for this Geometry solution - no trig required - so a simple calculator can be used - along with a tape measure, pencil and paper.

Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#5Trig solution
Dinyar Chavda
sl=st+. 0.35265396*sd
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#6Re: No Trig Solution
Terry Scott
New you'd come to the party Thanks Charlie
I only went to school to eat my lunch
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#7Re: No Trig Solution
Bruce Pratt
I think for Charlie's solution, H1 and H2 need to be measured in the plane defined by the two legs, not the vertical distance to the floor.
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#8I'm glad I don't make chairs....
adrien Coblentz
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#9
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
JL
What is wrong with the empirical approach?
Angles and sight lines I draw and calculate. Stretcher length is variable. I have a general idea about how long my stretchers are going to be.
I always measure. Typically for a side stretcher, I have 5/8" tenons on the ends of the stretchers. I may not always have the exact same depth when I drill the mortise hole in the leg. I take my "calibrated" measuring sticks and figure out what length I need for my stretcher. I also have to make sure that it is centered in the space (as I'm going to be drilling the side stretchers for the center stretcher holes).
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#10Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
john lucas
I can barely balance my checkbook. Consequently I do it like JL . I like a little tension in my legs so I spread them slightly and then using 2 small sticks that I stick in the holes for the tenon I take a measurement. This is the length of my tenon. I make most 3 or 4 legged stools but will be doing another chiar shortly.
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#11
Re: No-Math solution
Keith Tompkins
HI Terry, Before I became a turning addict, I was a furniture maker. I worked in a shop that produced 300 chairs a day. Every day. I built the prototypes, and then production jigs. Before that, my responsibility was to set up the machinery to produce the parts; one mistake, according to the boss, cost him in excess of 10K., so there wasn't much room for error. To complicate things, the front legs of a well-designed chair are not at the same angle as the rear. I worked at that job for nine years, and ended up with several patents for computing, and boring, compound angles.
Anyway, here's a simple, no math solution: First, locate and bore your seat for the legs. An accurate drill press is the best; I use a radial drill press. Next mill the stock for the legs, form the tenon, but leave the legs square. Then, determine the distance from the seat to the center of the tenon. Rip a piece of thin scrap plywood, etc. to that dimension. Lay it across the legs, as in #2 illustration, and draw a line. (This compensates for any error in drilling the holes) Use a bevel gauge to check the angle, (3), then transfer the angle to the drill press, using a piece of straight round stock in the chuck, tilting the table until the angles match. (4) Drill the legs, using a stop for repeatable accuracy. If your angles don't match, you can repeat this process for each leg. You can intentionally alter the angles by a degree or so to create tension on the tenons once assembled.
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#12Wow Keith, fast graphics work
Mike Foster
and well thought out and easy to understand. I think I could do it with your description. I would love to see your solutions in the production shop.
Mike
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#13
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
Keith Tompkins
Nece settee, JL. I like the workbench as well, I'm planning a new one, so that caught my eye. Sometimes, the "empirical" approach is the only way, especially if you're in uncharted territory.
Building a piece like the one you pictured is not for the faint-of -heart. One trying to duplicate this piece will discover that even though they used the same angles for all the leg holes in the seat, the stretchers won't fit...the center one will fit, but the end stretchers cannot be installed...too long; AND the distance from the bottom of the front leg to the bottom of the back leg is WAY off when comparing the center pair to the end pairs. Welcome to compound angles! One will soon discover, after ruining a few seats, that the end leg holes must be bored at a greater angle than the center holes.
This image shows the effect of rotating the boring pattern...the dotted circle represents where the leg will contact the floor, the heavy arrow represents the direction of the angle. Note the difference between dimension A and X!
The empirical method isn't always the best way, especially when it comes to turning . Lessons by a good teacher will shorten the learning curve dramatically.
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#14
Re:solutions in production shop
Keith Tompkins
Hey Mike...thanks. Here is one solution I came up with. A compound-angle gauge. The gauge consists of graduations on two planes, vertical and horizontal. I can move the "measuring stick" to any desired vertical angle, then rotate in in a horizontal plane as well, creating an easy to duplicate compound angle. (excuse the poor drawing) In practice, using two of these gauges, I could set my angles, check the distance between the two measuring sticks, and bore a chair seat for legs, back, arms, etc. No guesswork...comes out correctly the first attempt. Oh yeah...I built a compound-angle drill press using the same concept; I had the entire machine shop at the factory at my disposal.
(These were some of the ideas they patented, I got a pat on the back for it. 
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#15Re: No-Math solution
Bill Neddow
Great ideas for the mathematically-challenged like me. Even I could do this.
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#16You're Right! (OOPS)
charlie belden
Back to the drawing board. Hopefully no trig.
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#17
Check out this site: *LINK*
steven antonucci
peter galbert is a buddy of mine and a chairmaker. Lots of stuff you can use. None of it is hard or fancy...
Re: For the Mathematicians ( help needed)
#18Two stretchers
Jorge Casta�eda
Terry,
I build stools and never did any math, also, life is easier if you make them with only two stretchers, one goes between two legs, the other from the middle of the first stretcher to the third leg. I make the first stretcher fatter in the middle, where it is going to be bored for the second one. If I can find a picture soon I'll post it.
The stools with only two stretchers, seem to hold better than the ones with three. I always bore through, scarf and wedge all the joints, and glue of course.



