Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

bevel rubbing a scraper

Posts

bevel rubbing a scraper

#1

bevel rubbing a scraper

john lucas

To try and answer a question the other night I tried rubbing the bevel of a scraper. I had never done that, thought it was a no no. Well it works. However you had better not come off the bevel or you are inviting a large catch.

If you polish off the burr it cuts cleaner. Not as clean as a spindle gouge but better than flat scraping with a burr.

If you use it at a skew angle with no burr it cuts like a spindle gouge, or at least it would if you sharpened them to the same angle. It catches just like a spindle gouge when used this way which of course makes sense since the tool angles are identical.

I cut a bunch of coves. What I didn't try, and I will today, is cutting coves that connect with a sharp reverse V at the top. Most scrapers won't do this without tearing off the top of the point.

Does anyone out there use a scraper with the bevel rubbing?

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#2

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

Matt Birchfield

All the time... look up Myron Curtis' Drop-Nose Scraper. He has made a career of architectural turning using scrapers with the bevel rubbing.

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#3

Bedan and Chisel...

Jerry Hall

are commonly bevel guided tools are they not? The only variation is the width of the tool, and the forces that develop as the tool gets wider. Does this make sense?

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#4

Steven Antonucci

Sometimes, but not often...

steven antonucci

I have tried it, but with all of the kids running around the shop, I prefer to use a gouge, which is a little more forgiving when a 4 year old screams "Daddy" or your 12 year old son suddenly plasters his face in the garage window.

Assume you mean on face grain in bowl orientation?

S

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#5

Re: Bedan and Chisel...

Clifton C

Jerry, to some degree, however the drop nose and other scrapers

that Myron uses are not ground to an acute of an angle as the Bedan (which is

35 deg.) I�ve watched turners using the Bedan as a scraper, but as there is not much mass, as in steel, under the scraping edge, the edge does not seem to last long. I'll admit to using my skew as a negative rake scraper on occasions but only for light, finishing cuts.

c

Ps. Myron is our club Sage, Mentor, and a wellspring of knowledge...

but I am biased

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

Keith Tompkins

Good topic John...You and I think very much alike. When I get a minute, I'll send you a pic of my latest grind. :)

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#7

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

john lucas

I'm going out on a limb here and try to discuss some differences in scrapers. I have 2 grinds I'm playing with (along with negative rake). For lack of a better description I'll call them blunt grind, sharp grind. My blunt grind scrapers have a grind that is about 75 degrees. The sharp grind at the present time is 45.

The difference seems to be 2 fold. How long the burr lasts and how much chatter you get. The burr doesn't last anytime at all on either but seems to last longer on the blunt grind. The sharp grind seems to cut cleaner but you have to form a new burr very often.

There is a difference in the burr depending on which diamond hone I use or if I come straight off the wheel. The hardness of the tool also affects the burr. I have a homemade scraper that was hardened to 62 rockwell and it almost has to be sharpened on the grinder. It holds a great edge. The other 2 tools are name brand and I have no idea how hard they are. They don't old burr very long but can be sharpened with the diamond hones and they cut very clean.

Negative rake scrapers are still a new thing for me. What it does is change how you orient the tool to the work. The bevel angles can still be the same, in other words my sharp grind is still 45 degrees it's just that the tool now looks like a skew laying on it's side. Instead of flat on top meeting at a 45 degree edge the top has been ground down about 5 or 10 degrees and I grind the bottom bevel so that the edge is still 45 degrees. It doesn't cut any better than my normal sharp grind but you can hold the handle higher to engage the burr. For beginners this might be safer because it's sometimes hard to get them to hold the handle higher than the cutting edge.

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#8

Leo Cuellar

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

Leo Cuellar

John, just tried this last night on a piece of curly spalted birch. My scraper has an angle of 82 degrees, didn't polish the bevel, just the top to 6000# on water stone. Was able to get rid of all but "micro" tear out. My technique has suffered due to not turning for the past several weeks, but this let me start sanding @ 150 grit.

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#9

Ken Vaughan

It is called a "flutless gouge"

Ken Vaughan

or a skewchgouge, and a few other similar tools

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

#10

Re: bevel rubbing a scraper

robo hippy

If it has a bevel, you can rub/ride it. The only time I do this with a scraper is an inside the bowl, across the bottom cut. The bevel is in the 75 degree range, the same as my bottom of the bowl gouge. The scraper has a swept back grind to the left, and the nose is more of a point, not rounded. The important thing is to cut with the nose. If I was to try this with a round nose scraper, I would be cutting above the center line of the tool, and would worry about getting overpowered and having it slam down on the tool rest. It cuts with with a grinder burr, or no burr. A burnished burr rolls over too much, and you can't rub the bevel.

As to burr durability, the burr from my grinder lasts as long as the cutting edges on my scrapers. A burnished burr is about the same. A honed burr is gone in an instant.

robo hippy