Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

bowl steady and deep hollowng system

Posts

bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#1

bowl steady and deep hollowng system

Jim Canning

It's that time of year again and my kids called today asking what I wanted from Santa this year. Well I normally grab a couple of supply house catalogs and give the kids a list of wood turning stuff that they can buy me.

But it's different this year because there are only two things that I need to complete my shop. I need or want a deep hollowing system with the laser attachment and a good bowl steady. I have thought of making them myself but I really think that I should leave that up to someone that knows what they are doing.(I have the Powermatic 3520A lathe) So I need to know who you think makes the best one of each? Thank you in advance for all of your information, Jim.

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

Lyle Jamieson

Jim, as you might expect I am biased. I think the answers you get at a forum like this will be so broad and varied that they will only confuse things. When you get conflicting information which one do you accept?? Many will promote home made systems. There is nothing wrong with home built systems, I have helped hundreds of turners build their own. But not everyone has the time or interest in making their own tools.

I highly suggest you use it before you buy one. Borrow one, if it is compatable with your lathe, or go over to a fellow club members shop and do a complete hollow form on their lathe. Your club members will have a wide variety of tool systems to choose from, my hollowing system included. Just ask and they will be glad to help you. You will soon see what hollowing system will do the job for your particular needs and interests.

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#3

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

Fred Holder

I have or had a number of deep hollowing systems: The Kelton System was the first, it was a good system but too heavy for me to set up, so I sold it. I have both the Mini-O and the Maxi-O systems. The Mini-O works well on small lathes like the Oneway 1018 that my wife has. the Maxi-O works pretty well, but I like the Jamieson system best. For small hollowings not needing a laser, the one from Vermec in Australia works very well. It does not have a laser pointer and it does not require a secondary tool rest, it fits into the tool rest banjo. This was the last system that I acquired. I saw it while in Australia and had to purchase it. Incidentally, I do very little work of the hollow form nature. The Chinese Ball is my specialty, but I've tested a lot of tools over the years.

The only bowl steady that I know of is the OneWay bowl steady. It work pretty well if the bowl is round and gives good support where the tool is cutting. I have seen photos of where people made up steady rests similar to spindle steadies with three or more wheels riding on the bowl. I have no idea how well these work.

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#4

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

Dick Wilson

Jim, The only hollowing system I have ever used is one that a friend of mine welded and machined. It is a knock-off of the Jamieson system, with laser light. It works great. The only thing about my system is I don't have all the attachment, etc. that you can get with the Jamieson system. There are a number of other systems out there and I know nothing about them. I recommend the Jamieson system.

PS - Come on, your not being very truthful when you say you only have two thing to buy to complete your shop. You would be the only person I have heard say that :-))))).

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#5

Steven Antonucci

Not an answer to your question, but questions:

steven antonucci

1.) When you say deep, how deep do you mean? The Powermatic can probably handle 30" or so...

2.) When you say hollow, how hollow do you mean? Are you looking for 1/4" or 1/32"?

3.) When you think of a hollowform, is it the full 20" wide that your Powermatic can handle or is it narrower?

4.) What sized opening do you envision? 2"? 1"? Or 1/4"?

If you can answer these, it should go a long way towards answering how you should evaluate the systems...

S

P.S. that you can make on your own :D

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#6

Re: Not an answer to your question, but questions:

Jim Canning

Dick- I guess I should have said only two things for right now, who knows what I'll see next month.

Steve - 1.Maybe 18-24" tall 2. I would be happy with 1/4" thick 3.Maybe 15-18" round. I would try to make my own but I don't know how to weld the parts together and that is probably a pretty important thing to do right.

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#7

Steven Antonucci

At that size, I doubt there is a commercial answer

steven antonucci

Most of the commercial rigs are not designed to handle pieces more than 12" deep or so. If you plan on undercutting that far, most hollowing systems also don't reach that far to the left. You'd have to pick your shapes carefully.

Most commercial systems want to fit in a 12x"12"x12" cube. If you want to go bigger, you'll want to make your own.

Steve

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#8

Lyle's big rig will.  I'll have to let him tell

john lucas

you how deep it will go but it has a really huge bar. I remember looking at it last year and thinking that it would easily go 15 to 20 inches deep but my memory isn't as good as it used to be and I can't remember the size of the tubing.

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#9

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

George Guadiane

I'm getting a Jeff Nicole steady ring for my Mustard monster.

I already have a Randy Privett "Monster" hollowing rig. He made a 3/4 inch bar to go with one of my Rolly Munro articulated hollowing tools. I have not used it much.

I am currently working on a 15+ inch diameter by 5 1/2 inches high Rosewood hollow form, using the standard 5/8 inch shaft Rolly hollowing tool. I have to say, it IS a little dicey at the extremities and I have had to set the cutter pretty far out from in line with the shaft in order to get to the tough spots, but I have been able to hollow to my satisfaction and need only finish hollowing the inside. SO, The Monster setup won't go as deep as you would like, but I've been over 10 inches deep so far. Again, a bit "exciting, but manageable.

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lyle's big rig will.  I'll have to let him tel

Lyle Jamieson

You are right-on John. My system will do any shape you want. It has three reach capabilities to undercut shoulders of any shape. The basic system will do up to 10-12 inches because it has a 3/4 dia boring bar. My jumbo bar attached to the basic system will get 15-17 inches off the tool rest...without vibration. The depth you go will depend on the diameter of the bar, wet wood, dry wood, porus grain, fine grain, experience and tool control to make light cuts. I never go past the vibration point, not safe.

My new Giant system is another stronger system that will go out 22-24 inches deep. When you go that deep the entire system needs to be beefed up to handle the stresses.

Its is nice to hear the friendly reporting about my tools, I have worked hard to make a system that works as easy as possible with the least restrictions and obstacles as possible.

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

#11

Re: bowl steady and deep hollowng system

Carole Valentine

I use the Kelton hollowing rig with laser and like it. Don't have any problem putting it on and off the lathe. It's my understanding that the Kelton Mark II system will take a 1 1/2" x 24" boring bar which in turn holds the 3/4" hollower. I don't have that setup because I don't turn anything that large, but considering the beefiness of the rig, I would think you could certainly do a vessel the size you are talking about and more.