Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

Posts

RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#1

RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

Joe Pack

I have read a few articles and watched several videos re: lathe tools using carbide tips that are replaced other than sharpened. The Easy Wood Tools line is the one I have read/watched the most on. I am curious as to the thoughts of people who have actual hands-on experience with these. Care to share thoughts as to comparisons with traditional tools, ease of use, etc.?

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#2

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

Jim Sebring

I've been using an EWT CI-1 since before the company was named, I think. It's the square-ended tool Craig first introduced. I use it mostly for initially rounding bowl blanks where the 'bounce' is the worst. It's a scraper at heart, so doesn't leave the smoothest finish on end grain. I do find this tool to be a lot more comfortable to use on initial roughing than any bowl gouge. I seldom use the full face of the cutter at once; I usually have only about 1/4 or less of the edge engaged in the wood. It's nice to be able to use the edge as well as the face at the same time where sharp corners are needed.

I also have the two round-cutter tools Craig offers. They work very well for some hollowing operations and for gentle removal of small amounts of material. I just squeeze my left fist to move the tool a very small distance. All of the EWT tools are tough hombres.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#3

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

Eduardo sarmiento

I made one with cutters from global tools and they can be sharpened with a diamond card,if you see the captain Eddie videos in youtube he shows there how to make some tools too,my 2cents

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#4

Steven Antonucci

$10 cutter on a $5 bar with a handle

steven antonucci

Whether they work or not is somewhat immaterial. The cost on these things is pure insanity for what they are. I've used a hacksaw and a file to make the bar, and it might be 10 minutes worth of work.

Youtube is your friend.

S

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#5

Re: $10 cutter on a $5 bar with a handle

john lucas

I agree Steve. You can buy the cutters for $2.50 apiece. There's very little machining involved. A few minutes with a hacksaw and file and you could make one. But, obviously it goes for what the market will bear. I guess the market needs more competition. There are 2 places selling them so far and may be more I don't know.

It is a good tool for the beginner. Extremely easy to use but beyond the price range of many beginners. With careful shopping you could buy 3 tools for the price of these and you would have much more versatility.

What would you say is the minimum # of tools needed to turn a bowl. I should say by a beginner. I turn bowl at some demos with nothing but a bowl gouge but some of the cuts can be a little tricky. I would say, bowl gouge, parting tool, flat scraper and round nose scraper. If you can do shear cuts with the bowl gouge you don't need the scrapers. The parting tool is just handy for shaping the tenon to fit the chuck jaws.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#6

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools? *LINK*

Wayne Kuhn

I bought one and was sorry at first use, esp. with a 13 dollar replacement cutter cost. However, i got the square edge replacements from global and am sold. This is my go-to tool to get all the junk off of a blank. Once round and balanced its back to my Trusty Thompson bowl gouge.


Global Tooling

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#7

Re: $10 cutter on a $5 bar with a handle

Bob Lalonde

I couldn't agree more but I'd throw in a skew to cut the dovetail on the tenon. Or you could grind a scraper with an angle to make the dovetail. B.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Can use, or best used?

steven antonucci

I can turn a bowl with only a bowl gouge, but I use either a skew or a detail gouge to get a good corner in the chuck tenon. I'm more likely to use the tool I have in hand than switch to another.

I think the $100+ prices are nuts and actually help people make more mistakes than they fix. The notion that you don't need to learn how to sharpen (and can't anyway) or worry about riding the bevel just means you can be sold, not that you've learned anything about turning.

S

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

Keith Tompkins

HI Joe,

I've seen and actually tried the EWT tools....a couple of weeks ago, a student brought a full set to the class. He raved about them, and used them throughout the two-day session. He asked me to try them out and give him my opinion. My first impression was that the tools were extremely well made; according to an article in the latest AAW mag., the maker is a machinist...and it shows. And, being a bit of a traditionalist, I tried to keep an open mind concerning their usefullness. I think they have a place: fitting the lid on an end-grain box, for example. The square tool left a very clean surface, and it was very easy to remove the finest amount of wood. They are also good for finishing the inside of boxes, leaving a clean bottom with no tear-out. The problem is, we all tend to turn the way we initially learned to turn, and may become resistant to try new things. The turner who relys on these tools has missed out on many of the facets of woodturning that make it such a great pastime...and sharpening is one of them. Another issue is that the tool, not the turner, can become the deciding factor in the end result....let's see, I need a cove cut here..my disc is 1/4" diameter. So, all my cove cuts work out to 1/4" or so, but NOT smaller. Not too much different than selecting the right router-bit profile for a flat-work job. The EWT tools are designed to be used FLAT and level. The turner doesn't develop the skill of rolling beads and shear cutting, while using his whole body to control the cut. Instead, the idea is to just stand there, pushing the tool straight in. I've always believed one has to pay their dues, and that includes a lot of practice, a lot of frustration, broken pieces, disappointment, and finally a bit of pride when someone refers to you as a craftsman. You have earned that title. Sure the carbide tools are easy....but should life always be easy?

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#10

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

Nelson

I love the EWT tools, and yes after 30 years of turning I know how to use a skew,rub a bevel and sharpen my tools.Since my main objective is the finished product ,I now like tools that do it quicker and better and the EWT tools fill that need. They are a joy to use.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#11

Ken Vaughan

Carbide is great for cripples

Ken Vaughan

Arthritis is slowly and steadily winning and I find myself on the stool more and more. All that use of the body stuff is great when the hips, knees, and ankles are still good, but as they fail, the carbide inserts let me get more done with upper body control and a tall stool.

The carbide insert tools do give me better choices these days. I still use gouges but with much more restraint and not for very long periods of time.

They do not replace my skews though --- just use smaller ones mostly.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#12

Steven Antonucci

"I just wanna make a bowl"

steven antonucci

I think that the folks marketing the various carbide tools are smart- they understand their audience. The audience is the casual turner who just wants a bowl and hasn't mastered their other tools. The perception is that making bowls is hard, and they need to make it "Easy" with a tool instead of practice.

If you practiced and mastered your basic tools, a bowl gouge does EVERYTHING better than a carbide tool, but to each his or her own.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#13

Re: Carbide is great for cripples

Don Thur

I have EWT cutters which I find invaluable; I am working with 2 root burls which means they are full of gravel, dirt and just about anything the root system picked up during its life. Carbide is about the only cutter that will handle this. This type of turning will take the edge off HSS very quickly, just as it dulls a chain saw. My only beef is the cost of the round cutters; I just paid $17. I can access the square cutters for $4.75; anyone know of a cheaper supplier for the round???

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#14

Re: "I just wanna make a bowl"

Nelson

As a full time turner I have mastered the tools and yes all and I want to do is turn a bowl and the carbide cutters do it faster.Some times it's hard to change but this is one time I'm glad I changed to a better way of doing things.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#15

Re: "I just wanna make a bowl"

Wayne Kuhn

Steve, I agree with you. However on the other hand catalogs, the internet and this forum are full of tools, tricks and tips that make turning spindles, bowls and hollow forms easier. It is the natural progression of a craft person/tradeperson.

If not for progress we would not be having this conversation, and we would be living in a shack in the woods with our spring pole lathes and the townspeople would still live in fear of the bodger that lives in the woods.

There are times as I look through the catalogs I wonder when they are going to start selling finished bowls, and all you have to do is put your name on it.

BTW- Flat woodworkers have been arguing about this forever, Normites vs. Neanderthals.

Wayne K

Columbia, MD

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Carbide is great for cripples

Keith Tompkins

HI Ken, I gasped when I read the title to your post... Wow! That's politically incorrect!!!!! :D I have arthritis symptoms as a result of Lyme disease, and that's a big problem. How will I be functioning in ten years? Hollowing KILLS...I hurt for days afterwards. I purchased a captured rig, which helps, but only if I actually use the thing.

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: "I just wanna make a bowl"

Keith Tompkins

Wayne, I think you are correct. Problems also present opportunity. A good example is how many turners are afraid of the skew. I've asked people in the front row to please move during a demo when I pick up the skew chisel...and most of them actually stand up and begin to select a new seat! I have to convince them I'm JUST KIDDING!!

So, if someone could figure out how to make a skew that doesn't have such a tedency to catch...

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#18

Steven Antonucci

Better for you perhaps, but...

steven antonucci

Without getting into a heated argument, I would like to bring two very simple FACTS to light: (feel free to independently validate via Wikipedia or elsewhere)

1.) Carbide does not get as sharp as HSS. It's a molecular thing, but generally speaking, a properly sharpened and honed gouge will outperform a carbide cutter for finishing cuts because it is sharper.

2.) While it is true that carbide WEARS longer, it is continually degrading in performance, the HSS edge can be perpetually renewed to optimal performance.

3.) All of the reading I have ever seen about carbide tools recommends using about 1/2 of the cutter while roughing out. I think they are roughly 3/4", so that means you are able to make a 3/8" pass. I can use a 5/8" bowl gouge with a ground back wing in shear to make passes that are 1"+ wide and clean across the end grain. If I had a bigger motor on my lathe, I could make a wide pass, but it stalls the belt if I try it now (so it's not the gouge or me).

I am glad that there are folks out there trying to make turning easier for the masses, but it's an aggregious overstatement to say that it is better or faster than conventional gouges.

YMMV.

Steve

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#19

Steven Antonucci

The best tool to make turning easier is practice.

steven antonucci

I am not opposed to new tools or things that make things easier at all. I am opposed to the cult-like following that promote carbide tools as better.

Carbide tools may be "better" if you aren't very good at sharpening, which is a common problem that I see all of the time as someone who teaches turning. My students almost never sharpen unless I tell them to go sharpen.

Carbide tools may be "better" if you aren't riding the bevel, since they don't rely on a bevel. It's not hard to believe that using a tool improperly will result in the cut being worse than using a different tool properly. I can't blame the tool for that.

I laugh everytime someone says to me "Oh, you are a natural", "You make it look so easy", and so forth. What they don't see if the 1000+ bowls I have cut. The hundreds of hollowforms. The 1000's of spindles.

Perhaps you are right, Wayne. The ultimate woodturning lathe will be a laser controller carbide cutter that can correct form issues and leave a perfect surface while the turner looks for a pen...

S

Re: RE: Easy Wood Tools and other carbide tools?

#20

Thanks!  A good discussion, don't you think?

Joe Pack