Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Dust Collector Reviews?

Posts

Dust Collector Reviews?

#1

Dust Collector Reviews?

Keith Inscho

I am in the process of adding a dust collector and in doing my homework have discovered an overwhelming pile of stuff on the subject. Is there anywhere I can get a fairly current review of small to mid-size collectors? Advice?

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#2

JL

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

JL

I am in the process of adding a dust collector and in doing my homework have discovered an overwhelming pile of stuff on the subject. Is there anywhere I can get a fairly current review of small to mid-size collectors? Advice?

Other than on-line? First, a couple of questions.

Are you going to be using the DC as a single collector or for a system?

If you are going to use it as a single collection point - you should be researching 1 to 1.5 hp dust collectors. IMO, the best ones are the canister types such as the Jet. If you want to go for a double bagger, you'll have to switch out the bags for something that will take out finer dust. I wouldn't get a single bagger - they don't work well with the more "restrictive" bags - good for saw dust, but not fine sanding dust (IMO).

If you are going to ducting a shop with a system - how large is your shop?

IMO, you need at LEAST 2 hp for a small system. Preferably more. I would hesitate to use a single canister DC for collecting the dust in a shop. IMO, you'd be better off with a cyclone or a double canister.

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#3

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

Bernie Weishapl

I bought the Harbour Freight DC and added a Wynn Enviromental filter. It is the 35 A and is .5 micron with a plastic bag on the bottom. I have it plumbed to 4 stations using blast gates and it does a pretty good job for a 110V unit since I don't have 220V in my shop.

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#4

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

Keith Inscho

My plan is to have my DC in a room outside, but directly adjacent to my lathe room. It will only be serving the lathe station and a floor sweep, with about a 12' single run from the DC to the lathe. I was also considering sealing the dc room and providing a return vent with a couple of furnace filters to retain some of the heat/cooling. Bandsaw and other shop stuff is in a separate building.

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#5

Re: Dust Collector Reviews? *LINK*

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Keith,

I have mine set up just like that. I bought mine several years ago. It is a Grizzly 1029. It is 220 and 2hp. I am not sure if they even make this one any more.

I switched out the top stock bag for one with that filtered a bit better. I also replaced the lower bag with a plastic bag.

I use it on the lathe and the bandsaw with blastgates to direct the flow where I need it. It works great for me.

I also bought a remote for it. It is a real time saver. It will work just fine right through the wall. It is really nice to have the dust collector in another room. Cuts down the noise to the point where the air sucking through the pipe at the lathe is almost louder that the dust collector.

This link is similar to the one I have.

Best wishes,

Dave


Grizzly

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#6

Re: Dust Collector Reviews? *LINK*

charlie belden

You won't find reviews of specific dust collector models on Bill's site. That's because, even though he had objective emperical data, collected using valid testing procedures and methods, to support his conclusions, he could not afford to pay lawyers to fight law suits threatened by several "dust collector" companies. What you will find is an explanation of what you need to protect your lungs. And that's not just the CFM of the dust collector - but also ducting as well.

If you go through what he's put together you'll have a pretty good understand what you need and why.


http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/index.cfm

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#7

Steven Antonucci

They're all the same: this thing sucks

steven antonucci

Sorry, couldn't resist...

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#8

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

robo hippy

You will want a two stage system, one with a cyclone, and filter. The cyclone will separate out anything but dust, which would otherwise run through the impeller/fan of your collector. Shavings will plug up the fan, and chunks can bend or break the fan blades. The pleated paper filters, which go down to 1 or .5 micron will eliminate the need to refilter the air before it goes back into the shop. Furnace filters are not that fine (3 to 5 micron I believe). I have an Oneida system and think it is the best one out there. They have systems down to 1 hp. If you are running just the lathe on it, a 1 hp system should do fine.

robo hippy

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#9

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

bill Crommett

I have a Grizzly system that I modified to take a 6 in. PVC input. It works great except that with the modification to allow the 6 in. intake there is so much pressure that the upper bag kept blowing off. This was particularly bad because the unit was down stairs in the outside paint locker and was not monitored every day. After the fourth time the bag blew off I re modified everything so now the sawdust blows directly outdoors with enough force that it doesn't build up to any great depth. This system does a good job of handling the sawdust from the planer, the jointer, the saw, the band-saw and the router table. The shop is still a mess.

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#10

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

Ron

I'd recommend not putting in the floor sweep, I just removed two of them I put in my shop last weekend. Trying to use it for lathe shavings will just plug up your runs (I know from experience), much easier to sweep and pick them up with a large dustpan. For other shop floor dust etc I found I just didn't use them.

FWIW I have a 3hp JDS cyclone in a garage just outside of my shop with 6-8 runs to various shop equipment, installed ~4yrs ago. I use it for dust on the lathe, not shavings. If I had to do it over again I'd go with the new model JDS cyclones, probably the 2hp since I never run more than 1-2 gates open.

Good luck.

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

#11

Re: Dust Collector Reviews?

Big Dave

I had a Delta 50-760 for about 6 years before I upgraded to a cyclone. I sold it to my neighbor, who uses it for his lathe(s).

While I haven't really kept up on recent dust collector reviews, the 50-760 used to run near the top of the list. It came standard with 1.5hp motor and a 1 micron bag filter.

I never had any problems with it, an wished I'd bought one years earlier!

DAve