Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Un discovered scratches

Posts

Un discovered scratches

#1

Un discovered scratches

bill Crommett

Yesterday I finished this massive 17 in. bowl made from a hard maple burl that has been sitting in a cabinet makers shop for thirty years. The tearout was terrible and I had to use a bunch of 60 grit to get through the tearout . I set it out on the deck to get some sun to polymerize the walnut oil and low and behold I found some unseen scratches. My question: What is the best way to get rid of the finish so I can sand out the scratches and start over ? The base has a nice flare to it so I can't fit it back on a chuck.

Re: Un discovered scratches

#2

Re: Un discovered scratches

HeatherAinAK

Mike Mahoney sometimes sand with walnut oil. Would that work?

Heather

Re: Un discovered scratches

#3

Re: Un discovered scratches

Fred Holder

I finish virtually all of my bowls with walnut oil. I often final sand with walnut oil on the wood (it is a bit hard on the sandpaper). I see no reason why you can't just put some fresh walnut oil on the wood and hand sand to get rid of the scratches. When all done, you can apply a new coat of walnut oil all over and when it dries, you can buff it, if you have a buffing system.

Re: Un discovered scratches

#4

Steven Antonucci

If it is localized...gooseneck scraper!

steven antonucci

Occassionally, I find that I missed a spot or there are some areas around the end grain that could use a little more care. Rather than resanding the whole bowl, I choose to use a freshly sharpened cabinet scraper. The gooseneck ones are perfect for the inside of a bowl. You feather out the area to be larger than the affected area, and you won't even see a divot...

S

Re: Un discovered scratches

#5

Re: Un discovered scratches

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

I just take my glasses off. :b A lot of times during a class or demo, I will make the comment that the older I get, the less I have to sand. Almost every time, someone asks, "Are you getting that good?" in hushed tones of reverent awe.

"No", I say. "My eyesight is getting worse!" :D

Seriously, if I find a few scratches, I usually wet sand like Fred says. I have never tried the cabinet scraper thing that Steve describes, but it might be worth investigating - if I see another scratch that is. ;)

Re: Un discovered scratches

#6

Re: Un discovered scratches

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hey Bill,

Can you post a pic? If it were me I would try to find a way to re-mount it. Sanding off the lathe is a real tough thing.

For such a big bowl there may be enough meat left to re-mount it.

If worst comes to worst, you will have some sore and tired fingers.

Also, one question, Why the walnut oil? It is one that I will never use again. It seems to never dry.

Happy Holidays,

Dave

Re: Un discovered scratches

#7

Cabinet scraper is great

john lucas

I've been using those for years. You can get rid of torn grain very rapidly and then feather out the divot so the low spot isn't noticeable. It doesn't leave high and low spots like sandpaper will. DO NOT DO THIS WITH THE LATHE RUNNING.

I get scratches in Maple that I cannot see until I get to the high grits. I put the light at severe angles. I dust between each grit and inspect it very carefully. Almost everytime when I get to 400 grit I will find at least one or two scratches. I don't know the solution other than possibly wiping it down with Naptha between grits. I think whats happening is dust gets in the scratch and hides it. Even though I'm wiping it down with a dust rag and sometimes blowing it out with the compressor. I don't seem to have that problem with other woods.

Re: Un discovered scratches

#8

Re: Un discovered scratches

dick gerard

During the sanding process, I will often stop, inspect with a low angle light. If I see scrathes, I tend to them before moving up in grits. But about every other grit, I flood the surface with mineral spirits. This highlights all the scratches, and the MS dries quickly - 10-15 minutes. Enough time for a quick break or to attend to other small projects, like sweeping the floor (see Clay, I can learn!).

Re: Un discovered scratches

#9

Steve Kubien

That's a great idea

Steve Kubien

Gezz, I never thought of that. Thanks Steve. I doubt I'll ever see any tearout but it's nice to know there is a solution, if it were to occur. :D

Re: Un discovered scratches

#10

Re: Un discovered scratches

bill Crommett

Dave: The reason I put the big thing out on the deck to get some sunshine is that according to the intelligence gathered on this forum it takes some UV to polymerize the walnut oil, because the last thing I want is a weeping bowl.

Does anyone have more to contribute on this issue ?

Re: Un discovered scratches

#11

Re: Un discovered scratches

bill Crommett

John: I tried the cabinet scraper in the early stages of trying to get rid of the tearout, but there was so much tearout that my arthritic thumbs would have put the finishing into next year, thus the 60 grit.

The biggest problem with the invisible scratches is the pattern of the burl was so imitative of scratches that I was overwhelmed. I am tempted to take Bill Gumbine's tactic of removing my glasses and showing the bowl only in poor light.

Re: Un discovered scratches

#12

Re: Un discovered scratches

bill Crommett

Sweep the floor ? Neatnick or craftsman ?

Re: Un discovered scratches

#13

Re: Un discovered scratches

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Bill, you've received lots of advice that should keep you busy for awhile. Getting rid of 60 grit scratches can be a bummer. You could remount it on the lathe with some sort of jam fit chuck. To go back to the beginning, have you tried to figure out why the the heavy tearout ocurred? Cutting against the grain is the usual reason. A lot of good shear scraping is a whole lot better than 60 grit sp.

Wally

Re: Un discovered scratches

#14

Re: Un discovered scratches

bill Crommett

Wally: On this piece everything was against the grain. I tried it all - resharpened and honed tools, scraping and shear scraping. Everything was still all against the grain. The most miserable chunk of wood I ever had on my lathe ! Being a burl that had dried out for thirty years was not the best project for a Christmas gift idea.

Re: Un discovered scratches

#15

Re: Un discovered scratches

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Yeah Bill, a chunk of wood like that can be very frustrating. You did well to not set it aside for another day.

Wally

Re: Un discovered scratches

#16

Steven Antonucci

I only show it to OTHER people

steven antonucci

I've never used it myself :b

S

Re: Un discovered scratches

#17

Re: Un discovered scratches

john lucas

I hate it when I get wood like that. I'm too stubborn to give up on it but it costs me huge amount of time and frustration. Still these usually sell well just not sure I truely get my money out of it.

Re: Un discovered scratches

#18

Re: Un discovered scratches

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Thanks Bill,

I had no luck at all with it. I may have had a bad batch. I may give it a go again sometime in the future.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Un discovered scratches

#19

Re: Un discovered scratches

bill Crommett

Wally: My good friend, Mickey took a piece of the trimming home to try out and he recommended that I put it in the burn pile. Being stubborn and wanting to see what beautiful figure would come out of the blank, I persisted. I WILL get a decent finish on this thing, but it will be next year. I thank everyone for the suggestions so freely offered.