Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Harmonious - Analogy To Music

Posts

Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#1

Harmonious - Analogy To Music

charlie belden

While lisitening to an NPR program on music, I was surprised to learn that a committee defined the frequency of the musical note "A" (don't ask me if that's Middle A, I know little of musical notation or rules) to be 440 cycles per second, and all other musical notes would be based on that somewhat arbitrary value. What this did was permit instrument makers of different instruments, primarily wind instruments, to produce standardized sounds regardless of which instrument it was to be produced by. It probably made composers happy as well, especially those who composed music for symphonies, since all the instruments they wanted playing an "A" would in fact all be playing a sound with the same frequency.

Another thing I learned while listening to the program was that there are two, three and four note cords which produce a pleasing sound - a Harmonious sound - and - that there are two, three and four note cords that produce an Unharmonious sound - a Discordant sound. The former typically are perceived as calming and pleasant sounds, while the latter are perceived as unpleasant, irritating sounds or sounds that make us anxious. Think of the screaching sounds in Hitchcock movies - Vertigo, The Birds, thye shower scene in Psycho. He used, in addition to images, sound - to manipulate our emotions.

Music has worked out not only the specs for musical sounds, but also which combinations work together to produce pleasant and harmonious sounds - and which ones don't.

So I'm wondering . . .

If music has worked out what works and what doesn't - are there similar constructs that could do the same for shapes and forms - and might the analogy to music help identify them? Music has developed a vocabulary to describe sound, timber, tone, overtones, frequencies, major and minor, sharp and flat. Are there analogous turning terms? If so, what are they and how are they defined?

Just wondering.

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

Keith Tompkins

Charlie, You've never been to one of my demo's, have you? I use music analogies all the time, in fact music and visual art have some interesting similarities....the big difference is which sense you use to appreciate. One form requires listening, the other, seeing. One can easily analyze a favorite song, just to see WHY it works..What key is it in, what is the time signature? What is the melody line and chord progression? What formula is being used, for example verse, chorus, verse, chorus, bridge, instrumental solo, verse, chorus...snappy ending. (?) A musician may "color" musical phrases with notes that don't fit neatly within the chosen key to add tension, and which in turn leads back to the tonic. A guitarist may improvise over a chord progression with a pentatonic blues scale, or a mixolydian scale, depending on the feeling he's trying to convey. As turners, we can do the same thing. We can create tension in a piece, we can create pleasing rythms and patterns, we can use color the enhance the appearance of our work, and we certainly can take advantage of known formulas, such as the rule of thirds, the golden mean, etc. The best music, and the best artwork somehow touch the viewer or listener, and are often based on life experiences. I did a demo where one of the people in attendence was a bass player...he sent me a Victor Wooten DVD to check out. Victor wrote the same words and phrases on the flip chart as I did in my turning demo! Pretty wierd, I must say.

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#3

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

J. Paul Fennell

Charlie,

You have touched upon a very interesting subject about expressiveness through music. A while back I created a Powerpoint Presentation on "expressiveness," specifically concerning how music and woodturning can sometimes come together, as in the case of woodturner Virginia Dotson as shown below. I'm not sure if the analogy you query can be described in straightforward terms, because of the expression of personal emotions involved in both the listening and making. But, in Virginia's case, it is a wonderful collaborative dialogue between her brother, a musician, and herself, a maker of art.


Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#4

Steven Antonucci

Sad to say, it's probably a math problem

steven antonucci

We can call art something else, but the truth is probably that art is nothing more than the science of the subconscious. We are all wired to nature subconsciously, and beauty is nothing more than tapping into what is already there. Ugly is a bug in the programming...

Now where did I put all of my old text books?

S

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#5

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music *LINK*

Michael Mocho

Hi Charlie,

Harmony and dissonance in music are easier to identify that the equivalent condition in the visual world, though some aspects of visual composition can be analyzed in order to broaden our awareness and understanding of them. For example- color theory, much like music theory, also deals with frequency (of light) and there are ways to discern contrasting / compatible colors.

Another visual component that turners are constantly dealing with- consciously or not- is proportion.

You may find this book interesting, as it addresses many of the ideas in your posting:

�The Power of Limits� by Gyorgy Doczi

I have found this book to be a fascinating and very analytical study of proportion in both nature and culture, and I suspect you may also find it interesting. While it may not provide any concise for �what works and what doesn�t�, there is certainly a greater awareness available for what tonality can be achieved by considering proportions in our work.

My feeling is that the creation of any great work tends is rooted in-among other things- informed intuition and awareness, and studies of nature tend to fuel that awareness. Music that we find pleasing has patterns that can be analyzed, but we certainly don�t have to know these patterns to enjoy them.

The 440 = �A� benchmark in music is a convenience, but it is a relatively recent development in the greater history of music, and certainly not essential to any child composing a tune spontaneously. Perhaps the same is true for anyone working at the lathe- having the definitions doesn�t necessarily give us pleasing work.


�The Power of Limits� by Gyorgy Doczi

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#6

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

john lucas

Charlie Having studied music and art during my various careers I think there is an analogy. For example when you study art they work with circles, lines and triangles to try and explain how our eyes travel through the painting and to try and explain why we like one over the other.

The Greek architects did the same thing, only they added math the the circles and lines.

These methods attempt to give a constant to form and shape the same way the 440 A does in music.

I think a bowl with a curve that doesn't flow well is the same as a discordant chord. I think my work leans toward a 7th chord. :)

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#7

Terms For Shapes & Forms

charlie belden

I started this message days ago and rewritten it multiple times trying to organize what I'm after and put that in as few words as possible - though brevity is not my forte. But here goes.

Until the form of woodturning which makes mainly non-functional objects

using a lathe and turning tools as the principle tools

- develops a vocabulary to describe the results in a way folks who are not

woodturners can understand, appreciate - and value

- it will never get where other crafts have gotten in terms of having a place

at the table in the art world and the resulting markets.

Music has developed a structure, with terms for much of what makes up that structure - a mental model of what makes up music and how it works - with a vocabulary for thinking about, and communicating about, music. A sound may be described over time as Attack (how fast it gets there), Sustain (how long it stays there) and Delay (how long it takes to leaves there - no longer audible) - that anyone can understand. Time is an important characteristic of music - so there are musical terms for various time based sounds.

In turning, there is an established vocabulary for types of cuts, types of tools, types of grinds. When it comes to the things that are turned - the results of the tools and the cuts and the grinds - spindle turning has words for just about every part of a profile imaginable - each with an agreed upon definition in words and an illustrated example - that one can understand and use as a turner - or appreciate as a non-turner.

There doesn't seem to many equivalents for "non between centers" pieces - especially for non functional objects. There's Plate, Platter, Bowl, Lidded Box, Finial, Foot, Neck, Lid, Hollow Form - very rudimentary terms. Hell, even these terms overlap. When does a Plate become a Bowl or a Bowl become a Hollow Form? What terms could be used to identify the pieces Malcom Tibbetts does, or Escoulen?

It's the non-functional pieces that are in the realm of the visual arts. The other Visual Arts have developed a vocabulary for the various mediums / styles / forms - water colors, oils, acrylics - washes and stipples, pointalism, cubism, surrealismm super realism. And with that vocabulary, the general public, or at least the potential market for the pieces - can be first educated and come to appreciate - and then buy - the pieces.

But the real value of developing a vocabulary for the medium and works done in that medium is that it makes communication between the makers and the owners/collectors easier. It's that short hand vocabulary that aids the dissemination of ideas and appreciation, for forms and parts of forms that could be valuable.

Some will say this is about Labels and Labeling and think of this as an attempt to constrain or limit things - to Pidgeon Hole people or things. I see labels as a means of educating, of facilitating the development of an appreciation of lathe based 3D visual art objects (objects who's value transcends function)

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Impossible task....

Jesper, Denmark

Music and sailing have very developed and very specialized vocabularies, which accurately and clearly describe specific functions and concepts. I suppose there is a similar language in medicin. The vocabulary is very specific and clear to the musician, sailor and doctor, but usually complete gobbledigook to the layman.

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

Keith Tompkins

Hey Charlie, I think the bottom line is any artwork, whether music, art, or craft, must make a connection with the customer. They may not understand, or even appreciate, the thought process behind a piece of art, but somehow it must make an emotional connection with the person who ultimately purchases the piece.

When I was a kid, my mom always had a flower garden. Even if you had no money, you could exchange seeds and cuttings with neighbors, and end up with a pretty decent garden. I remember the hollyhocks that grew in the back...the blossoms were translucent pinks, yellows, and reds. So, no big surprise when I spotted a large painting in a gallery with a galvanized bucket full of cut flowers along a picket fence lined with hollyhocks... damn, so many essentials that we needed..new appliances, bills to be paid off. Who needs a stupid painting anyway. My truck needs new tires and a radiator. Gotta' do the right thing.

Yep, you guessed it...radiator's still leakin' and the tires are shot. That painting sure looks good on my dining room wall. :)

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#10

Re: Impossible task....

charlie belden

Jesper:

Sails and sailing certainly have developed terms that work well within the sailing community. Thr Briitish Naval Admiralty had a term, with definition, for every part of every type of sailing vessel in the British fleet. And yes, to anyone outside that community , many of those terms seem like gobblydegook. But the terms all have definitions that anyone can learn and understand. That sailing vocabulary makes it possible to educate non sailors about sailing - and maybe share some of the buzz sailing can provide and and help them develop an appreciation of sailing.

Knowledge can lead to understanding. Understanding can lead to appreciation. Appreciation can lead to markets for turned objects - and a turning's value can transcend the value of its wood and utilitiarian function. And THAT may make it possible for turners, who turn to make a living, survive and prosper.

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#11

Leo Cuellar

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

Leo Cuellar

Hi Charlie.

An attempt to identify & quantify something is an admirable and necessary task. The dictionary is one of my favorite reads.

I do have to agree with Keith... it is at an emotional/instinctual level that I connect with any form of art. Not being able to read or play music does not lessen my appreciation of it. While I may, after the fact, be able to apply terminology to rationalize why I'm infatuated with a piece, it is the gut level reaction that has always given me the most satisfaction. Even though I'm sure that some people purchase artwork for its technical brilliance, I wouldn't be influenced by knowing something was patterned after a math problem. Anything that is created with a formula will always be formulaic, it may even appear to be pleasing, but it will lack soul. The true magic in art has always been the individual's expression. One person is capable of creating great beauty from a plain piece of maple, while another can turn the most stunning piece of burl into a fleamarket reject. Being able to discuss this phenomena with appropriate language will certainly add to our ability to critique & teach... I'm just not sure it will give that ever elusive extra $.

Leo

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#12

Re: Terms For Shapes & Forms

Jorge Casta�eda

Charlie,

Although I am a dictionary bug from way back and in different languages as well, there is no way for me to start putting words to something that to me initially and then confirmed by my clients, is a totally visual and gut experience. Why a lady comes and touches every piece on the table?,"they are begging me to touch them". Or why the young girl picks another and holds it to her chest? Why this gent makes a bee line through a crowd and picks this huge walnut platter and declares "this is mine" and many other examples, like the couple that cannot agree on which piece to buy and end up buying both.

I cannot really express in words what I can express on the lathe, bringing up a shape that pleases me is my way of "saying it", through my fingers and my eyes, a hand-eye coordination or is it an eye - hand? The result is, people glance at the pieces, some keep walking, but many others have to stop, look and touch and some have to take the pieces with them.

Is not a words thing.

Imagine we are trying to describe a shape and say: "it is kind of Tompinknesque", no, no, to me that is "Beldenesque"...

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#13

Getting A Place At The Table

charlie belden

While what causes a person to make a connection with a turning is probably intangible and undefineable, the potential connection can't be made if the person and the object never meet. That meeting and potential connection requires a venue in which it CAN occur.

One of the things a turning vocabulary MIGHT do is get woodturning a seat at The Table where those who provide the venue meet to plan shows and events meet and decide What Is In - and What Is Not In - and by "In" I don't mean art d'jour - what's HOT - today.

I got into making jewelry and quickly into lost wax cast jewelry because it was more sculptural and allowed me to "sketch" in 3D. Because I used the Additive Method - add wax where ever I wanted (and remove it easily) - I could quickly build an object (ring, pendant, ear ring, coke spoon, Death Head - I had a few Hells Angels customers) and a customer could see the piece - at actual size - before it was committed to gold or silver.

When shows came along, there was usually a Fine Arts Show - and a Crafts Show. Guess which show was on the best weekends, had the wine and cheese rather than beer and hot dogs, the most publicity and the most affluent attendees? Usually, the Craft Show was the weekend before the Fine Arts Show, and served to promote the Fine Arts Show the following weekend - the weekend that often had a parade or fireworks - and when the most revenue was generated.

Now to be clear, often both shows were Judged Shows and to participate in either, you had to send in slides or photos of examples of your work - and often your Price Range - and be accepted - or not. The few Fine Arts Shows I went to were typically limited to paintings, often not very good paintings, but paintings. But the quality of the pieces in the Craft Show were often quite high, with price points that reflected not only the cost of the materials (gold, silver, precious and semi-precious stones are far more expensive than paints and canvases) but the quality of the designs as well (and caused me to wonder how I qualified to participate ; ) ).

It's the Fine Arts exclusionary mind set that wood turners must overcome - to get acrossed that turning CAN BE scultpure AND painting, maybe even musical as well. Getting a seat at The Table with those who decide who gets into shows or events. To do that we need to speak basically the same language or a add to the existing language.

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#14

Leo Cuellar

Hadn't thought about that perspective...

Leo Cuellar

and you are absolutely right Charlie. It would seem that some sort of awareness campaign in highend publications would be of help.

Thanks for sharing the snippet about your experience with jewelry making, I will eventually cast some hardware for a few projects.

Leo

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#15

Renwick Discussion Panel on Wood Art ... *LINK*

charlie belden

createed primarily or initially - on the lathe

With a curator of the Renwick as moderator, Fleur Bresler, who donated 59 pieces of her collection to the Renwick, as the guest and a panel made up of Michelle Holzapfel, Mark Lindquist, and Norm Sartorius, an interesting discussion of wood art reveals that what I was getting at is already happening in terms of lathe created wood art gaining A Seat At The Art Table.

This panel discussion is an hour long - and touches on a lot of issues about wood art created or intitiated on the lathe.

The curator and moderator of the discussion asked a provocative quetsion - "When is wood art going to catch up with "Fine Art"?" - to which Michelle responding - "That's like asking when Jazz is going to catch up with Classical Music."


Video of the discussion

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#16

Re: Renwick Discussion Panel on Wood Art ...

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Link will not open for me Charlie,

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#17

Re: Renwick Discussion Panel on Wood Art ... *LINK*

charlie belden

Don't know why it doesn't work so try this one. Scroll down to

"Shop Talk" - A Revolution in Wood: The Bresler Collection


Smithsoninan Art Museum Videos on Vimeo

Re: Harmonious - Analogy To Music

#18

Re: Renwick Discussion Panel on Wood Art ...

Bill Clark

Thanks for posting the link Charlie. Really enjoyed the video. Next time I'm in DC I'm going to view the gallery. It was closed when I was there last time.