Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

SAFETY Warning!!

Posts

SAFETY Warning!!

#1

SAFETY Warning!!

Philip Duffy

OK, I am a sucker for new toys and today my PSI collet kit arrived from Amazon. Anxious to give it a try I drilled the appropriate hole in a test piece, seated it properly, tightened it up as best I could and brought up the tail stock. I then proceeded to make some cuts, coves and beads. Nearing the end of the exercise I let the shallow roughing gouge drift towards the headstock. BAAAMMM!! The collet exploded and pieces of the chuck section went flying into the walls. Fortunately I was not hurt by these "bullets" and the only real loss is the o-ring that holds the 4 sections together.

So back to the Instructions I go, looking for some cautionary tales, warning, or Something. NOTHING! They expect a whole lot of intuitive knowlege these days, guys and gals, so do not let the toys kill you!! At least now You are Warned! Philip

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

Keith Tompkins

Philip, glad you weren't hurt. Yes, you can get hurt, even killed on many pieces of woodworking equipment, even your lathe. Inside each cover of the AAW magazine is the statement...woodturning is inherently dangerous... That should be something we ALL should be aware of before ever starting up a lathe. Eye protection, appropriate clothing, mental state, lathe maintenance, speed settings, and skill level should always be considered before firing up a project on the lathe. I checked out the chuck in question on Amazon, it appears to be a compact unit with no protruding parts. Luckily, this wasn't a bigger 4-jaw chuck with improperly protruding jaws....the results could have been MUCH worse. I'm a bit concerned about your experience...Did you consider what could happen if you contacted the chuck with your gouge BEFORE it happened? Warning labels are not the answer; I don't know your skill level, but safety at the lathe is always the number one priority.

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#3

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

Philip Duffy

Hi Keith, I have been turning for nearly 20 years. However, this was my first use of the collet chuck. I even read the directions, made all recommended preps, and drilled the required hole in a nice piece of solid wood. So, the only thing that I can come up with is that the wood fractured outside the collet jaws. Now, all I have to do is fined a new O-ring.

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#4

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

john lucas

Phil I picked one up when they were on sale and I was ordering something else. I haven't used it yet. I'll try to remember to look at it again tonight and see what I think. Thanks for the heads up.

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

Keith Tompkins

Hi Philip, The main thing is you were't hurt. I'd like to take a close look at one of those chucks....to see what secures each section within the body. Not good to have flying parts.

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#6

Took it apart for a look

john lucas

The tapered screw on the right has a pin that engages the jaws. As you rotate the jaws the screw goes down pulling the taper into it expanding the jaws. As was mentioned the only thing holding the jaws together is the O ring. So apparently if the wood breaks and there is enough speed the jaws can break the O ring and go flying.

It looks like it's like using an expanding chuck. You need to make sure you have enough wood on the outside to keep from breaking.

Thanks for the warning.

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#7

sorry, meant to post the photo

john lucas


Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#8

Barb Siddiqui

Re: sorry, meant to post the photo

Barb Siddiqui

Thanks for posting that, John. So you have a small set of jaws being forced apart by the leverage of a tapered screw, against the questionable stability of a rubber O-ring? At high speeds. Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen.

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#9

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

Barry L Elder

"IF" I had one of those chucks, I think I would examine the O-ring with a magnifying glass to see if the O-ring had any cracks in it due to age. In auto tires it's called "weather checking" but the same thing happens in O-rings. DAMHIKT!

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#10

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

John Lucas

Barry The problem is only partly the O ring It doesn't actually keep anything from flying apart. I guess whoever designed that thing assume the wood would never break. I don't think anything short of kevlar would keep the jaws from flying apart. Of course Kevlar won't stretch so the chuck wouldn't work.

It could possibly be designed with lug wrench or X shaped central brace with screws that go through the jaws to keep them from expanding too far if the wood breaks. That would be pretty small and don't know if it would work.

As long as you keep the wood thick your safe. Otherwise when using this chuck I would do my very best to stay out of the line of fire.

Re: SAFETY Warning!!

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: sorry, meant to post the photo

Keith Tompkins

It appears that the chuck jaws are held in place by being inserted in a recess machined into the stock. All the rubber o-ring does is secure the jaws until they are tight. However, if you get the wood around the chuck too thin, or it cracks, you will have flying pieces everywhere...I can see why Philip was so upset. If this is the same chuck as posted by John, I'd be carefull too. 9 The Penn State chucks I saw on Amazon were different than what John posted)