Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Candlestick comments desired

Posts

Candlestick comments desired

#1

JL

Candlestick comments desired

JL


I'm thinking of making several pair of these. Before I start making more, I would like to have comments as to form, size and what not. This one is about 13" or so tall. The base is about 5 1/2" in diameter at the bottom. This one is sized for a 3/4" candle base - but the cup diameter is about 1 3/4". This started off as a project to make candlesticks for the altar at church.

Anyway - comments are welcome.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#2

Re: Candlestick comments desired

Bill Howatt

I think a picture that isn't so close would be helpful. Right now it looks like a floorlamp pole and its hard for me to put it into the actual perspective.

I think you need to put some more detail in the straight portion at the very bottom (this part will be very visible unlike the very top)and do a bit of curving or detail with the straight portion at the top. The base edge could use a bit more treatment I think.

I like the "middle" part of it a lot.

Bill

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#3

Re: Candlestick comments desired

John Lucas

Very nice and of course clean turning details. If it was me I would change the dimensions of the 3 main elements below the top. You might shorten the top and bottom element and extend the length of the middle element so the line between the 2 top elements falls more on the Golden Mean.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Candlestick comments desired

Keith Tompkins

Hi JL,

My first impression is that it too closely resembles a Windsor chair leg. My thought would be to enlarge the base a bit, and reduce its bulk, shaping it to draw the eye upward to the candlestick. Perhaps you cold consider removing a good portion of the top section,which would balance out the proportions a bit. The cup overpowers the candlestick, it could be reduced in size, perhaps a flared lip would add a nice touch. The overall look is "heavy", reducing the diameter just below the cup would give a light, delicate appearance. The variation between diameters would add visual interest. When I come across a design problem, I find a few sketches always help.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#5

JL

Re: Candlestick comments desired

JL

Thanks for the response, Keith.

Of course it resembles a Windsor leg :D - I make Windsor chairs.

So more of a "flare" towards the base and lighten up the top elements. I have promised a couple for the altar at the church. Those need to be heavier duty (liquid wax candles with fat bases) - but I will lighten and have a "reduced flare" for the cup. I always sketch first - but then I make prototypes. I hate to think of how many leg trials I've made - but they do make good firewood.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#6

JL

Thanks

JL

I'll give that a shot - but incorporate Keith's suggestions also.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#7

JL

Thanks

JL

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#8

Ellis Walentine

Safety concerns worth noting

Ellis Walentine

JL, regardless of how you handle the shapes, I would strongly suggest getting brass (or some other metal) cups to put in the candle hole at the top. I've had wooden candlesticks catch on fire when the candle burned down to the end. Don't figure that'll never happen.

I think they make caps that look like thimbles and also ones that look like little upside down cowboy hats. If you want to get really fancy, get some catlinite (Indian pipe stone) and line the receptacle with that. It drills and turns very nicely and will insulate the wood from the heat somewhat, too.

Ellis

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#9

JL

Point taken, thanks for the idea.

JL

I can get some brass and/or copper. I could even turn them.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#10

Ellis Walentine

Or spin them  *LINK*

Ellis Walentine


Metal spinning

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#11

Re: Or spin them

John Lucas

Ellis is right. Metal spinning is the way to go. Takes a little learning curve. I have been planning to do it for the last few years and have started to make the tools and tool rests but other things seem to get in the way.

I used to make T lights and the possible fire thing became an issue. I use the candles that come in a metal cup. I burned 6 of them down to nothing in very dry wood and didn't have any fire problems at all so I quit worrying about it with those. However if I was using a candle that would burn down to nothing I would definitely suggest a metal cup of some kind.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#12

Re: Candlestick comments desired *LINK*

HeatherAinAK

I like the shape of the ones Eli Avisera makes. There is a picture on the link below. Look at the bottom of the page.

Heather


Eli Avisera candlesticks

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Candlestick comments desired

Keith Tompkins

Hi Heather...The yellow one? I agree.

Re: Candlestick comments desired

#14

JL

Mucho thanks, I'll try that one.

JL