Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

What & How Done. Why Turn It?

Posts

What & How Done. Why Turn It?

#1

What & How Done.  Why Turn It?

charlie belden

Michaelangelo's The David shows David at the moment he KNEW he could and would slay Goliath. The actual slaying was a foregone conclusion - which proved to be absolutely correct.

Gary Knocks (intentional misspelling) Bennett submitted a cube of walnut with a penciled circle centered on each face to a "Sphere" contest - and won.

In both cases, once the idea was worked out in sufficient detail, the rest was basically grunt work - assuming one has the knowledge, skills and abilities required to do the grunt work.

There are folks who have incredibly turning knowledge, skills and abilities who can duplicate almost any turned piece they have seen - but are unable to come up with a design idea on their own.

And there are folks who have all sorts of wonderful and original ideas for pieces - but lack the knowledge, skills and abilities to actually make the piece or make it well.

So here are my question:

Do you prefer to basically make really good copies of other folks designs you seen?

or

Do you prefer to do your own ideas reasonably well?

I've got this idea for a piece and I've worked out the details enough to be able to make it. I've done "horned" two intersecting arcs boxes and successfully laser engraved a low relief carving on their faces. I've done "trumpet" finials and flattened the upper "trumpet" end. And I've done "inset" finials on box lids. So I know HOW to make the piece. I have the tools and skills to DO it and I have done the design for the piece - and even have the wood the design was created to use.

Could YOU stop at this point, satisfied with coming up with the concept, the design details and the HOW,

or would you HAVE to make the piece?

Here's the example of my frequent quandry.


Feel free to use the idea. If you do, please post a picture - and anything you found that's missing in the illustration and description of the process.

Re: What & How Done. Why Turn It?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Sort of Existential BS on value

steven antonucci

Charlie-

I have a theoretical idea for a 200mpg car and time travel. Do either of these things have any value if I don't make them?

A drawing with dismissive laguage ('I know how to do that...") is nothing really. I know how to dunk a basketball in theory, but saying I can do it without ever doing it isn't realy productive. Believe me, know how to do something and doing it ar two different things.

Does this idea have any value? I suppose, but it is far less than if you actually act upon it.

The idea that GNB put out with his "preturned wooden object" wasn't necessarily as simple as you suggest. I think it's a riddle. Keith Tompkins demonstrates turning a cube on the lathe, and so the question becomes more along the lines of perception. Is this a lathe made object? Or is he suggesting that it could be, but wasn't?

Your idea will have significantly more meaning if you make it than if you don't. You may discover that you don't know everything you need to know. You may also journey down a different path as you get into it.

The formula is easy to understand, but complex in it's nature:

value=journey+experience+idea+execution

If you zero out any of the variables, you lower the value.

Steven

Re: What & How Done. Why Turn It?

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: What & How Done.  Why Turn It?

Leo Cuellar

Hi Charlie.

I'm thinking that the real question is: Do you love what you do?

I've designed a lot of stuff that I have not/would not build. Other people might actually like these designs or have the skills to make them. Some of them are only exercises to help build my skill set. I have a long way to go before I'm even adequate at this craft. Part of the fun of an item for me is that it also challenges my mind (some days that's pretty easy;). Part of the design is finding an appropriate material to make the item from, but sometimes that can be turned into a pun. Some things that can be done should not be: plastic flowers?

I do not like to copy other peoples work, but all of life is just a variation on what has already come before. That said there are some period pieces that I want to explore in the future. No one lives in a vacuum, but do we know definitively where some of those great designs really came from? Paying homage to the great among us, past and present, is, I think good and inevitable. We still however have people trying to take credit for the wheel.

Would I make that piece if it were mine? Only if I loved it, or thought that someone else would. .02� Leo

Re: What & How Done. Why Turn It?

#4

Re: Sort of Existential BS on value

charlie belden

I don't think your response is existential or BS. I asked if you could stop at coming up with a design and working out how it could be turned - and you answered the question and gave your reasons why you couldn't. You want the whole experience - from conception through to the completed piece - and even provided an equation for your turning value system. Pretty thorough and thought out response. Gave me several things to think about.

Re: What & How Done. Why Turn It?

#5

Steven Antonucci

Tongue firmly in cheek, Charlie...

steven antonucci

I meant that in our world, "ideas" were almost meaningless unless they were acted upon. We can dream up all kinds of crazy things, but most of the value is the execution of the idea and the process of making it. If it's too easy or too poorly made, a good idea suffers.

However, if all we do is draw, then are we really woodturners? This artform requires both sides of the brain, a little bit of science, some mathematics, and a whole bunch of marketing. You have to be a "five tool player" or you get shoved down to Triple A ball...

S