Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

thin parting tool question...

Posts

thin parting tool question...

#1

thin parting tool question...

GaryG in MD

Some thin (1/16") parting tools come shaped simply with a sharp point at the very bottom (between the end bevel and line of the bottom), while others (like the so-called "Firmager" come with a small relief bevel just above the line of the bottom and just below the cutting point. I'd like to know which is better and why. Or is it not a matter of "better", but rather different applications? ...Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: thin parting tool question...

Mike Stafford

I don't know why the Firmager tool is designed as it is except that it provides a little more bevel on the bottom for the tool to ride upon as you make the cut.

I use several different thin parting tools depending on what I am trying to do. I have one which has no bottom bevel and I have one that has a little bottom bevel of about 1/16". I use the one with no bevel for parting blanks in two and the other I for end grain detail work such as creating beads etc.

Re: thin parting tool question...

#3

Re: thin parting tool question...

Bill Howatt

The Firmager can be used for more than just parting. According to the LV description it can be used for shear scraping and making small coves. I have one and have long since ground away the fluted portion and use it only as a thin parting tool.

BTW, I consider a thin parting tool to be one of the most useful tools - if it is sharp you can do very clean cutting with it compared to the wider parting tools.

Bill

Re: thin parting tool question...

#4

Thanks Mike...

GaryG in MD

That's an interesting observation. The one with no bottom bevel is certainly a scraper. Perhaps the "Firmager" type can be considered a cross between a scraper and a cutting tool (if there is such a thing).

I bought a new one to make super thin (much less than 1/16"), � la Hans Wei�flog, and I got to thinking about whether to add the little extra bevel or not. I guess I'll leave it "as is". I've had good success with my "normal" one, but I'm interested to know how the bevel would affect parting. I guess I'll have to buy yet another one to find out! (More tools!!)

Thanks, Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#5

Thanks Bill...

GaryG in MD

I agree. I think it's an underrated tool. I love mine -- and it's so easy to sharpen -- just zap the two sides quickly on a diamond hone, and you're ready to go. I've always been curious if the extra bevel would make it better or worse. That's why I asked the question. Maybe somebody has some additional experience... ...Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#6

Re: thin parting tool question...

john lucas

Gary Here's why I grind mine like the Firminger. I grind the tip of mine so the cutting tip is about the same height from my tool rest as my spindle gouge tip. This means I don't have to move the tool rest to get the same basic cutting angle.

You'll also notice the Firminger cutting angle is blunter than the other one in the packard catalog on the same page. I suppose that could mean the sharper one would cut cleaner but then mine seems to cut very well and it has an angle similar to the Firminger.

Re: thin parting tool question...

#7

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: thin parting tool question...

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Gary, there is a very good practical reason to have a small relief bevel. You will want to round over the bottom edge of the tool a bit to avoid scratching your tool rest and even if you do not do it purposefully, the edge will get rounded over eventually from rubbing on the tool rest. The relief bevel, even if very small, assures a flat bottom to the grind profile. Dennis

Re: thin parting tool question...

#8

Thanks John...

GaryG in MD

Well, that's a very practical reason. I hadn't thought of that. (I should have expected that from the Energizer Bunny!) ;-) Thinking in purely practical terms, I guess the Firmager style would be able to work farther off the tool rest because the cutting tip is supported with more metal. I hadn't thought of that before now either. In terms of cutting wood (which was actually the reason for my question), the burr will be at a different angle (as long as a burr is present, which probably is only a few seconds). Which burr would be more effective if the tool is held relatively horizontally? (Of course sometimes I use it angled upward, and that would present the burr at an angle like the Firmager-style held flat. So many variables... ...Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#9

Thanks Dennis...

GaryG in MD

Very interesting answer. What you say is certainly true. In my case, however, I never touch a grinder -- all my sharpening is done by honing on a diamond card, so the tool remains forever virtually the same length. So I can round the bottom edge over where it touches the tool rest and not affect the cutting tip shape. But for anyone who uses a grinder (Which I would not recommend), that's a valid point. Thanks, Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#10

Melvyn uses it... *LINK*

Craig Daymon

...for creating the thin wings/rings/disks on his turnings. Not certain what the advantage is, but it helps him create those in wet wood, which then later warp. I found a page below from a demo he did that describes his tools and his turnings to a reasonable degree. Here is his official site as well.

http://www.melvynfirmager.co.uk/

Unless you're specifically interested in using it to create a similar turning, I suspect a regular 1/16" parting tool will prove fine. They're easy enough to make from planer blades, though I usually get them from Penn State Industries for about $10 each. Cheap enough.

-Craig


Firmager Demo 2007 - Channel Island Turners

Re: thin parting tool question...

#11

Thanks Craig...

GaryG in MD

I appreciate the links and will check them both out -- I certainly like his work!

Since he uses this tool for things like that (some of it pretty far off the tool rest), I suspect that the additional stiffness of his shape may be an advantage. I guess I should ask him...

Yes, I get mine from PSI too. Can't beat the price. ...Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#12

whoa!

GaryG in MD

That demo link is loaded with interesting info. I reco it for everyone to read. ...Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#13

Re: thin parting tool question...

Jerry Klug

I purchased an additional thin parting tools from Penn State after a Stephen Hatcher class. Stephen grinds the thickness to allow very thin grooves to be filled with stone dust on his platters. They cut very narrow grooves with a clean edge.

Re: thin parting tool question...

#14

Thanks Jerry...

GaryG in MD

That's a good application. I can see it.

I got my extra PSI thin parting tool for a similar reason -- to try to duplicate the cut Hans Wei�flog uses to separate the Saturn ring from the box body. I have a special "point" tool from Paul Fennell (for making foot rings) that might work, but to get enough depth, the outer part of the cut might end up being a little on the wide side.

I still don't know if there's a good reason to add the lower bevel or not. The ideas presented here have been interesting, but I haven't heard anything definitive or conclusive for my direct needs. Per the demo info in Craig's link, the Firmager tool is unique -- it fulfills several additional functions, so the shape does not necessarily convey to a pure, thin parting tool. I guess there's only one way to find out -- buy another one and modify it and compare results. ...Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#15

Steven Antonucci

grind an old butter knife

steven antonucci

cost you almost nothing to figure out if you need to spend $$$ on either...

S

Re: thin parting tool question...

#16

Re: grind an old butter knife

GaryG in MD

Yes, I've used old screwdrivers too. The question is the shape tradeoff between having the cutting point at the bottom or on top of a "bevel". ...Gary

Re: thin parting tool question...

#17

Steven Antonucci

hence my recommendation

steven antonucci

why take anyone's "advice' when you can quickl, cheaply, and easily figure out the answer by yourself? Grind it one way, try it, and then grind it the other way. Should take 15 minutes.

S

Re: thin parting tool question...

#18

good point!   (pun intended)...

GaryG in MD