Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Question: cutting against the grain

Posts

Question: cutting against the grain

#1

karl jr

Question: cutting against the grain

karl jr

In the past while turning natural edge bowls I've been cutting against the grain on the outside from the rim down about an inch. This is to avoid knocking the bark of at the points where it is not really supported by anything but more bark, and avoid tearing the cambium. Shear cut (handle so low I was holding the ferrule) and a sharp Thompson 5⁄8 V-gouge. Yesterday I did a few out of cherry, but this time I did the entire outside against the grain. It worked great. Not only did the bark stay intact, but I got no tearout and no little steps where the cut changed directions, i.e. against the grain and then with the grain. An additional plus was that the ogee I did was very nice and fair, with no corners or flat spots.

Admittedly, the cut felt different. Sorry, I can't really explain how it felt different, it just did.

I suppose it worked as well as it did because cherry is relatively tight grained. Which leads to my question. What woods lend themselves to cutting against the grain? Am I right when I say (read guess here) that it is a function of open grain versus tight grain? I suppose, to a dendrologist this would be the difference between ring porous and ring diffuse.

9 down and 13 to go

KTK

Re: Question: cutting against the grain

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Question: cutting against the grain

Keith Tompkins

HI Karl, that cut is something I do all the time. If the wood won't cut cleanly one direction, try the other. Walnut, especially, has worked out well for me that way. Sharp tool, shearing cut, don't force the cut..

Re: Question: cutting against the grain

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Question: cutting against the grain

Lyle Jamieson

Great subject!! I dont think people take grain issues seriously enough. I prefer to always go with supported fibers cause I dont like to sand. Sure it will cut the wrong way but with delicate sheer scraping downhill the bark will stay on just fine and you dont have to sand so much. And on natural edge pieces that means hand sanding off the lathe. If you look at my Hollow Forms DVD you will see that back then when it was produced I was sheer scraping the wrong way on the outside of the hollow form. Thats the way I was taught. I have made grain a much higher priority now since I tested the cuts going both ways. Porous grained wood will accentuate the problems for sure.

Re: Question: cutting against the grain

#4

Steven Antonucci

Teaching this-

steven antonucci

It's one of the first things I teach in my beginner's intro to turning class. There are very few "hard rules" in turning, but I will always cut downhill when I can, and only cut uphill when I must. I resharpen before I do it, and work the minimum amount of material in the wrong direction.

The main issue it creates for me is that I end up with two different surface qualities. Wrong way may be 120 grit if I do a good job, but the other way is probably 220 or better, so I end up having to sand back the better cut area to get to one surface quality.

My students are always amazed that I can tell when they have cut in the wrong direction. In the end, I suppose you can always sand it out, but I have enough to do. I don't make a lot of NE bowls, but along the rim is one area that cutting "backwards" makes sense...

Steve

P.S. slow your lathe down a bit and try a skew...on some practice wood!

Re: Question: cutting against the grain

#5

karl jr

Re: Teaching this-

karl jr

Aside from safety issues, I wonder if there are really any "rules" in turning. If it works, it works. If I make a cut with the grain that results in a less than satisfactory surface, but a cut going against the grain leaves a nice surface, where does that leave me? I've done something against the "rule" where following that "rule" leads to a bad result. Perhaps if my skills were greater I wouldn't be having this particular difficulty.

Maybe the word "rule" is a misnomer. I know it is accepted terminology, but maybe "guideline" is a more suitable word.

As far as your suggestion to slow the lathe down and try a skew on some practice wood... for me it's basically all practice wood. And when I use a skew on larger diameter pieces I get nothing but grief. A very embarrassing moment for me was when I sent a box across the room during a Mike Stafford hands-on class because of a catch when I using a skew on some squirrely grain.

Didn't turn yesterday so the count is still

9 down and 13 to go.

KTK

Re: Question: cutting against the grain

#6

Steven Antonucci

Guidelines vs. rules...

steven antonucci

In my book, the rules are only a few.

1.) cutting down hill with the grain

2.) sharp tools

3.) large diameter to small

4.) bevel rubbing

5.) cutting when possible, shear scraping when not, scraping when all else fails

If you do these things, everything else is up for grabs as a guideline. If you choose to use ignore them, you likely get to resolve the issues that ignoring them creates.

Once you know the rules...you get to break them! :)

S