Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Food friendly finish

Posts

Food friendly finish

#1

Food friendly finish

Joe Dickason

Since I mostly turn bowls for decorative purposes, I am being asked if one could put food in them. In the past I mostly used polyurethane finishes by Minwax. Recently I have changed to Watco Danish oil and buffing using the Beal type system, finishing with the carnuba wax. My thoughts are that dry "stuff" such as popcorn, pretzels, candies,etc would be O.K. Your thoughts?

Re: Food friendly finish

#2

Re: Food friendly finish

Carole Valentine

They will be fine. Almost all finishes are "food safe" after they dry. In my mind, utility bowls, ones that are meant to be used, should over time actually LOOK like they are used. It gives them character and a bit of history. I don't baby my utility bowls...I put most anything in them from popcorn to salad to cereal with milk! One day they will have the character of a couple of old bowls that I got from my grandmother that have were used on a daily basis. And FWIW, sometimes, if they are made from a dense, less porous wood,I even leave them natural with no finish at all.

Re: Food friendly finish

#3

Re: Food friendly finish

Cyril Griesbach

Joe, I believe that it's generally accepted that any finish, once it's fully cured, is food safe. My test for being fully cured is when one can no longer smell any finish on the object. Certainly mineral oil is food safe as it's also consumable but it's a non hardening finish and, like most finishes on a bowl that is being used regularly, it needs to be refreshed as needed.

Re: Food friendly finish

#4

not just food friendly but............

Ruth Niles

I'm also concerned about how the finish will look if the bowl is used a lot. Will Carnuba wax spot or get hazy?

I only use oil and buffing or rubbing with no wax because I tell the customer the bowl will only get softer and smoother to the feel with a LOT of use. Some people might not use it for fear of not knowing what to do if that beautiful "point of sale" finish spots or hazes.

Then again, I love the old bread bowls, wooden spoons and spatulas from my Grandmother's kitchen. They were toally used, abused and loved. : )

Re: Food friendly finish

#5

Re: Food friendly finish

George scott

Joe,

I am not an expert by any means but....

My little turning group uses mineral oil, mixed with beeswax and a touch of lemon oil. It works great. Get the mineral oil at your local pharmacy, beeswax ???? (depends on where you live) and lemon oil we get at WoodCraft.

I experimented with the proportions until I got the consistency I wanted. It doesn't take much lemon oil and that seems to keep the mixture soft. I use the microwave, some use the stove top. I also apply this to end grain cutting boards I make...again...it works wonderfully. One of our group has a formula for his but I don't remember it since I just experimented.

Re: Food friendly finish

#6

Re: Food friendly finish

Bernie Weishapl

I use Mahoney's walnut oil. I spoke with Ernie Conover a couple of years ago and he got me to use some Minwax Antique Oil on some utility pieces. At that time he said that was all he used because Behlen's or General Finishes Salad bowl finish would turn gummy after a couple of years or so. I also agree with Cyril that I use smell to tell me if it is cured when you can't smell the finish.

Re: Food friendly finish

#7

Ken Vaughan

Food friendly finish

Ken Vaughan

Crititical is to advise that hand washi (not the dishwasher) is the key to durability.

I use "natural" kiwi shoe polish/wax as the recommended finish for those who like a shine on the bowl. Buffs right up with a soft cloth and works wonders for the not-wet uses. Easy to find and easy to use.

Brown and back work well also but have the color effect -- Was it Russ's pages where I saw Black Kiwi on an ash bowl???

Tried and True polymerized linseed oil is a personal favorite because it wet sands so nicely, but we all develop our favored techniques.

Decades ago, heavy metals were used in finishes, but not for the last few decades. No odor, no problem (unless you have a really really ancient container of finish).

Re: Food friendly finish

#8

George- mineral oil is a lot less.....

JamieDonaldson

..expensive if you buy it by the gallon from your local veterinarian!

Re: Food friendly finish

#9

Beeswax:  Just follow a bee (or a Bee Keeper)

Al Kapocius

Re: Food friendly finish

#10

Steve Kubien

I'm with Bernie

Steve Kubien

I use Mahoney's Walnut Oil on all of my utility pieces and most of my work is meant to be used. Once it has cured I buff it with the red and white Beall stuff. It comes to a soft glow which I really like and my customers seem to as well. In the past I used General Finishes Salad Bowl stuff but I just don't like the shine. It looks like h*ll after a while.

Re: Food friendly finish

#11

Re: Food friendly finish

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

This topic just won't go away. Once again, I will post an article I wrote on this subject a year or so ago.

Woodturners often face this question -- Is this wood, or wood finish, food safe?

The answer is almost certainly yes. And remember that food safe is different from food friendly � a few drops of linseed oil or turpentine won�t harm you, but the flavor of your food may suffer.

In fact, the solvents and wood dust inhaled in the average shop constitute a vastly greater health hazard than any wood or wood finish that might be ingested by placing food in contact with a finished wood item.

In a previous life, I was a pharmacologist/toxicologist who spent a lot of time evaluating the toxic potential of drugs and other substances foreign to the body. It is important to know that most foreign chemicals are quickly removed from the body, typically by some biotransformation in the liver, followed by elimination in the urine.

Dose is a critical factor. As Paracelsus (circa 1530) stated: All things are poisonous, for there is nothing without poisonous qualities; it is only the dose which makes a substance a poison. Cherry wood and apricot pits contain cyanide, one of the most toxic chemicals found in nature, but the amount of cyanide is too small to produce problems under most circumstances. On the other hand, drink enough water, and it will kill you.

Let�s take an extreme case. Rather than ingest a tiny amount of shellac with each bowl of cereal, we could swallow the amount of shellac covering a wooden bowl in one gulp. What would happen? Not much. Shellac is a resin secreted by an insect, the lac bug. And you won�t be consuming all the shellac at once, probably not even over many years. A similar situation exists for most other common finishing chemicals.

Most ingested oils and waxes are not absorbed by the body to an appreciable extent; in fact, long chain hydrocarbons (mineral oil, etc.) are used as lubricant laxatives because they pass right through the gastrointestinal tract.

How did all this concern about containers being food safe get started? Remember I said most foreign chemicals are quickly eliminated from the body. Well, there are a few exceptions and heavy metals constitute a major exception. Lead, for example, accumulates in the body when ingested over a period of time. And, it does not take a lot of lead to produce serious toxicity to the brain, heart, kidney, and just about every other critical organ in the body.

About 50 years ago there were a rash of toxicities reported in people using unglazed lead-containing pottery from Mexico. Daily consumption of acidic beverages (orange juice, etc.), which leeched lead from the pottery, and over a period of years, resulted in irreversible and serious neurotoxicities, including developmental disorders, seizures, coma, even death.

If you want to worry about food safety � think about the last person who used your fork at your favorite restaurant. Did they have hepatitis? Was the tableware really sterilized in the dishwasher? Did the kitchen guy making the cold salads have E. coli smeared all over his hands? There is a lot to worry about relative to food safety, but a few micrograms of polyurethane in your cereal is not one of them.

A postscript for the professional woodturner. If you are trying to sell �food safe� products, you have to respect what customers believe, even knowing that they are wrong.

Some people are so caught up in the green, organic, and natural world that they are totally opposed to any commercial �chemicals.� Therefore, you may be forced to use mineral oil, beeswax, walnut oil, and other perceived �natural� finishes to make a sale.

Re: Food friendly finish

#12

Re: Food friendly finish

George scott

This is certainly not my thread but...Thanks for the lead Jamie...I would never have thought of the vet as a source of mineral oil. And Emmett...yes this is an ongoing topic of interest to turners. I have long known what you said in your interesting reply....but I like mineral oil and beeswax because it leaves a more...well....pleasing finish on the product (just my opinion you understand) as I am much more interested in utilitarian "turnings" as opposed to the artistic product.

Hope to see you all in St. Paul at this years AAW symposium. I am this year's Coordinator of Volunteers and will be around trying to recruit all of you.

George

Re: Food friendly finish

#13

Re: Food friendly finish

Barry Irby

I agree with everything Emmett said.

They use shellac to coat candy to make it glossy. Its edible. Some are coated with carnauba for the same reason.

Mahoney's walnut oil has been treated to prevent injuries to people that have walnut allergies. But It might strike fear in the heart of those with a walnut allergy. They might not be dieing to find out if it really is safe.

Russ suggested Sunflower oil. I buy a quart at Kroger for about $4.00. It has essentially no odor and no one is allergic to sunflower oil. You could add bee's wax if you wanted it to be a little thicker.

If you are selling user bowls do not put any finish that has an odor. If it smells like finish, they won't sell, no matter how safe they are.

Re: Food friendly finish

#14

Re: Food friendly finish

Joe Dickason

"Wow". This site continues to amaze me. What a wonderful source of talent & knowledge. I appreciate everyone's willingness to share. Thanks so much!

Re: Food friendly finish

#15

Steven Antonucci

Mineral oil and beeswax once

steven antonucci

replenish the mineral oil as you think necessary...

Over time, I think that the Beeswax in my mineral oil compound is just for looks, and the real deal is the mineral oil. I suspect that fake butter from all of the popcorn we eat is really what the current finish is instead. They might get wiped with a paper towel once in a while, and for the most part, nothing sticks to them any more...

Remember that early man ate road kill off the ground and managed to survive anyway...

S

Re: Food friendly finish

#16

Wait a minute Steve!? How early did man...

JamieDonaldson

...have roads for collecting roadkill? :D

Re: Food friendly finish

#17

Steven Antonucci

Sorry- "Found dining opportunity"

steven antonucci

Although I think there are documented cases of the ancient Greeks and Romans hitting the occassional deer with a chariot! Little did they know that they had just created the world's first drive-through!

:b

S