Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

beware...

Posts

beware...

#1

beware...

GaryG in MD

I just bought a Sorby 8-inch "figure-8" caliper from Klingspor, and I am extremely disappointed. It wasn't exactly cheap for what it is, and I expected a quality tool. Instead, I got a total piece of garbage. This is worse than something from China! The fact that the ends don't match up is the least of my worries. It's totally unusable. It is so tight that I can barely open and close it with all my might. I thought it might be adjustable, but it isn't. I tried to "exercise" it a bit to see if it would loosen up -- not only did it not loosen, it started to bind. The edges all around are sharp (square cut) with no relief -- just a cheap, crappy stamping hammered together and not inspected. This is the last thing I'll ever buy from Sorby. Their QC has obviously gone in the dumper. Needless to say, this is going back to where I got it, for a refund. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#2

Re: beware...

Terry Gerros

That is a drag. In More Woodturning, I can't remember which issue, there was a guy from Arizona selling calipers. I emailed Fred and he gave me the contact...yes, I have unfortunately lost it, information. Extremely well made!! Looks, shape wise, like the Kelton caliper, but flat steel rather than round stock. It was one of those purchases that at the time seemed a little spendy, but once in hand, was well worth the money. Sorry I can't be more help. Yes, I would buy it again....that is if I could remember who made it. No name on the item.

Re: beware...

#3

Steven Antonucci

May not be their fault

steven antonucci

FWIW-

I have the same caliper for years, and from time to time, if I drop them, they bend enough to have the issue you describe. If you just pull the ends that touch marginally out, it will close the gap on the other side.

For whatever reason it happens, it is a relatively simple fix and takes a second.

Steve

Re: beware...

#4

This upsets me because

Ruth Niles

You didn't say that you contacted Sorby and told them of your disappointment before posting online. Yes, there should be better quality control. It's not always possible to check every single item and you just might have gotten a bad one.

I totally understand that getting less than what you expected is a real bummer and you (and me, too) get mad. But perhaps they would not only send you another (better) one but also give you a discount on your next order...........or maybe not after reading your post.

As a retailer, I really hope that anyone who is not pleased with a purchase would first give me the chance to refund or replace. Every retailer wants happy customers.

Re: beware...

#5

Re: beware...

Steve Harder

Take a look at the Veritas Thickness Calipers at LeeValley. They are definitely high quality and they allow you to measure the thickness, remove caliper from bowl, and then still view the thickness as a reference.

Re: beware...

#6

Re: beware...

Nelson

Maybe a dumb question but did you loosen the knob so it would open and close better?

Re: beware...

#7

Re: This upsets me because

Galen Vetterick

Ruth

I hear what you say and they may make it right if he calls.

I looked at the same Sorby (7") figure eight calipers at our local Woodsmith store a while back.

I passed them up.

I know they are just two pieces put back to back so the points did not line up but the ones I saw had this and one side seemed sprung so they did not line up in a smooth circular plane.

They were just hung on a rack in a plastic bag. I wonder if part of this was just poor handling during shipment or someone dropped them once in the store.

I'm sure our Woodsmith store will sell them as is and not pull them off the shelf. I am buying less at that store for quality I see of items on display.

Re: beware...

#8

Re: beware...

Fred Holder

The information on the Calipers mentioned in More Woodturning is found in the November 2008 issue. The maker of the caliper is:

CHRIS VEMICH

5670 W GERHART RD

TUCSON, AZ 85745

or by e-mail at:

cjvemich@cox.net

or by telephone at: 520-743-0858

This is a Photo of the unit.


Re: beware...

#9

I Did, You Did!

George Guadiane

I had an issue with a Tee Shirt a while back. I called/emailed (who remembers), offered to return the defective one, you said keep it and sent another one right out, which I still wear often!

The original is now sleeveless and rarely gets out of the drawer, but I couldn't bare to just throw it in the rag bag.

Customer service is EVERYTHING in retail, but, judging from another comment, it sounds like this tool might not be of the same quality as the name it carries.

Re: beware...

#10

Leo Cuellar

I bought the same ones from...

Leo Cuellar

Grizzly, and was equally disappointed, mostly with the quality of the finish. It was one of the few Sorby items that wasn't on display in the showroom.

Re: beware...

#11

Steve Kubien

Re: beware...

Steve Kubien

Hmmm, I've had the same calipers for almost 2 years. I love them. Easy to adjust and the tips line up just fine, even after visiting the floor a few times.

Re: beware...

#12

thanks for the reco, Steve

GaryG in MD

Yes, you're absolutely right. I have that one and have been using it happily for many years. I just thought it would be nice to have a double ender for small things and instant readout. (I said 8", but it's actually the one they call 4" because that is the max distance over which it can measure -- the full length is 8"). After this experience, I'll just keep using my good ol' Lee Valley. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#13

the problem is...

GaryG in MD

...it doesn't have a knob. The fastener is locked tight and is not adjustable -- believe me, I tried -- even with a pliers. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#14

ineresting...

GaryG in MD

Re: beware...

#15

Steve,  apparently...

GaryG in MD

they changed their design or production methods (or location); their QC has now gone in the dumper -- probably trying to cut costs. I was very surprised -- I used to think the name Sorby meant quality at a higher price. No longer. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#16

Thanks Terry and Fred...

GaryG in MD

That's an interesting looking device, but not what I'm looking for. I wanted a figure-8 type that shows the thickness on the other end. Thanks for letting me see this one anyway, Gary

Re: beware...

#17

that's not the real problem...

GaryG in MD

I mentioned it as an aside. The real problem is that I cannot open and close them without extreme effort with two hands (and a pair of gloves, to keep from cutting my hands on the sharp edges)! They are completely unusable. The tension cannot be adjusted, and the more I exercise them (hoping they would loosen up with use), the more they bind. Complete garbage. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#18

sorry Ruth...

GaryG in MD

With all respect to you, because I know you're a conscientious person and retailer, my problem is not with the retailer (Klingspor) -- I'm sure they will give me a refund. My problem is with the huge manufacturer, Sorby, and I don't feel like they are going to listen to little ol' me -- even if I would take the time to figure out how to contact a rep.

I'm sure this caliper used to be a quality product, but they're obviously cutting corners now, and this is garbage. It is indicative of what is being done in many area of our life -- going cheap and giving the customer less for more. (I seriously doubt this item was made in England -- if it was they should be ashamed.) When that happens, I believe that it is our duty to alert other potential customers. If we stop buying their products en masse, maybe they'll get the point. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#19

Galen, as I've noted elsewhere here...

GaryG in MD

the alignment is not the problem. The problem is that it will not open and close. That makes it worthless, and insulting to us as customers. And yes, I am insulted by their obvious lack of caring what they make and sell now. If we don't buy their equipment any more, perhaps they will get the message. Penny wise and pound foolish. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#20

It Took Less Than A Min.

Barbara Gill

You indicated in one of the above posts that you anticipated having difficulty figuring out how to contact Sorby. Here is how:

sales@robert-sorby.co.uk

They also have a Twitter presence.

It seems quite harsh to try to trash the reputation of a retailer based on one experience with a bad product without even trying to inform them of your problem. I agree 100% with Ruth's post. Without responsible feedback we as retailers will not always be able to catch mistakes.

Re: beware...

#21

Re: It Took Less Than A Min.

Carole Valentine

I would have to agree with Barb. I am no huge Sorby fan (for other reasons), but it's just a fact of life that stuff happens even with the most diligent manufacturers. Nobody is perfect. One of the marks of an excellent manufacturer, in my mind, is how they respond when there is a problem. Do they value their customers enough to correct the problem immediately at no cost and with the least possible inconvenience to the customer? Obviously, they cannot do this if they are never made aware and given the opportunity. To beat anyone up publicly before even giving them a chance to correct a single perceived wrong is, I think, uncalled for. I have made enough mistakes in my life to be grateful for second chances!

Re: beware...

#22

Re: beware...interesting

Don Evans

Funny in a way how some view this differently!

I took his message (mainly due to the subject "beware") that he was informing all us to NOT fall victim to this particular bad product.

That was the main reason for the post, not to trash as stated the maker so much as warn us not to waste our money...

We call that a "heads up".......

Don

PS, if you respond I probably will not see it, sorry

Re: beware...

#23

How Often Do They Respond?

Stuart Johnson

My wife and I routinely send emails praising and complaining to companies about both products and service. When sending negative messages we explain the issue and what if any remedy we expect. We get a much higher response number thanking us when we compliment the company. When we have an issue the responses are less and less depending on the size of the company. The larger the company the fewer. It is not unusual to get a thank you for a compliment and then silence from the same company if a complaint is sent.

An example is Lowes. They did a good job on a door installation. My wife sent a message complimenting them and received a thank you. I bought 9 shop lights and had six ballasts go out. I sent an email about the quality and did not receive any response. When they installed a dishwasher they charged $50 to add a faucet that cost $5 and took 2 minutes to install. I complained about the charge and was told that was their rate. I sent a second email asking for the email address or phone number for the company president and they promptly issued a $45 credit.

So in my opinion contacting the company, Sorby in Gary's case, is really a crap shoot. Posting the issue here maybe a little calmer, contacting the vendor and Sorby is probably the best approach. As other users it is nice to see a review from a recent purchaser.

Re: beware...

#24

Barbara and Carole...

GaryG in MD

IMO the DESIGN is flawed, not just the manufacturing of this one item. There's nothing they can do to help me with that. They need to retool back to the original specs. This thing says cheap, cheap, cheap all over it. ...Gary

Re: beware...

#25

Re: Barbara and Carole...

Carole Valentine

Gary, are you absolutely sure they are not adjustable? Mine certainly are...they have a hex nut that can be loosened or tightened, as do all the ones in the current catalogs that I see.