Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Cognitive Friction and Turning

Posts

Cognitive Friction and Turning

#1

Cognitive Friction and Turning

charlie belden

Cognitive friction is "the resistance encountered by human intellect when it engages with a complex system of rules that change as the problem permutes". Alan Cooper, author of "The Inmates Are Running the Asylum: Why High-Tech Products Drive us Crazy and How to Restore the Sanity" coined the term for use by software and hardware developers. But the concept is applicable to all sorts of other human endeavors.

In a nut shell, it says that the greater the gap between cause and effect, the harder it is to cause a desired effect - or from an effect figure out the cause. As a male, trying to understand just onefemale, I've encountered what may be the ultimate High Cognitive Friction conditions. This person had a magnetic sign stuck on the refridgerator door that said

I know you think you know and understand what I said.

However, you don't understand that

What I said isn't what I meant

HER mother had the same thing on her refridgerator door

and

HER grandmother did as well.

THAT was a contributing factor to our no longer being married.

With that back ground information - let's look at woodturning - single axis turning for starters.

We've got a piece of wood being turned at one end by a motor and perhaps supported on the other end by a tail center. We have a tool rest whose height can be adjusted up and down and on which our cutting tool will be placed. And we've got a cutting tool with a bevel and cutting edge on one end and a handle on the other. The desired effect is a piece that's symetric around its single axis that's shaped as we desire it to be shaped.

Learning the relationship of tool to tool rest, handle movement to bevel and cutting edge and the bevel and cutting edge to the spinning wood all must be understood and used to get the desired effect. To a novice turner, this all seems equivalent to chewing gum and walking - while you're whistling and yodeling at the same time - and doing a graceful pirouette every fourth step. Did I mention going through the alphabet - backwards in your head while you're doing all the rest of that stuff?

The fact that few if any self taught turners are killed while overcoming turning's cognitive friction is somewhat of a surprise. Once the connection between cause and effect is understood, either consciously or unconsicously, the desired effect is achieved without worrying or thinking about the cause. With practice muscle memory takes over - think of what you want - do it without thinking of HOW. Want a cove and you turn a cove - automatically. And once you've got IT, it's assumed to be Common Knowledge. As such it is often not even mentioned - to a newbie turner - because It's So Obvious - and we tend to forget when IT wasn't obvious at all.

But if you teach or mentor new turners you're faced with a quandry. If you point out things that are obviously obvious to the novice - you run the risk of having the novice think that you think he or she is an absolute idiot. However, if you assume the novice already knows something she/he needs to know and understand in order to turn safely - and you DON'T point it out - and he/she DOESN'T know ir - she/he could get injured - or screw up a piece he/she spent so much time and effort doing.

So here's the question:

"What turning technique you are aware of has the highest congiitve friction and how did you overcome it or learn the Cause & Effect?"

You'll get partial credit for identifying a High Cognitive Friction technique and extra credit if I can understand your explanation of how you overcame it .; )

Re: Cognitive Friction and Turning

#2

Leo Cuellar

Veni, vedi, carborundi!

Leo Cuellar

I came, I saw, I sanded! I'm one of those guys who started out without a teacher... being a reasonably intelligent sort I figured I'd be able to figure it out.

Skew chisel; so simple, so elegant, so devastating!

It is the one tool that could have killed me; if I didn't have enough (m)ass to keep it from bouncing too much. It is the one tool that I couldn't figure out on my own! I had to purchase the Keith Rowley "A Foundation in Woodturning" DVD to keep from doing myself in. After a great many viewings and as much practice as I can (continually) fit in, I'm finally no longer "scared" of the skew. Your "Skewing Around" articles have been a tremendous help as well. In fact the whole idea of riding the bevel into a cut at the beginning was a foreign concept! I was a carver, stick the pointy end in first, then ride the bevel to refine. Needless to say I had to resort to the 80 grit gouge always, all my gouges were "roughing" gouges :D . Now though, since learning that fact I can usually start sanding in the 180-220 grit range.

Practice, practice, practice!

What really makes me feel stupid in retrospect, is after all the hours I'd spent sharpening various types of tools: that fact should have been self evident! It is odd but people do sometimes get offended if you try to save their lives.

Re: Cognitive Friction and Turning

#3

That's A Million Dollar T-Shirt Idea!

charlie belden

I'd pay $20 for one.

The skew, and the bedan as well, are probably the most misunderstood by newbies turning tool, yet one of the most versatile - once you understand the different ways they can be used. I think it might be because of that long sharp nasty point in the case of the skey and those two sharp corners on the bedan.

They can be used by getting the bevel rubbing first then engaging the cutting edge, supported behind by the bevel to control the depth of cut - OR - by starting a cut with the long point -just the tip - or, for the bedan, one of the sharp corners - and riding down 'til the bevel engages the wood.

With a curve in the cutting edge of a skew, it becomes a perceived safer tool to use for peeling cuts AND allows it to be used as a curved scraper on the inside of bowls and boxes. And it isn't hard to put a curve in a skew's cutting edge by rotating the tool a bit and spending a little more time grinding towards the "heel" and again towards the "long point". A six or eight inch MDF disk mounted on a face plate - with PSA sand paper stuck to it is great for shaping and sharpening a curved edge skew.

For me, it's those nasty fingernail ground spindle and bowl gouges that scare the hell out of me. When you get near their arcs center - things can get really twitchy - and the wrong side of the edge can be engaged VERY QUICKLY. I understand the theory of their use and can, with some trepidation, use them semi-properly. And I can appreciate what they CAN do - when used properly. But they still put my teeth on edge when I use them.

Re: Cognitive Friction and Turning

#4

Leo Cuellar

I had to look up bedan.

Leo Cuellar

Looks like something that will merit further research in the future.

I just ground my big skew to that style last night. I have to play with the curves/slope a little more, but I like it. I'm going to try grinding one in a bullnose shape like the one Cindy Drozda advocates. It looks like it would be a great detail skew. Or perhaps a great temporary ceiling decoration! I still like a nice pointy skew for dovetailing for the chuck though.

I've been busy trying to learn how to make that fancy grind. I'm getting consistent results now. I found Keith's little tip about using the skew to cut a series of starter grooves for the bowl gouge very helpful. Most particularly for the lids on boxes, where no evolution of shape is allowed :D . I still have a little trouble at the very bottom of the cut, probably because I haven't got a tool rest that fits inside the bowl on the smaller pieces. Just one more thing to make, sure glad I don't own a boat as well.

Not sure if that last word really translates as "sanded", but it was descriptive of the 6 months I worked for Sauder.