Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

Posts

Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#1

Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

Mike Foster

I have recently been exploring the intersection of math and sculpture. One of the really cool things that I have found is the class of math objects called minimal surfaces. These are surfaces that describe the least amount of surface area that will connect a circumscribed area. Soap bubbles will form a surface with the least amount of surface area with a given boundary. Bubbles have no boundary, so form the least amount of surface area for a given volume, a sphere. A loop of wire will result in a flat disc, bend the loop and the bubble will join the area in a smooth curve that minimizes the amount of film. More complicated structures can be made by creating bubbles from two or more loops of wire with a film joining the two (called a catenoid). This is a fairly complicated surface that joins 3 discs (or loops of wire) but has holes that perforate and join the surfaces. This was described by 3 mathematicians, Costa, Hoffman and Meeks (hence the title). I have no understanding of the math that underlies the form, but I do know that computing power is really essential carry it out.

I found the form irresistible and decided to try to create it out on the lathe. While carrying it out, I found it more and more satisfying as I carved the joining holes. I really did not expect that I could do it. This model has 3 perforations from each side, making 6 total. This can be varied from 2 on each side up to as many as you care. The holes get smaller as the number increases. The wall thickness for the entire piece is about 1/8� including the perforations. It really astounded me as I was carving the holes to size that I could really pull it off.

This form not is cool not only in how the holes perforate the discs and compliment each other so perfectly that I could get a consistent wall thickness, but instead of having 6 surfaces, it only really has 2. I debated whether or not to accentuate this, but it seemed to call for it. All I did was bleach one surface, and leave the other natural.

I really agonized on how to display the piece. It is really a piece that calls for interaction and moving it around to see it from all sides. This stand is an initial stab at it. I considered a motorized revolving mount, but rejected that. I wonder about suspending it from above. Anyone have a better idea?

I'm afraid that pictures really can't capture the piece, as it begs for closer inspection and interaction.

Bubinga 9�d x 6�h. Maple pedestal.

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#2

Very Cool

Matt Overton

I warn you if you take it to the next level, your head might explode. It has great possibilities! Nice work, Mike.

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#3

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

Barb Siddiqui

That is ..... quite overwhelming. I admire your spunk in trying that. New genre.. 'Concept' Turnings. Well done!

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#4

Steven Antonucci

It's cool, but you lost me

steven antonucci

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#5

Preety Cool Mike

Don Orr

Weird, crazy, different-but cool! Very well executed as is usual for you.

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#6

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

Philip Duffy

Fantastic piece of art! Congratulations on bringing it all together in one concise thought and action. Phil

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#7

Thanks all

Mike Foster

The math behind this is really beyond me, but the idea behind it is more comprehensible. All it requires is a vat of soap and some wire, and you can start creating minimal surfaces as the soap film seeks the smallest surface area for a given boundary. This particular form is more complex, but was so cool, I had to give it a go. Thanks for the encouragement (more is coming).

Mike

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#8

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

Bob Macgregor

Yeah, very imaginative...but California's referendum on legalization isn't until tomorrow.

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#9

Re: It's cool, but you lost me

Don at Central Illinois

Thank you Steve. I thought I was the only one that can't visualize through the photos. I would love to get my hands on it, to take a real close look. Looks real cool though.

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#10

Steven Antonucci

In three dimensions

steven antonucci

Is it that horn shape with three holes on either side, with the two sides being offset?

I'm still not clear on how you'd produce this shape in soap bubbles with a wire. Would it require multiple wires?

S

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#11

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

Randy Gleckler

That is very cool... I like it a lot. Not sure I really followed the explanation, but your form just looks amazing. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#12

Steve

Mike Foster

I don't really think you could actually construct this shape with wire and soap. The soap film analogy works for these structures, up to a point. Yes you need to use more than one wire loop. Imagine taking two wire loops of the same size, dip them in soap and put them together. Now stretch the two apart and you will have film that forms a disc inside each loop, but you would also have film that connects the loop, and it will take the shape of a catenoid. This is similar to the shapes of some of the nuclear power plant cooling towers that have a narrow waist. You can pop the film so that the only film left is a catenoid, and this is the basis for one class of minimal surfaces.

The mathematicians have taken things a lot further, as in the structure. Here, they first constructed the catenoid, then bisected it with a plane (or disc as in my piece) then pierced the result with holes. I don't think you could actually do this with soap and wires. There a whole series of different minimal surfaces that they have described, many of which have become the basis for other sculptures. I am working on a second in this series which is also fascinating, but I'll wait till it is done to give out more.

Mike

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#13

Steven Antonucci

that explains the third plane- thanks!

steven antonucci

Re: Costa-Hoffman-Meeks

#14

Very nice!

Jorge Casta�eda

Mike,

Sure is an interesting field, doing searches I found some of the applications of these forms in architecture make pleasant roofs that I've seen in my native Mexico made of ferro - cement. The math is beyond me, I lost my calculus long time ago. But I did enjoy reading all I found

Thanks for posting it.

Looking forward to the following pieces.

Jorge