Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

What do you give credit for?

Posts

What do you give credit for?

#1

Steven Antonucci

What do you give credit for?

steven antonucci

Keith brought up an interesting topic: if someone asks you to show them how you do something, do you expect them to give you credit for it in the future?

How "specialized" does something need to be to deserve credit? If I taught you how to make a bowl, would it be something you'd feel obligate to mention every bowl you present? How about a burning pen?

Where do you draw the lines in giving credit?

Steve

Re: What do you give credit for?

#2

Re: What do you give credit for?

George Guadiane

Personally, I think woodturning is like being born and growing up (older for those of us who will NEVER GROW UP)... You don't come out fully formed and you have a lot of help along the way. Whatever techniques I have learned have been at the feet of others.

The first thing I ever turned was a pen, the only pen I ever turned... I did it at the first AWA Totally Turning... One of the guys from the club stood over me and made sure I did it properly... George G. I think, and I give him credit for helping me decide to turn wood instead of make exotic wood (flat board) boxes.

The rest, bowls, hollow forms, multi axis, off axis, burned, dyed, painted, pierced, carved.......... I give credit for all of the things that I have learned to the people who have done demos in club meetings, symposiums and hands on things that I have attended. None of the things I have tried so far have been proprietary. Untold HOURS looking at woodturner/woodturning websites and the months of hours I have spent on this and other boards, reading the questions and answers, looking at the work and explanations about it has been monumental in helping me along my path.

If, for instance, I ever get around to making Keith Tompkin's flowing flag like thing (I'm sure it has a name), I'll give him credit - as if all turners won't already know.

Finials are a little dicey for me. As an Antiques Dealer, I know that finials and writing instruments have been turned for centuries, in one form or another, so I don't know that I need to give Cindy Drozda credit for any finial I turn, although I did watch her turn one in a demo she did.

On the OTHER side of the question, I did an "OATS" segmenting demo a few years back, provided a six page handout at a Totally Turning (no pay). A few months later, I get an email with a link saying that someone (who apparently saw my demo) was using the acronym, using a "similar" handout and teaching a class (for pay) without making any reference to me.

I feel like I "invented" this concept, even though 14-16 months into showing it off, Matt Clarke and Don Orr informed me that two English (OK, I forgot their names too) guys had showed the idea, one in a book and the other in an article 15 years or so before I started turning.

As a side note, I also "invented the omelet" at age 8. My mom let me cook my own breakfast. I was SO EXCITED at my new cool invention and she just said, "Oh yeah, that's called an omelet." My first invention let down.

Paul Petrie, Keith Tompkins, Don Orr, Steve Sherman are a few of the local standouts who showed me things that I use on a nearly day to day basis.

I have read books, seen videos, DVDs and seen demos of many of the top turners. They come up in conversations often, as resources. The list is long and varied, depending on what type of turning, burning, painting, piercing, or whatever is the topic.

Re: What do you give credit for?

#3

Re: What do you give credit for?

Peter Lamb

To this very day I give credit to Bonnie Klein for much of what I have learned some twenty-five years later.

Peter

Re: What do you give credit for?

#4

Re: What do you give credit for?

Dick Wilson

I have ventured into the carving and piercing arena. I fell in love with the work of J. Paul Fennell the first time I saw one of his extradonary pieces. There is a young gentlemen out of Scotland, Richard Kennedy, who's work just blows me away.

One thing that I have learned is no mater how original I think I am being the wheel has already been invented. And........ I come up with a design........now is that original or is it something I have seen in my mind's foggy past. I guess the only way to make sure your work is "original" is to live in a vacuum.

I have mentioned Fennel when showing my work. After a while it seems redundant to mention someone after every piece you do. I agree with others, I pick up processes and ideas from so many sources it is impossible to give credit.

Re: What do you give credit for?

#5

Use a little common sense

Ed Moore in SW VA

When I teach a class or do a basic demo I often start with the acronym SAFER, which refers to Speed, Aside, Fasten, Eyes, Rotate. I give credit to Don Riggs and Keith Rowley. I first heard it from Don and it comes from Rowley's book. It costs nothing to give them credit.

I attended a demo and the presenter spent the entire demo praising and crediting a nationally known turner in the audience. The known turner was embarrassed and not pleased by the excessive attention directed at him. I was uncomfortable for my friend and turned off by the presentation.

If I were to do a demo on hollow forms, and I don't, I would feel compelled to mention David Ellsworth and John Jordan. They don't need my endorsement, but my academic background would not permit me to ignore them and act as if what I was doing was original with me.

A little honesty and a lot of humility can go a long way in avoiding unpleasant misperceptions.

Ed

Re: What do you give credit for?

#6

Re: What do you give credit for?

Bill jacksonville, NC

I am self-taught, besides reading books and watching more than a few videos. I admire too many woodturners and their work to list. Besides keeping an open mind, believe in the three P�s. (Patience, Practice, and Perseverance) Once you have basics of woodturning down, good tools and equipment, do not be afraid to try anything.

The old internet news groups and now message board helped me more than any one turner. I have yet to meet the turner want to emulate.

On topic of copying and plagiarism unless you was a classmate or roommate of Leonardo da Vinci do not get so full of yourself! Do not know if he ever turned a piece of wood or not but guess, you get my drift.

Re: What do you give credit for?

#7

Steven Antonucci

So is there a concept of public domain in turning?

steven antonucci

I don't disagree with a word that you've said, but I wonder when something goes from being specialized knowledge to public domain? And what is the proper timeframe that someone is credited for something, even though it may have transformed from their original idea and/or grown?

Do you feel it makes sense to still credit Ellsworth for hollowforms? Even if people cutting them today are using different methods? I was astonished to see hollow, wooden vessels at the King Tutankhamen exhibit yesterday. Were they the same thing? Probably not, but it seems that he may not have invented the hollow wooden vessel after all?

If you've never met him or been exposed to his work, is the credit transitive? If you learned it from A who learned it from B who learned it from Ellsworth, do you need to credit A or Ellsworth? Or can there be a public domain of idea within the world of turning? Creative commons?

Clearly, it is right and proper to be thankful fo the folks that have had an influence on us-directly and indirectly. I meet people all of the time who are not exposed to woodturning at the depth that I am, and quite honestly, they mistakenly credit ME for being "the guy". I always take a minute to correct it, but in subsequent conversations, I will hear them say "Antonucci showed me this..."

To a certain extent, they are correct for crediting me for showing THEM, no? Influence is about exposure and contact. If I have never heard of you or seen your work, I cannot be influenced by it, can I? If I meet someone who has, I see your work through a filter, which always transforms it somehow.

Black and white isn't always black, nor is it always white...

Steve

Re: What do you give credit for?

#8

Re: So is there a concept of public domain in turn

Ed Moore in SW VA

I try to avoid giving absolute credit for something. In my hypothetical demo I would have said that David Ellsworth turned hollow forms and is credited with popularizing them. My reference to John Jordan would be that he has a distinct style of carving and texturing them that I find appealing. I don't know who made the first one on a lathe. I suspect that pottery of some kind influenced them both. I think it is good to mention those who helped with the development of a style or form to give a perspective to a newbie and to indicate that you have not worked in a vacuum.

I heard a well-known demonstrator say that Person A was one of the top turners in the world. Person A is a refined turner whose work has gotten some attention. I was annoyed by this statement because I am aware of someone else (not me) whose work is similar, and just as good, but not quite as well promoted perhaps. I guess I am saying that we must be careful not to put people on pedestals nor give undeserved credit.

There is validity in the concept of public domain. I think one can make a hollow form at this stage and not give credit to anyone - unless it is a deliberate copy of some person's work.

ED

Re: What do you give credit for?

#9

Re: What do you give credit for?

robo hippy

I never hesitate to mention where I learned a particular trick. One reason is to give credit to the instructor. Another reason is in some hopes that it will get back to them that I learned from them. It never hurts, and in a lot of cases, helps all involved.

"When sphincter tightening exceeds chuck tightening, you have a problem!" frp, Pat's Fan on Woodnet forums.

"If it don't hold soup, it's art." Anthony Yak (Yakoski I think) also from Woodnet forums.

"Bad words will be said" and "the 80 grit gouge" from big Bil Grumbine.

"Anything with sharp teeth eats meat. Woodworking tools have sharp teeth. People are made out of meat." Some Aussie whose name I never got.

"Use sandpaper like my 4 year old uses toilet paper." Steve Antonnuci

I have an affinity for quotes, mostly because some people just say things so well, and I don't.

robo hippy

Re: What do you give credit for?

#10

Steven Antonucci

Imagine that... I am quotable!

steven antonucci

Re: What do you give credit for?

#11

Re: What do you give credit for?

Peter Lamb

By the way for the sake of accuracy "the eighty grit gouge" was used by Bob Stocksdale in 1983

Peter

Re: What do you give credit for?

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: What do you ...LONG

Keith Tompkins

Hey Steve, We are all influenced to some degree by the work of others, but the things that stick out in my mind are those who helped me along the way. My high-school shop teachers, Mr. Travis and Mr. Mahler.They literally changed the direction of my life. I received the "Craftsman of the Year" award in my senior year; these guys cared about and believed in me. I have never forgotten their kindness. Bob Way was a foreman at the cabinet shop where I got my first real job. He went out of his way to help me get started; I learned more from him than I would have ever gotten from some fancy woodworking school. I met Stan Rosenberg at our local turning club. Stan was much older than me, he became my friend and mentor...One day, after looking at my latest turning, Stan asked me "You have a lot of ability...what are you doing with it?" Nothing really, I replied. Stan gave me a talking-to that I will never forget; "You have been given a gift, a gift you don't appreciate, a gift you are wasting." I didn't fully understand where he was coming from until I heard his daughter speak at his funeral. There was nothing she could not accomplish, her dad had taught her. Indeed, she had led a very successful life. An accomplished musician and professor, she had even done much of the work on her home, including ripping out and replacing the floors and cabinets singlehandedly. Oh yeah,did I mention she was born totally blind? Stan was a true inspiration, and touched a lot of lives, including mine. These are just a few of the people I am indebted to, and have helped shape my career.

Re: What do you give credit for?

#13

That's a good tribute Keith, and I recall.....

JamieDonaldson

...several people that have been influential in certain periods of my life that I label as my "uncles." They appeared at opportune times and were instrumental in allowing me to initiate or complete efforts which would not have happened without their support. One such person was my copyright attorney, who represented me in Federal court vs. 3 publishers for 5 yrs, and he worked on a contingency basis. I believe we all have such instances of fairy Godfathers/mothers, and we sometimes don't recognize their influence on our actions until after the fact.