Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Good luck with that!

Posts

Good luck with that!

#1

Good luck with that!

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Today I got an email from someone "who works for a private collector" and had need of a small ivory piece turned and stained to replace a piece of wood that had earlier replaced a piece of turned stained ivory. In other words, she (he? - it was one of those androgynous names) wanted a piece of ivory to restore an antique.

I wrote back to explain that while the turning part was relatively simple, the ivory part wasn't. I wrote that it is illegal to buy or sell real ivory unless it is documented to be antique ivory. I went on to say that I could locate substitute ivory, but that I had no idea how it would take a stain. I finished up by asking if that would be acceptable.

The person wrote me back in very short order to thank me for my time, but that she/he would continue looking for someone who could turn a real piece of ivory. I wonder how that is going to work out? :\

Re: Good luck with that!

#2

Re: Good luck with that!

Don Evans

Hi Bill, you probably know this but you can get all the Monmoth ivory you want. Ivory is ivory, did they state African elephant ivory? If so then you can get that too as you said but the price would be more than I would invest. They would have to pay before ordering. Museums sell off elephant ivory now and then but you have to be sure to get documentation with it.

It's good idea to get documentation with monmoth also just to be safe, especially if going to display in show or sell site.

Don

Re: Good luck with that!

#3

Re: Good luck with that!

George Guadiane

What are the dimensions that would be needed to turn the piece in question?

I have collected quite a bit of it.

To my knowledge, it is legal to own, buy and sell "pre ban" ivory.

I have made several finials from an old tusk pieces, and a number of collars from bracelets and rings.

In short, I may be able to supply the material.

Re: Good luck with that!

#4

Re: Good luck with that!

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Don, I know the stuff can be had, but even without checking the price, I can say this isn't worthwhile for me. There is just too much hassle to make it worth my while.

George, I will write you privately with the email of the person who contacted me, as they asked if I knew of anyone else who could do the job. If you have the material and the desire, I am sure your skills are up to the task, judging by what I have seen of your work.

Re: Good luck with that!

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Good luck with that!

Dick Hines

How do you tell pre-ban ivory forn post-ban ivory. Is there a lable on it?

Re: Good luck with that!

#6

Re: Good luck with that!

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

That's the problem Dick. Like most other things, it is not an issue of them having to prove it is illegal ivory, it is you having to prove it isn't. From all I have read, if you are caught with the stuff, you are guilty until you can prove yourself innocent. And, it is commerce that is the issue. You can have all the ivory you want, apparently. You just can't sell it or buy it from someone else if the documentation is not present. That turns a little job like this into a huge nightmare for me. I have passed it on to George, since he thinks he may have the resources to do the work.

Maybe I am shooting myself in the foot saying this too, but I am getting real picky about doing "little" jobs in some instances anyway. I had a spindle project come my way, repairing a walnut chair for a guy. He almost burst a vessel when I told him $50.00 for the spindle, but decided he needed it done. I did not have the appropriate thickness of wood in my stash, so I had to go buy it. I ended up having to pay $40.00 for a small board. Yeah, I have some extra walnut now, in 10/4 to boot, but who knows how long that will sit around before I need it again, or if I will be able to find it when the need does arise. So, after burning two gallons of gas to go to the sawmill, plus buy the board, I was left with a net of approximately $4.80 on that one. :(

Re: Good luck with that!

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Good luck with that!

Dick Hines

Hard to make a living like that.

Re: Good luck with that!

#8

Re: Good luck with that!

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Fortunately, it does not happen often.

Re: Good luck with that!

#9

but, Bill...

ihmserv

...how much is it worth having a new story to tell at demos

about when not to do a turning. :D :D

IAN

Re: Good luck with that!

#10

Re: but, Bill...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Ian, I am getting some mileage there, that is for sure! :D