Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Because I Can

Posts

Because I Can

#1

Because I Can

charlie belden

Some turned pieces are turned Just Because I Can.

I stood and watched Soren Berger spend close to three hours turning a cylindrical 11" diameter by 9" tall lamp shade out of a 14" diameter by 14 inch logette of Atlas Cedar that had been cut less than a month ago. The first 20 minutes and the last ten minutes of that three hour process were kind of interesting in a way. The in between 150 minutes were more like watching paint dry - with narration.

In the first 20 minutes I'd seen him use a large roughing gouge to rough the logette to round and use the tool to make a finishing cut on the outside surface that more often is done with a skew. And I'd seen the main tool used - his design - and how it was used. I also learned why doing curves in a wood lampshade piece makes for a very weak lamp shade. In the last 10 minutes I saw how the final light cuts are made to finish off the inside of the shade - and part it off.

After lunch I watched what was basically an ad for, and demonstration of, his patented threading unit - which sells for around $600 USD. I DID learn a way to adjust threaded boxes so the grain aligns. THAT piece of information I might use - someday.

Then I got bored and went home - just a wee bit disappointed. Perhaps if I'd hung in there, I might have seen him do a turned Bowl With Handle ladle/spoon he does. I don't know if he did or not because he never told us what he'd be covering in his demo and other than his special calipers, hollowing tool and thread making device, he had no turnings to see, let alone see how they are made.

The Golden Ratio device he designed and sells was shown and its use described . That was sort of interesting. But that took all of 5 minutes.

He did create some big chips - quite suitable for kindling - while hollowing out the log for the lamp shade.

Maybe if I had a BIG lathe - say a Stubby, VB36 or the like I might have found the demo more interesting. Alas, I have only a JET VS Mini and 8 inch diameter lamp shades aren't all that useful around here.

I'm sure the gentleman does some great demonstrations. This one? Not so great.

Re: Because I Can

#2

Re: Because I Can

Terry Scott

Charlie if you ever get to sit in on one of my demos

Id like to hear what you think

Id appreciate credit if credit is due also I would welcome comments on improvements for next time .

One thing I dont do is ever finish a piece.I believe stagging the item is important .And if I stuff the piece up I am turning I have another in my magic box.

I do realize some may take offense to having their demo critiqued but I would welcome it

Cheers

Re: Because I Can

#3

Steven Antonucci

Why did you go?

steven antonucci

If you weren't interested in the topic or didn't know what the topic was in the first place, then what made you attend? We regularly bring in demonstrators, and if the topic is uninteresting, then I just don't go?

As someone who demostrates from time to time, I think it's important to share your feedback with the demonstrator beforehand and as a follow-up. If 50% of the club only turns on a mini lathe, perhaps you could have warned him that lampshades are interesting but not going to be well received. If nobody really cares about threading boxes, take it off the agenda.

Closing the feedback loop at the end of the day is critical. I always ask "so, what did you think?" I don't institute every idea ("Hey, you should really turn something start to finish"- "hey, you should have 5 intermediate steps prepared and not go end to end...."), but it helps to see how people receive what you have presented.

I'm not sure that posting "a review" here has any merit?

My .02.

Steve

Re: Because I Can

#4

Re: Because I Can

Doug Trembath

Charlie, I'm surprised that you didn't find Soren's demo at least partly interesting. I have only watched him demonstrate once, but found him engaging, insightful, and he shared a LOT of good info for a wannabe turner. This was in 1998, I think. I have applied a bunch of his techniques since then. If it seemed like an "infomercial", that's too bad. Most folks can't make an adequate living turning, so they develop tools to help the exploding number of people who, like me so many years ago, wannabe.

Everyone has to make a living, I guess...

Secondly, although I now have four lathes in the studio, I have turned 11.75" hollow vessels which sold at the shows I was in at the time, when that lathe was the only one running. (Don't ask why, OK? Bad karma...) It is a Jet mini, non-variable speed, and has a 12" capacity. Is yours different?

A 12" lampshade is a bit more useful, no?

It's probably simply a matter of perspective.

Yes, a lot of the items being demonstrated around the world are turned to show the technical ability of the demonstrator. I wouldn't want it any other way. The techniques shared have helped me become the turner I am today.

When I demo, I do the same thing, focus on what I think will educate, motivate, and provide more clear understanding of the techniques. I really think that's the best way to go about it.

Like Steve said, my .02...

Then again I don't, as yet, sell tools. ;)

Doug Trembath

Re: Because I Can

#5

Re: Why did you go?

charlie belden

Since I joined Silicon Valley Woodturners I've signed up and paid for just about every pro demonstration. And I've learned a great deal I can use. I usually get on the web and find out more about a demonstrator whose works I'm not familiar with. I found what I believe is his web site, but didn't find much about what he turns.

www.berger.co.nz

The rest of the web search hits were for galleries, some with images of some of his pieces.

Figured what the hell, maybe I'll learn something and/or pick up a useful tool. So I paid my money and went to the demo.

For this demo, there was no agenda and there was no "Here's what I'll be doing today." in the introduction. Other than his threading device and range of calipers / dividers, he brought no turned pieces or photos of his turned pieces. He did have some lampshades on his iPad - which he passed around AFTER his 3 hour Cylindrial Lampshade Demo. Other than being the one who provided the atlas cedar logette he'd asked for, I had no idea of what he'd be doing, nor apparently did any of the other attendees. There were no handouts and no requests as to what we'd like to see him demo.

To be fair, I should have stayed and provided some feed back. As a "consumer" I usually make an effort to provide feedback on a product or service - good or bad. If I like the product or service I let the source know why. If I don't like the product or service I also let the source know why. But demonstrations and pro demonstators are a bit different. He or she is a pro who has been doing this well for a long time. I'm just an amateur turner. I guess I should find his e-mail address and provide some feedback on this specific demonstration.

I did teach lost wax casting for over a dozen years. Spent a lot of time making illustrated handouts, with room in the margins for notes and always solicited comments, specifically requesting suggestions for improving the handouts. I also repeatedly told my students "If you don't get what I'm trying to get acrossed to you - ask again and keep asking until I explain it in a way you understand. You're paying me to teach you and you have every right to keep asking questions until you get it. And if you want to get together after class we'll work together 'til you get it."

For beginners, things were pretty structured and the Here's What We'll Be Covering and When list was the first thing handed out and in the class description. For intermeidiate and advanced students it was usually Here Are Some Possibilities But We'll Go Where The Class Decides. Usually my job was to provide ways of getting where they wanted to go and helping with the method selected.

I've posted reviews of tools, techniques and demonstrations here before. Most have been positive because my experience with the tool, technique or demonstration were positive. In this instance, I did learn some useful things. But I also spent quite a bit of time watching chips, albeit it BIG chips, fly. I, and everyone else attending already know how to do THAT. And I can think of two or three other ways to turn a thin lampshade that would have taken less than three hours to do. And the technique demonstrated was shown in the first three inches of the turning. The remaining 6" was just more of the same - only deeper.

As to the merits of posting reviews here, this one is merely my impression and opinion of this specific demonstration and I hope I made that clear. My reviews of tools typically include specific reasons why this tool is better than any other I've tried or looked into - in depth. For those reviews I go into probably more detail than most folks are interested in. But I believe that providing more info is prefereable to providing too little info. It's up to the reader to decide if the info and opinions I provide are useful or not.

The gentleman probably does other demonstrations I'd likely find more interesting and useful. I do feel that paying in cash to see an ad for a product with a $600 price tag is a bit cheeky - but that's just a personal thing for me.

I realize that a good day long demonstration takes a lot of preparation and a lot of skill. Cindy Drozda and Graeme Priddle demonstrations are my gold standards though almost at opposite ends of approaches to demonstrating. Cindy is almost an Aesthetic Machine while Graeme is more proned to free flowiing, interactive demos. Others may have other opinions of course.

Re: Because I Can

#6

Steven Antonucci

I'll rephrase it:

steven antonucci

If you had no expectations of Soren to demonstrate or discuss a topic, how could he have met them? I don't mean this as an attack on you Charlie, but I think it's an important item to flush out.

I work in my club as one of the guys who demonstrates, and it's easy for me because I know what type of stuff usually is interesting to a majority of the club. I come with an agenda, and I start my demo by suggesting "what we're going to do". Since I am not paid for this by the club and do it as a volunteer, I aim to be professional, but I don't have to be perfect. Often, we'll table an idea for a break if it's too distracting from the main subject.

I also am one of the "recruiters" who solicits demonstrators that are paid to demonstrate at the club. In my conversations with these folks, I try to express the skill levels and interests of the general population to make sure that they will be prepared and presenting a topic of interest to a majority.

I wonder if you polled the others that were there if they had a similar opinion of Soren's demos? I've seen him on the woodworkingchannel.com making scoops and I agree that it would have been a good topic for him to cover for your group. Perhaps you can communicate some of your concerns to your committee and get these things flushed out for the next demo?

Steve

Re: Because I Can

#7

Re: Because I Can

charlie belden

Doug:

The JET Mini VS I've got has only a nominal 10" max diameter - a bit under 7 1/2" max diameter if you want to be able to move the banjo without dismounting and remounting the piece. I have turned a few 9 1/2: bowls on it but found bowls aren't my prefered thing to turn.

I'm well aware of the Starving Artist situation. Pursuing a passion often has a significant price tag few of us are willing to pay. I very much admire those who follow their passion for it usually requires sacrifices. But it is the passionate, amateur or professional, that seem to drive turning into new realms. The fact that they share, monetarily compensated or not, their hard won knowledge and technique spreads their passion and benefits turners everywhere. Cindy and Graeme, along with many others, endured years of anonymity pursuing their passion. That they are finally reaping some of the rewards of their commitment is wonderful. I hope that the AAW continues to help find markets and better rewards for their effort and dedication.

And don't get me wrong - I REALLY like watching a demonstrator push the limits of what is possible, doing what had been thought unthinkable. It was a joy to watch Jimmy Clewes turn a Chinese Hat Lidded Box, and I was lucky enough to win the piece he did for the demo in a club raffle. And after most of the demos I've attended I went home and did a piece using what I'd learned at the demo. Not nearly as nice a piece as I'd seen made in the demo - but similar enough to be recognizable as a piece inspired by the demo. I often do an illustrated step by step guide to how the piece was done for future reference - and share the url to it.

Here's an example of a Cindy Drozda method of doing an inlayed "rim" lidded box with finial

http://svwoodturners.org/Demonstrators/Drozda/DrozdaMyrtleBoxProcess.html

There's not much about turning a cylindrical lamp shade that warrants an annotated illustrated procedure.