request
Keith Tompkins
I just got a request from someone who saw my work online. They would like me to provide them a step-by-step guide on how to complete a piece they are interested in making. How would YOU respond to that one?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
request
Keith Tompkins
I just got a request from someone who saw my work online. They would like me to provide them a step-by-step guide on how to complete a piece they are interested in making. How would YOU respond to that one?
Re: request
Steve in Durham NC
There are many great books and videos on the market. I may provide a brief summary but respectfully decline the detailed instructions. Suggest a book or video or join a club.
Re: request
Fred Bearman
Thank them for their interest, and that you will put them on a list of those who are committed to purchase the first edition of your book on this subject, once you have time to write it. In the meantime, you could offer them lessons at a rather high fee, which may cover some of the techniques - or ignore this unsolicited request completely.
Re: request
Bruce Lane
Put me on that list to purchase your book... 
Re: request
Richard Allen
That piece is one of my "signature" pieces. I do not provide instruction on making my "signature" pieces. I do offer classes on some of the techniques I use to make my "signature" pieces. I could provide you with a class schedule if you are interested. I also do demos from time to time in which I show some of the techniques I use on my "signature" pieces. I could provide you with a list of demos I will be giving.
Re: request
charlie belden
In the UseNet newsgroups I would ask if you happened to hear the PLONK of the fishing lure hitting the water.
Phiserman get points based on the number of responses their fishing lure gets.
OR
You could provide page 1 of 435
Acquire a lathe.
Acquire some turning tools.
Acquire some means of sharpening them
Acquire some wood.
Use the turning tools on the wood as it spins on the lathe.
Turn 10,000 pieces
1000 spindles
1000 weed pots
1000 bird houses
1000 christmas ornaments with icicles
1000 plates
1000 bowls
1000 vases
1000 hollow forms
1000 lidded boxes
1000 ideas of your own
Send me a photo of yourselof with your 10,000 pieces.
I will then send you page 2.
Pass
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
It's one thing to want to learn the methods and develop the skill-set needed to make the piece. It's quite another to simply want to copy. This, naturally reopens that bottle holding back the evil genie of plagiarism.
Tell the gent that if he'd like to have the piece, you'll be happy to make him one. At the same price that's listed at Del Mano, of course.
Unfortunately, woodworkers seem to have an inbred predilection to literally copy another person's work and see nothing wrong with this. Maybe it 100 years of Popular Mechanics with free (or even not free) plans, or good old Norm selling his "measured drawrings" of or shop class making a step stool, etc., but woodworkers seem to think that they have a right to do so. In that context, your questioner does not, I'm sure think he's asking for anything out of the ordinary.
No use in making an enemy. Just tell him that the information he seeks is not available, but thank him for his inquiry. If he asks "why?" Politely tell him "I don't inform or teach people how to do what I do."

Re: Charlie has the best one, but
Doug Trembath
I feel your discomfort. At shows I often get some housewife who runs to get her hubby, points out one of my own signature pieces, and says "Make me one of those, willya??"
OR, they just tell me bald-faced, that they will have their husband make one for them.
I just wish them well, and turn to the next customer. I did have one of my good craftsmen friends get upset when they heard one of these, and she gave the woman quite a dressing down, right outside my booth, letting her know what a tremendous insult it was. I just giggled inside...
Just politely decline, Keith, and with a wink let them know you don't give out trade secrets. "If I told you, I'd have to kill you."
None of us should have to deal with the silliness quite prevalent in our society, (and many others, as well), but we sell for a living, so...
Doug Trembath
Re: request
George Guadiane
Keith,
You could thank them for asking about the piece, then explain:
"I spent a lot of time and energy developing this. I think of the ideas and process as my personal intellectual property. I would have to think about how much time it would take me to develop the documentation and imagery necessary to fully explain the process.
I could then figure an hourly rate and bill, based on the amount of time it took me to prepare the materials.
Then I would have to consider the possibility, that once you had the information, you might compete with me, using my own design.
THEN I could consider the other things I could have done with that time and how much money or fun I could have made/had doing that instead.
Once I gave you a price, you would probably think I was out of my mind and decide to try it on your own. You would probably get a better result if I helped you, but it doesn't seem like a bargain you would consider, since your initial contact didn't start out "How much would it cost me to learn how to do..."
It's funny how people don't consider the value of a professional's time and experience.
Re: If you replied....
Donna Banfield
...and there's a lot to be said for just ignoring it, but if you reply, you could state as it is your signature piece, you are not prepared to disclose to the public all the knowledge, skills and techniques that you have gained over the several years that it took to eventually make that piece. Until that time comes, it will remain the trade secret that it is.
If they really need to have it, they can certainly purchase one - an original - at the retail price.
Re: request
Don Evans
I think the best way is the simple way.
Keith would you do this instruction manual for say $10,000.00
If yes, then write them and say you will write an instruction manual and tell them the price.
If you are not willing to do that, then ignor it. Pretty much anything you say to someone who thinks the way this person does is only going to dig the hole deeper. This is where the saying "silence is golden" came from.......
It's one thing to ask about a product that is a finish, like Terry's verdigris and another to want detail instructions on how to use it to get the look he does.
I cannot tell you the hours and hours I have used on some idea that when into a piece. I'm glad I don't do galleries anymore, it's not fun.
Don
Re: request
Keith Tompkins
Thanks everyone for responding...I thought the e-mail was pretty amusing, perhaps he wasn't aware that we take our work seriously. I think I responded without hurting his feelings
Seemed like an interesting topic for discussion.
Re: request
Coyne
I am always amazed at how kind and generous woodturners are in sharing the things they have learned the hard way, and how willing they are to share the secrets that work for them. Every day I see examples of this on this blog, and I am grateful to each of you.
I feel certain that the person making the request to Keith did so in innocence and ignorance of what it actually involved, and I hope that he learns enough over a period of time to realize what it would have meant. You have all been kind in your comments.
Coyne
You'r Right
George Guadiane
It IS difficult for many people to value the time of others... And kindness is a better way to go in explaining why people who are so generous and giving under almost every circumstance actually have limits.
I just had a guy take up a great deal of my time at an outdoor event, I came to the conclusion that he was "one of those" who didn't realize what they were doing... I gave him my card and had an email waiting when I got home, asking me if I taught classes or would give lessons. It's hard to take money, but the time I'm spending with him I could be doing something else, so I set a rate and he agreed...
Then he showed up with an INTERESTING piece of wood that he had gathered from England, I think... He didn't want to "ruin" it, so he asked me to turn it.
I can't charge for that time, I was having fun and he was just watching, not really asking questions.
So far, I'm charging a little, but not what we agreed to, and once I get him to a club meeting or two, I'll add him to the friends who I get to "play" with.
Anyway, my point was, on the one hand, our time is worth something. On the other hand, as a woodturner, I have an "obligation" to be another one of the nice guys.
I get this all of the time
steven antonucci
Usually, I dumb down the answer to force the person to figure things out on their own. It's one thing to WANT to copy something. It's completely ANOTHER THING to be able to do it. I don't want to discourage people from trying something new, but in the same light, I don't think "free answers" are really all that helpful.
So I give them enough to get started, and if they come back with problems, I give them some more direction, but still no step-by-step answers.
(or maybe I just draw it out on a napkin over beers...)
S
Re: request
John Jordan
Suggest they join the AAW to start.
John
What do you guys think you have to lose?
Mike Jones in Redding Ca.
In about the time that you spend here, you could have (likely) shared something of great value to a fellow turner. Most of the above replies above seem a bit selfish to me.
Can We Keep Anything For Ourselves?
George Guadiane
Most, if not all of the people who posted about this already do "public service" stuff in the woodturning arena.
I donate wood to my fellow turners because I have more than I can use.
I donate finished turnings to a couple of charities, because it makes me feel good. I supply (DONATE) most of the wood for demonstrators at our annual symposium, I have done demo rotations at these symposiums, at least every other year... Without payment... I share pretty much every trick I have for the few "signature" things that I do... How much more should I do?
After a person learns the basics, thinks up something cool, figures out, through trial and error how to do it, refines it until its so appealing that others want to copy it, you come along and call them selfish. Should we then be required to take more time to outline the steps of our processes and provide them to others for free?
Why? Because they don't take that hard EARNED distilled knowledge and just give it away?
I don't depend on turning to keep a roof over my head, I can "afford" to be generous with my materials and experience, but should that matter? If I couldn't afford to give away my secrets or my time to share them because I needed the income to survive or prosper, THEN would I be selfish?
Woodturners are generally friendly, generous, helpful people, including those who posted our "selfish" opinions. But we don't have to give anything away. And we certainly don't have to give it ALL away.
In your life, is there a point where you would say no? Could I borrow some money, can I move into your house and eat your food?
I get this too.
Ron Sardo
My answer depends on if I know them. If I consider them a friend I would most likely share how to do something. Especially if we were standing in front of a lathe.
If I never heard of them before, sometimes I do not respond. When I do, I ask what level turner they are. The ones that do reply say they are beginners and then I point them to my forum.
I've sent instructions from published articles I've written to people only to never receive a thank you.
Most people who ask for a "Free How To" have no idea haw long it takes to write a step by step. I guess I'm selfish because I value my time.
Perspective
Tony - Memphis
I'm still quite a rookie turner. The turning I do is mainly for furniture parts with a few things like pens and tool handles, etc. for fun. I don't hesitate to ask a specific question, but asking for step by step is a bit much in my opinion (unless we are talking a business proposition here - I paid Mr. Grumbine for some step by step and it came in the form of a DVD!). I've always impressed with the time that some of you already spend trying to help out other folks. I know it took a lot of time and effort to know what you know and some of that isn't easy to put in words anyway. I'm very appreciative of the help that I get here and elsewhere. I try to pass what I know (ain't much, but...). Anyway, I think it's a bit much to ask for step by step in any detail. One could also search the postings and find a lot of stuff already answered. Then there are books, dvd's, PBS, etc. I kow some folks can't afford to buy all the books and dvd's, but some libraries have a lot of that stuff. Also, there are usually local turning organizations with folks that are willing to help.
Tony
Re: Perspective
Grant Wilkinson
I wonder if the turner asking for the detailed instructions is a pen maker. In that world, it seems to be obligatory to provide detailed tutorials, including pictures, on how to make a particularly difficult or different pen style. Failure to do so results in nasty pm's and emails suggesting the "inventor" is selfish and thoughtless. I understand that imitation is the highest form of flattery, as some wise guy once said, but if the inventor is competing in a market for customers, I always find it presumptuous to think that the competitors have a right to his process.
There are no shortcuts to experience.
Ray - Middletown, IN
With enough experience one can figure out how just about anything is made. Doesn't mean you can duplicate it, just understand it. If you don't have the same skillset of the originator you will never completely duplicate his/her piece. Asking for step by step instructions indicates a lack of experience and understanding of the processes and skills involved. Perhaps just an outline of the various skills and processes necessary to develop the signature pieces is enough. Very few folks will ever develop the same level of expertise in the various physical skills used by the originating artist. The vision and thought process is something that probably cannot be described, taught, or understood to the novice. Here are the skills and processes involved, when you have the skillset and experience in those you will understand the rest. Wax on, Wax off.
Ray
Re: There are no shortcuts to experience.
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
I totally agree, give them the basic process and let them run with it... the details would take forever to explain and who has time for that.
Re: What do you guys think you have to lose?
Keith Tompkins
Hey Mike, I think as turners, we all share; especially compared with other craft or art forms. Personally, I've done countless demonstrations for nothing more than a thankyou. But I depend on my work to earn a significant part of my income, and am hesitant to just give my ideas away. I share the basics, but try to stay away from showing my "signature" techniques. Sometimes people don't place any value on what may have taken years to develop, and see no harm in copying other's accomplishments. As one example, you can't go to your car mechanic and ask how to fix your car, so you can do it yourself, can you? Mostly though, I'm sure requests like this happens to other turners frequently, and wondered how they would respond.
Re: request
Barry L Elder
Due to prior commitments of my time for the rest of my life, blah, blah, blah, blah.