Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Vacuum chuck size

Posts

Vacuum chuck size

#1

Vacuum chuck size

Ted Evans

Can someone tell me what the smallest practical size is for a vacuum chuck? I know the less surface for the vacuum equals less holding power. I was wondering if a 1 - 1 � chuck into a vase or HF would hold well enough to clean up the bottom. The chuck�s OD would match the vessel�s opening size. Thanks for any info. Ted

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#2

Richard Allen

Re: Vacuum chuck size *LINK*

Richard Allen

Do the math. 30" of mercury weighs 14.668 pounds per square inch. You are not likely to get a 30" vacuum so we can round it to 14 pounds.

The surface area of a 1" circle is a little over 3/4", giving you about 11 pounds of force.

The surface area of 1 1/4" is about 1 1/4", giving you about 17 pounds of force.

A 3" chuck give about 100 pounds of force.

A 5" chuck 275

You get the idea. A 1" chuck is not going to provide the force you need to hold a hollow form.

You might want to look at the woodchucker mandrel linked below.


Alternative chuck reverse chucking a hollow form

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#3

Re: Vacuum chuck size

Bill Howatt

I agree with Richard - it's too small.

Not only do you have a low holding force problem but it is compounded by the torque moment caused by the length of the HF or vase. When you push on the gouge to clean up the bottom it will tend to push the bottom of the HF sideways and very easily break the seal with the chuck because of the low holding force. I don't think it would work even with a steady.

Normally with a drum chuck in the bottom of the bowl the torque moment is small because the bottom of the bowl is almost adjacent to the drum chuck's sealing surface.

Bill

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#4

Re: Vacuum chuck size

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hi Ted,

The formula is easy. Take the area of the circle formed by the chuck's contact ring (3.14 x radius-2) and multiply that by the amount of vacuum you've got. Simple rule of thumb is to figure 5 pounds of pressure for every 10" of vacuum. Since you'll never get close to hard vacuum of 30", its best to figure on 25".

A 1" chuck has an area of .785".

At 25" of vacuum you've got about 12.5 pounds per square inch of atmospheric pressure. Thus on a 1" chuck you'll get .785 x 12.5 or 9.81 total pounds of pressure. That's not even enough for Christmas ornaments.

You have three alternatives

a) the hollowform chuck already mentioned.

b) a doughnut chuck that holds your piece sandwiched between two pieces of plywood; or

c) a jam chuck using the tailstock to hold the piece in place with friction on the headstock end driving the piece well enough for you to finish off the bottom. Last thing then is to carve off the nubbie where the TS pushed.

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#5

Re: Vacuum chuck size

Doc Green

Ted, there is no reason to limit the diameter of the vacuum chuck to the size of the opening in the hollow form. It will work if the vacuum chuck seats on the outside of the opening, out on the shoulder.

For example, suppose a HF is 5" in diameter at the shoulder. It should seat nicely on a vacuum drum chuck that is 4" in diameter, with the opening of the vessel extending into the drum. This changes things significantly.

The area of the chuck will be 12.56 square inches. Then, if you can pull a vacuum of 20" Hg, the force per square inch will be 10 pounds. Multiply this by the area to get 125 lbs of force applied to the hollow form.

If the piece is not too tall, it should work. Also, you can use the tail center for support for all but the very last cuts at the center of the foot.

~Doc

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#6

Doc is correct

Nick Stagg

Ted,

I make my own vacuum chucks with PVC pipe and put a wooden bearing surface on them about an inch to an inch and a quarter wide. I glue on the foam and roughly find the middle and cut pie shapes back to the wooden former. The pie shaped pieces are then folded back inside the chuck to protect hollow forms when they are reversed.

The only limiting factor, as Doc said, is the length of the neck of your vase. If you are planning on making long necked vases often, you could build youself a deeper chuck. It will work just fine in this application.

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#7

Re: Vacuum chuck size

Bob Macgregor

I guess I haven't quite grasped how this works, yet.

Let's suppose you have a 5" spherical vessel with a 1" opening. If you had a chuck that exactly sealed the opening, it would have a surface area of about .78 in^2. However, it seems to me that the force on the chuck would come from the entire surface area of the evacuated sphere, 78.5 in^2 times (say)10 or 12 psi. That doesn't mean a 1" contact area would be very stable, compared to a larger diameter chuck, but wouldn't they both have the same atmospheric force pushing on them, given that this is a hollow form?

Since I don't yet have an operational vacuum chucking system, I don't have any practical experience to validate my supposition, so I'll let more experienced voices correct my misapprehension.

BOB

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#8

Re: Vacuum chuck size

Bill Howatt

The atmospheric pressure is indeed pushing on the entire area of the evacuated HF but only the component that is parallel to the bed and pushing towards the evacuated chuck (the small 1" area) is doing anything to hold the piece. The forces around the HF pushing on the wall are doing just that, pushing on the wall, and they are balanced except for the area of the chuck since it is an area where there is no counter-acting air pressure because of the vacuum. So the only area that is holding the HF is the area of the chuck/HF interface where the vacuum is.

When chucking a bowl on a drum chuck, the only force holding the bowl is the one pushing back towards the drum chuck/headstock. All of the other forces around the bowl are in equilibrium because of the air pressure surrounding the wall. If it weren't for the friction between the drum chuck's sealing gasket and the bowl it would slide off the chuck regardless of how much vacuum was applied since there is no holding force generated laterally. To be a bit more correct, in most cases the curvature of the bowl "wraps" around the drum chuck so this is also an aid for lateral stability.

Bill

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#9

Re: Vacuum chuck size

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Of the forces that vacuum is the least effective is that of sheer force. Sheer force needs the help of mechanical resistance to be more effective.

And a vacuum chuck on a lathe is trying to resist sheer force. (sliding off the chuck)

So more vacuum pressure (in this case, measured as psi) is not the whole answer. On a narrow necked vessel, the mechanical resistance comes in the inserting of the vessel into the chuck, rather than just on it.

Another issue that compromises the effectiveness of of vacuum clamping is the porosity of the wood. Here is where thin walled vessels may not be your friend. Plastic food wrap can be a help here.

HTH.

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#10

Re: Vacuum chuck size

Jim Rutten

So is what you are saying is that while this:


May be dangerous that this:


is more acceptable?

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#11

Yep !

Doc Green

Re: Vacuum chuck size

#12

Re: Exactly!

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ