Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

Posts

Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#1

Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

Woodmangler

Sounds like a weird question I am sure but.... I had a piece of white oak that I had drying on the rack for about 8 months... I decided, since the bark looked real secure to do a natural edged bowl...

I had a heck of a time even getting it shaped on the outside, then the inside was resisting every gouge I own... resharpened, honed... nothing seemed to help. I was getting dust that was so hot it was burning me...

I finally got one of Randy's monster tool hollowing tool and was able to get it hollowed a very little at a time... then it was almost impossible to sand!!

I am going to soak it in oil tomorrow and then buff...

I have never encountered a chunk of wood like this...

You?

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#2

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

john lucas

I made the mistake of turning some barnwood once. I was making hand mirrors. I would not even get one pass across the 5 1/" board before I had to sharpen the gouge. Once I got down about 1/8" or so it turned OK. Must have been the sand trapped in the outer layers.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#3

Don Pencil

No!

Don Pencil

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#4

A friend in TX gave me some........

JamieDonaldson

..."desert ironwood" and it must have been petrified! I understand there are several types of ironwood, and I was finally able to cut this stuff with a homemade carbide tool, and it polished up like glass. :b

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#5

Re: No!

Woodmangler

I'll send ya a chunk Don!

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#6

I've encountered some hard woods, but

Mike Foster

I've always been able to turn them. Some require frequent trips to the sharpener and scraping often does better with them. The three woods that come to mind are 1) goldfield burr (It is a eucalyptus from AU that has many cousins) 2) Desert ironwood (fine powdery, nasty dust from turning with hardly any shavings) 3) a burl I bought from another crafter who told me it is elder burl. This is NOT box elder burl. It has gorgeous figure once turned and finished, but is like rock to turn. First time I turned it I thought I had lost my touch, or was not getting a good edge on the tools. Like your wood, I found that it not only turned difficult, but sanding took forever as well. Results are worth the effort with it. I would suspect that this wood was fine to turn when wet, but like your oak, turned to rock once dry. I would consider if the look of the wood once completed is worth the effort. The woods I have mentioned here were worth it.

Mike

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#7

Desert Ironwood is pretty tough ...

Jim Sebring

I destroyed a 1/2 inch bandsaw blade while cutting up some knife scale scraps a friend gave me. I did manage to make a (one!) very nice Sierra pen I decided to keep.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#8

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

Jeff Rich

I have turned a few pieces of honey locust and black locust near stream beads that were nearly impossible.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#9

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

Jorge Casta�eda

I had some Osage orange, black locust, elm-crete and very recently bird's eye rock maple that took lots of determination, many trips to the grinder and I almost resorted to profanity but eventually the pieces got done.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

Steve Kubien

I think anything can be turned. Heck, ask the Aussies. Insane stuff growing down there. Having said that, the worst in my opinion are birdseye maple and white oak. I know there are lots of things harder than them (even in my own shop). Something about them...

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#11

Dick Hines

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

Dick Hines

Osage orange after it has been sitting in a friends barn for 10-12 years. I gave it to a "friend" to make a bow. He never did get back with me. Maybe he is not my friend any more.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#12

Betty Scarpino

Re: Black locust

Betty Scarpino

I'll second the black locust and it wasn't even growing near a stream!

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#13

Steven Antonucci

Too hard?  Nah.  Not worth the effort?  Maybe...

steven antonucci

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#14

Reply from quercus country

Mike Jones in Redding Ca.

In my area there are so many oak species I can't list them all...and I have turned a bit of most of it. Also having turned ironwood from baja, manzanita, and tan oak (which isn't an oak) I can tell you that white oak is seldom worth the effort unless it is a true burl, and then, only while still green.

Someting about the way that the grain twists (or something) make for side-grain turning that acts like end-grain turning, and an abundance of fine particulate dust with little chips and virtually no shavings.

It's not too hard to turn...but like Steve says...time spent on other wood is likely to produce a more satisfying result.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#15

Steven Antonucci

I have a lifetime supply of White Oak for you!

steven antonucci

turn it once a year, just to remind myself that there are woods not worth the effort. Chips and dust, almost hot enough to ignite...

S

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#16

Yep, sorta *LINK*

mike hamilton

On the trip to Arizona that netted me the current sighting photo and a wonderful visit with Carol Reed, I encountered this in a national park.

Geez, I can't recommend vacations strongly enough!

Mike


Petrified Forest

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#17

Steve Kubien

Re: I have a lifetime supply of White Oak for you!

Steve Kubien

The hot dust is one of several reason I hate the stuff (the others have been mentioned). Japanese white oak isn't like that. At least, the small amount I've turned isn't like that. What they call white oak (shiro kashi) is actually an evergreen tree.

Steve, white oak is perfect if you are going to carve bokken.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

Keith Tompkins

I have a piece of greenheart that someone gave me...he couldn't turn it. I'll have to try it out.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#19

You got us Mike

Mike Foster

I didn't think of that. My mom, who lives in Colorado, has a 3 ft section of petrified log that my grandfather got back in the 50's. He was an avid rock collector and taking some home wasn't frowned on then.

I wonder if someone like Max Krimmel hasn't thought of chucking a piece up?

Mike

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#20

Re: Black locust

Doug Trembath

I'll go along with Jeff and Betty on Black Locust, and Honey Locust as well, but BOTH exhibit some incredible visual effects when turned. The highlights and chattoyance of the BL are as pretty as I have seen over the years (especially if there's burl involved), and the creamy, marble-like consistency of the HL, along with the luscious colors, make both of these woods some of my all time favorites.

They are tough to turn, but who ever told us this would all be easy? ;>)

Doug Trembath

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#21

Steven Antonucci

My son found out the "hard way"

steven antonucci

His small Greek sword is made out of cherry (because the scrap was the right size). My smaller sons both have katanas made out of white oak. They were "dueling" and one of the boys struck my older sons cherry sword... it is now serrated...

It's all fun and games until someone loses an eye...

S

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#22

Steven Antonucci

Lines have been drawn!

steven antonucci

One of my buddies just got a whole bunch of black locust and is saving some of it for me. I will have to see firsthand if it's as bad as you all say it is...

S

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#23

There's no actual wood in petrified wood

charlie belden

It's all been replaced by minerals. The fact that that is possible is pretty amazing.

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#24

Re: Lines have been drawn!

fgvanatta

I've turned a lot of black locust and I like it. Anyone who thinks it's too hard to turn just package it up and send it to me. :D

Frank

Re: Is there wood that is too hard to turn?

#25

Re: My son found out the "hard way"

R Payne

> It's all fun and games until someone loses an eye...

then it becomes a game of find the eyeball.

ron