I made this hollowform and ended up just buffing it... all the sanding in the world was not going to get those little pits in the wood out... this was pretty soft as you can tell.
Looks like Silver Maple(soft maple). It takes very light finishing cuts with a freshly sharpened tool. . Sometimes if it is very punky , you can stiffen the fibers with thinned lacquer before the finish cuts. Another way is to soak the entire piece in a 50% white glue & water solution for 24 hours, let dry and then finish turn. You can usually, but not always, get nice piece by one of these methods. Nice shape!
Some people will also coat the whole thing with CA glue before the final cut(s). You have to use good technique all along the way, or the tearout will be so deep that it will take multiple "final" cuts to get rid of it. ...Gary
Steve Sherman showed me a two part mixture that he used successfully to treat some very punky spalted wood, but I don't remember what it was. Perhaps if you posted the pic on WoW and asked for his comment directly he could tell you. It did a great job.
Spalted wood will suck up sanding sealer, or first coat of finishing product. Should do some light sanding with 320-grit or finer to get rid of raised grain or even out first application. Not sure will see much of a build with more application of sanding sealer, do not worry apply finishing material.
You can make your own or buy shellac-sanding sealer. Or buy Deft lacquer sanding sealer in a can. You must lightly sand after application before putting on final coats of either shellac or lacquer. Light sanding between coats of Shellac or Lacquer only required if have picked up dust. Shellac and lacquer finishes look great after rubbed out.
Even easier application without a sanding sealer might be Oil-Varnish blends like Mini-Wax Tung Oil Varnish, Watco, or Deft Danish Oils. Wiping Varnish products like Formby�s Tung Oil. Both Oil-Varnish Blends and Wiping Varnish require apply, wait, wipe off excess, wait to dry before re-applying additional coats. Have to pay attention to drying times if do not want a tacky/sticky surface.
EVerything mentioned above works. However if you turned the final passes before trying these things you might have already pulled out some fibers. I try using a cabinet scraper. You can remove the spots without leaving the uneven areas that sandpaper will. If they go very deep even that won't work because you leave a large depression.
If the holes are too deep to sand out or scrape out without creating dips in the wood then your stuck with filling them. I usually just use thin or medium CA for small ones. For larger ones I'll sand lightly so the sanding dust fills the pores and then use either thin CA or thinned lacquer.to set these areas. The CA will often run and leave streaks you can't get out so I prefer the lacquer. It's helpful if you apply a coat of finish or two before you try filling. Then the CA won't penetrate as it runs. Since I use lacquer as a finish on these any run of the lacquer won't cause problems because it will blend or can be sanded flat.
When filling the pores this way they often show but at least the finish is smooth and glossy over them so most people don't notice.
I have had a lot of this type of maple come through my shop, and I have determined that the best way to handle it is to make my finish cut with a skew and then hand sand with the grain. The tearout is minimal, and the only issues I usually face are in blending the transition point where you cut L-R vs R-L and up around the collar, where I just don't have the skills to make that cove with a skew consistently.
The lacquer, sanding sealer,, shellac and white wood glue will work, up to a point. One problem with a piece as punky as this is that it will soak up so much of the fluid that it will stay damp for ages (yes, even with lacquer). White wood glue can take weeks to dry. (Don't ask how I know this!)
The best and easiest solution is a product called Polyall 2000. It is a 2-part polyurethane liquid thinner than water. It will soak about a quarter of an inch into wood like this vase. It hardens in three minutes, so you can continue your turning almost uninterupted by drying times. It leaves a finish similar to an oil finish. Put on a bit too much, and you will get a milky looking finish. This is fine, as you can easily sheer cut or sheer scrape this off, getting the last bits of tearout with this final pass of the tool.
It looks and reacts much like the epoxy used in fiberglass. What you are doing is turning the vase into a plastic item, replacing the glass fiber in fiberglass with the wood fiber in the boiwl.
I have no connection with the company. I am just a very satisfied user. I have been finishing a ,lot of redwood and punky burl this year and this i has been a godsend. The company website is at: http://www.polyall.com/
Re: Not for the faint of heart: Final cut with a s
Keith Tompkins
I agree, Steve. The skew isn't really designed to cut coves..it CAN be done, but a close inspection shows a series of small flats, rather than a continuous curve. I hone, then power-hone the edge to a mirror finish on a swept-back spindle gouge for the neck and take tissue-paper thin cuts.
Lot of respected names coming up with solutions, but no mention with Minwax woodhardener! I've been turning out a bunch of spalted maple bowls with a bunch of punky areas and associated tearout. I liberally douche it with the woodhardener and it turns fine. Discovered though if you put on a ready to sand item, it clogs the paper up something fierce. At least at first in the course grits. Now I hit it just after getting the item round and before the finishing cuts. Only takes a couple of hours to dry according to the instructions, but I often push that, especially on touchups. Bit more expensive than I like, but better than tossing the item and I'm very happy with the quality.
Polyall states that because of its thin consistency it can be well loaded with fillers. Maybe this would work for your cupcake icing???
Bill Neddow will give you the operational answer for shelf-life but I did see a document by turner Hermen de Vries that said after a year it was still good - he carefully cleans and replaces the correct cap on the bottle (he marks the cap). Being a 2-part system a reasonable shelf life might be expected.
I know that if has any thickness, it is an opaque yellow, when used in this manner (of hardening the wood) do you have any issues with optical clarity?
Yes it has a yellowish color if it is thick and there is no wood fiber. That is why I sheer cut or scrape to get rid of the tear-out where this occurs. When it is surrounded by wood fiber, you cannot tell that it is in the wood. The wood looks like it would with a oil finish. I put an oil finish over it just to make sure everything is protected and it does not change the color at all. Once in a while, after the sheer cutting, there is a little pinhole of the yellow left where the tearout was deep, or there was a large gap. A touch with a black felt pen turns this into an instant spalt spot.
To avoid the yellow spots in pin holes, I fill any badly torn areas with CA glue and coffee grounds. Instant bark!
John, I know it last for over a year. I "lost" a package of it in the spare fridge (in the bottom at the back) and it was there for at least that long. I keep it in the fridge in the hopes that it will slow down any chemical reaction as it does with CA glue. I have no proof that it works, but as long as the stuff does not harden prematurely on me, I will keep putting it in the fridge between uses.
I know it is not cheap. But, a little goes a long way. Mix about half what you think you will need. If you need more, the mixing only takes a few seconds.
I generally take the bowl to be treated off the lathe (still in its chuck) and lay it flat before treatment. That way, you have gravity on your side and you spill less. I pour the mixed liquid on the bowl and swish it around with a disposable paint brush, shoving it into areas where the wood still appears dry. Remember, you only have three minutes to "play".
Is it expensive in the long run? No -- if you are buying wood. I have a piece of Redwood on the lathe at the moment that is very beautiful, very full of bird's eyes, and very full of dry rot. I have used a little less than two cups of Polyall to stabilize everything. That's about $15. I now have a $400 bowl to sell. If I had not used the Polyall, the wood would have gone in the garbage.
Yes Bill, that's the stuff Steve used on the punky nested set he did. It did a fabulous job strengthening the rotted wood. Expensive, but it would be worth it if the wood is that good.
This seems like another good solution to the problem. I have had no experience with it, but it is a resin and is NOT water based. Therefore, it should work, as your experience indicates. I have had terrible luck with the water-based hardeners. I don't think they ever completely dry -- at least, not in a time frame impatient woodturners would like. I have had pieces treated with the water based stuff sit for days curing. Then I put them on the lathe. After the first cut took the hardened surface off, I got showered with sticky goo.
Well, Dave, it must work a LOT better in Alaska than it did for me in California or Pennsylvania... That's a good thing, as it seems to be working for you.
I tried it a few times, and it just ended up being a sticky mess. Maybe I doused it a little TOO "liberally"
I just take my time, sharpen up real well, and make fine finishing cuts, sand very little, and hope for no low spots.
I've used it many times on various woods with good results. I do find it's best to let it harden over night.
The primary solvent in it appears to be acetone and it may just be some form of lacquer or simply PVC. I pour what I'll need in a jar and when done, close it up. I set the brush on top of the jar and let it harden. I often come back to find the contents of the jar evaporated down, adding more or some acetone redissolves it. The hardened brush is usable again about 2 minutes after putting it in the solution.
You do need to take light cuts and avoid generating any heat as it will melt and make a sticky mess on the end of your gouge.
..is the metal can, which I have refilled hundreds of times with lacquer thinned with a bit of acetone. That is my magic potion used for everything from wood hardener to wiping finish.
I was in the hardware store today and checked the can. Now I remember it. I bought some a couple of years ago to repair a window sill. I was out of Polyall. I soaked the Minwax product into the punky spot and waited for it to harden. Three weeks later it was still gummy, so I tore the rotten sill out and replaced it -- and ordered some more Polyall.